BRAVO SALVA: A New Impetus to the Talks in Ethiopia

    Article
    Comments (17)

email Email
print Print
pdfSave
separation
increase
decrease
separation
separation

By Luka Biong Deng

Originally published by the New Nation Newspaper, 29th July, Addis
Ababa, Ethiopia

The talks between Sudan and South Sudan over the pending issues of
oil, border, status of nationals and the final status of Abyei are now
at critical stage as the clock of the time-bound of United Nation
Security Council and African Union to conclude these talks by 2nd
August is ticking. The parties lost most of their time over
demilitarized zone and the map provided by the African Union Panel for
this zone and as the basis for security arrangements for the cessation
of hostilities. In fact Sudan was so unreasonable for not accepting
the proposed map for the demilitarized zone but failed as well to
provide alternative map as its suggestion of adopting the existed
boundaries during interim period of CPA was baseless. Almost the talks
came to standstill because of arrogance of the regime in Khartoum and
its rejection to the proposed map by the Panel. When I was in Addis
one diplomat confided to me how the international observers were
furious and frustrated by the conduct of the negotiating team of the
Sudan.

The non-compliance of Khartoum with the Roadmap became ever clearer
during the recent meeting of the African Union Peace and Security in
Addis when President Bashir, in his statement to the Council, not only
rejected the Map but accused the African Union of imposing a flawed
map that created new disputes. On the other hand the statement of
President Salva to the Council was reconciliatory, responsible and
forward looking and reassured the Council of his acceptance of the
Roadmap and compliance with the UN Resolution 2046. Also the
comprehensive Strategic Approach proposed by the Panel to address the
pending issues was endorsed by the South while Khartoum came instead
with a matrix for discussing the pending issues with a clear aim of
diluting the Roadmap and its time-bound of three months.

It was clear that the Parties were heading to a dead end in
negotiations and the Panel was losing patience in reaching win-win and
voluntary solutions to the pending issues. President Salva and with
backing from the SPLM Political Bureau decided to meet President
Bashir during the AU Summit without the presence of the Panel and
international observers. He was not only bold and strategic in his
move to meet with Bashir but he shocked Bashir and international
community as he put on the table specific suggestions on how to move
forward with the negotiations. This timely and forward-looking
leadership provided by President Salva to normalize relations between
the two countries brought new impetus and hope for the talks in
Ethiopia. One diplomat told me that the move of President Salva has
not only surprised the international community but has revealed the
hidden qualities of his style of leadership.

This move was welcomed by all including President Bashir who indicated
that he would take two steps for every step taken by President Salva
towards normalization of the relations between the two countries.
However, the Sudanese negotiation team totally misinterpreted the good
intention of President Salva. They came to the conclusion that this
move clearly showed the South is so desperate and its economy will
collapse probably next August when its remaining foreign reserves will
allegedly be exhausted. One is not surprise that the current head of
negotiation team of Sudan is not any other person but the very person
who believes in military and security approach to normalization of
relations between the two countries. He is also believed to be the
person who provoked the tension along the border and dragged the South
into unplanned war over Panthou so as to fail the planned summit in
Juba between Bashir and Salva. With humiliating defeat of the Sudan
Armed Forces in Panhou, there has been strong demand within the NCP
and Parliament for his dismissal as Minister of Defence. Again, the
Government of Sudan is represented by weak and politically vulnerable
head of the negotiation team and above all he is indicted by the
International Criminal Court over the gross human rights violations,
ethnic cleansing, war crimes and crimes against humanity committed in
Darfur.

Besides this strategic move of President Salva, the negotiating team
of the South came up with a forward and comprehensive approach titled
“The Agreement on Friendly Relations and Cooperation”. This framework
is a turning point in the negotiation and put the talks on the path of
reaching final and amicable solutions. I felt at a certain point that
the South might have given much more in this proposal and beyond the
expectations. However, I reflected on the wisdom I came across from
the writings of Prof Eric Reeves that “You may either win your peace
or buy it: win it, by resistance to evil; buy it, by compromise with
evil”. Although the regime in Khartoum may not be described as evil
but the way it has been treating its own people and its neighbours,
particularly the South may qualify it to be at a certain level of
evil. We hope with such generous move by the South that the regime in
Khartoum will have incentive to alleviate itself from the status of
evil to status of righteous and virtuous. But the real question is
whether the regime in Khartoum is ready to accept the offer of
friendship and cooperation by the South?

On oil and other payments, the South offered about $3 billion towards
meeting almost one-third of the financial gap faced by Sudan after
secession. Equally, the South is ready to forgive all arrears and
claims against Khartoum that is about $5 billion. Besides these
offers, the South will contribute with about $5 billion towards debt
forgiveness as well as working jointly for the debt relief,
development assistance and lifting of economic sanctions. Also the
South offers to increase transportation and process fees by 7% while
maintaining transit fees at international level. What an offer! There
is no any return to the South except friendship, cooperation and
peace. In response to the offer of the South on oil, the regime in
Khartoum out-rightly rejected the offer and suggested instead
transportation tariff of $21.8 per barrel compared with the offer of
the South of average of $6.5 per barrel. Also Sudan suggested a
transit fee of $6 and processing fee of $4.4 per barrel compared
respectively with international fees of $0.65 and $1 offered by the
South. Sudan is unreasonably offering total fee of $32.2 per barrel
which is about four times higher than the international practices and
almost 40% of the average oil price per barrel.

On Abyei, the South maintains its position of the conduct of the
referendum by a commission consisting of equal members from each state
and with a neutral chair to be appointed by the African Union and with
eligibility exclusively for the Ngok Dinka and other residents in the
area except nomads. The Sudan, however, is reluctant to the conduct of
the referendum as it might lead to loosing Abyei to the South and
decided to explore instead with the Panel other options of maintaining
the entire area of Abyei in the Sudan or partitioning it between the
two states. Khartoum also does not entertain any attempt for the
referendum to be conducted by African Union or a referendum commission
to be headed by a neutral person.

On the borders and security along the border, the South accepted the
map provided by the Panel as the basis for demilitarizing the buffer
zone and cessation of hostilities. The South proposes to resort to
regional or international arbitration as the basis for resolving
amicably the remaining outstanding contested border areas. The South
and particularly President Salva is keen as well to assist Bashir if
Khartoum could initiate talks with SPLM-N and to accept the framework
agreement on partnership between NCP and SPLM-N. The Sudan, however,
has not only rejected the map provided by the Panel but insisted on
the endorsement and use of 1/1/1956 map that was used during the
interim period of CPA. It also demands the South to withdraw its
forces from areas that it currently occupies allegedly north of
1/1/1956 border line. The Sudan negotiating team in Addis also
rejected not only talks with SPLM-N and the framework agreement on
partnership but also insisted on delivering humanitarian assistance to
the two states through their organizations.

Given the huge gap between the negotiating positions of the Parties,
the last opportunity rests now with the two Presidents of the two
states. It seems that they both have a political chemistry of
understanding each other, especially after the courageous move of
President Salva to break the ice. The scheduled summit between the two
Presidents in Addis on 31st July is expected to yield concrete results
of concluding comprehensive agreement on the outstanding issues. One
would expect that the Panel to put forward options from which the two
Presidents could take bold and final decisions. On oil and other
payments, one would expect the Panel to adopt the proposals put
forward by the South and with window of flexibility in areas of
transit fee and possibly transitional financial assistance. On the
border, the Panel may need to adopt dialogue and arbitration as basis
for resolving amicably the contested border areas and to adopt its map
for demilitarization of buffer zone. On Abyei, the Panel may need to
put forward the conduct of referendum by a commission chaired by a
neutral person to be appointed by the AU/UN and with equal members
from both states and eligibility exclusively for the Ngok Dinka and
other residents in the area except nomads. The Panel may need to
suggest a package of how to mitigate the negative consequences that
may be experienced by Sudan and nomads if the people of Abyei area
opted to join the South as the most likely outcome of the referendum.

I would like to congratulate President Salva for his leadership and
courage during this difficult time of building our new nation and
normalizing relation with the most difficult neighbour, the Sudan. One
should also congratulate our negotiation team headed by Comrade Pagan
in Ethiopia as they have not only outperformed the team of Sudan but
have shown to the world that the newest nation is indeed a responsible
member state of the United Nation and is keen to promote peace and
stability not only with Sudan but also with all its neighbours. We
should encourage and support our President and the negotiations team
to take bold and far-sighted decisions that will bring peace,
stability and prosperity to our new nation. Our nation has a bright
future and any sacrifice today by the people of the South for a better
future is worth taking. We are dealing with a desperate and reckless
regime in Khartoum that has no hope in the future but a neighbour that
we cannot change except through good relations. This puts the
leadership of the South on higher moral ground to look far ahead in
creating a prosperous and peaceful future with friendly cooperation
and good relations with the Sudan.

Luka Biong Deng is a senior member of the Sudan People’s Liberation
Movement (SPLM) the ruling party of South Sudan. He is currently
serving as the Co-Chair of the Abyei Joint Oversight Committee on
appointment of South Sudan President Salva Kiir. He can be reached at
[email protected].


The views expressed in the 'Comment and Analysis' section are solely
the opinions of the writers. The veracity of any claims made are the
responsibility of the author not Sudan Tribune.

If you want to submit an opinion piece or an analysis please email it
to [email protected]

Sudan Tribune reserves the right to edit articles before publication.
Please include your full name, relevant personal information and
political affiliations.

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.


Reply via email to