Kenya moves on? from ICC to Lupita Nyong'o - By Magnus Taylor Posted on March 12, 2014<http://africanarguments.org/2014/03/12/kenya-a-year-on-looking-for-a-plan-beyond-the-icc-by-magnus-taylor/>by AfricanArgumentsEditor<http://africanarguments.org/author/africanargumentseditor/>
William Ruto and Uhuru Kenyatta on campaign material from the 2013 election. I went on the Daily Nation (Kenya's biggest newspaper) website today and one of the 'Hot Topics' at the top of the homepage was 'Lupita Nyong'o' - the Kenyan winner of this year's 'Best Supporting Actress' Oscar for her role as Patsy in Steve McQueen's 'Twelve Years A Slave'. In the last few days you can read the following articles: *9th March:* Lupita's gown stole the show *7th March:* 10 things you may not know about Lupita's brother *6th March:* Lupita lip balm sold out In Kenya, as with much of the world, Lupita is hot property. And in Kenya people know how to say her name<http://africasacountry.com/how-to-say-lupita-nyongo/> . I arrived in Nairobi, a year since my last visit, the day after the inaugural First Lady's Half Marathon; a charitable event organised in the name of Margret Kenyatta, who in baseball cap and jogging bottoms, appeared more soccer mom than Lady Macbeth. The President, still (just about) under indictment from the International Criminal Court (ICC), looks like a half marathon or two would do him good - but then it must be stressful coordinating most of your country's government to keep you out of the clutches of international justice. Ironically, I remember Kenyatta argued during the pre-election presidential debates last year that this was entirely "a personal matter". Nairobi certainly has shinier buildings and better roads than when I first came here in 2008 - even my taxi driver has a nicely printed business card which lists him as 'Company Director'. The 2013 election was also massively less traumatic than the violent ethnicised clashes of 07/08. But there is another Kenya away from the reflected glitz of Lupita Nyong'os lip balm or Margret Kenyatta's Michelle Obama impression. Over the past few months I have interviewed 3 prominent members of the Kenyan civil society community (the most recent being Gladwell Otieno of Africog) - a set of individuals for whom the word 'disillusioned' might have been invented. First, John Githongo<http://africanarguments.org/2013/12/03/interview-john-githongo-kenya-incs-software-downgrade/>, Head of the Inuka Trust, stated that "It would appear to be the government's intention to not only roll back hard won freedoms, but to recreate Kenya into the Cold War condition of fear and repression". For Muthoni Wanyeki<http://africanarguments.org/2013/11/26/interview-muthoni-wanyeki-in-kenya-this-is-not-a-time-when-moderates-are-carrying-the-day/>, former director of the Kenyan Human Rights Commission (KHRC), the Supreme Court judgement, which dismissed petitions made by civil society on the electoral commission's handling of the polls, "called into question everything we'd worked on for five years: what didn't we do in terms of electoral reform? What didn't we push for? What didn't we do in terms of judicial reform?" Otieno expresses a similar sentiment: "Frankly, I think many of us [civil society actors] are just exhausted, we feel like we've been banging our head against the wall". She also commented that during the elections "civil society felt very much alone in the way they [the elections] were being assessed. Clearly a year later you've got a government that seems to be quite aggressive and sensitive about criticism. It comes down to the fact that they do know that they have a legitimacy deficit." The narrative since the Supreme Court signed off the election result has been one of 'moving on'. This was pervasive during the election itself, with the 'fear of nightmares'<http://africanarguments.org/2013/03/10/kenya-2013-the-power-of-nightmares-%E2%80%93-by-magnus-taylor/>- a return to the violence of 2007/08 - being the most obvious disciplining factor for both sides. But has the political leadership of the country itself 'moved on'? It has seemed, over the past 12 months that much of Kenyan government policy, and certainly its foreign policy, has been oriented around the ICC cases. And this, along with the ever compelling draw of the favourable electoral arithmetic, was what brought Ruto and Kenyatta together as the Jubilee Alliance (in the form of the UhuRuto). The ICC cases remain the focus of this government and it seems likely that the Kenyatta case will be dropped with the Chief Prosecutor, Fatou Bensouda, admitting that she is not "currently in a position to present a case". A product, says Otieno, of Kenyatta and his supporters' use of "bribery, intimidation and murder" to prevent key witnesses testifying at The Hague. Perhaps the one area where Kenya has 'moved on' is regarding the conduct of the election itself. Of the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) - which ran the polls - Otieno said, "I don't know whether they have any more credibility than the ICK." This is saying something, as the ICK presided over the blatant rigging and hasty swearing in of Kibaki that set off the country in 2007. And according to Otieno, "there are no serious moves to discuss reform of the IEBC" despite the fact that it "crumbled on every front to the politicians" (or perhaps, because of it). Kenya is not obviously a different place from a year ago, but the conduct of government itself clearly has changed. The politically charged rhetoric of anti-westernism, attempts to curb the independence of the media and foreign funding of civil society form perhaps the most coherent 'project' of those who currently hold power. Perhaps, conversely, when the Kenyatta case is dropped by the ICC then things might improve, but as Otieno says - "What would be the main thrust of government policy without the ICC? I don't get a feeling of deep thought or deep work." When thinking about what I would write about on this trip I started by listing the biggest events that took place in Kenya over the last year. The election and Supreme Court verdict are top, the start of the ICC trials of Kenyatta and Ruto are also key, plus the formation of legislation to attack the work of journalists and those NGOs with significant foreign funding (principally those working in matters of governance). The accusations of graft over the tender for the Mombasa to Nairobi standard gauge railway construction - a project that seems to have been designed almost entirely as an opportunity for massive graft - have more recently made headlines and underlined the continuing scale of Kenya's corruption problem. Added to this list should be the country's most internationally covered event of the year - the Al Shabaab attack on the Westgate shopping centre. The building remains boarded up and spookily empty with clusters of bullet holes marking the exterior walls. What happened within seems remote and unreal - an event the like of which many had predicted, but no one was quite prepared for, particularly the Kenyan security services which both bungled the response and saw it as a misguided opportunity for the mass looting of the building. Westgate exemplifies the country's dire need for reform in many areas - notably security, intelligence and policing - but the willingness or capacity of the current government to achieve these things remains unproven. It all seems a long way from Lupita Nyong'o sweeping all before her at The Oscars, but then Kenya is often described as a country of extremes. This is just one of them. *Magnus Taylor is editor of African Arguments.* -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "South Sudan Info - The Kob" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. To post to this group, send email to [email protected]. Visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14orzWKG_P_gPKR1pwd-tNVReEodYYTnUAKSXUzqqLw2jcw%40mail.gmail.com. For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.
