South Sudan's Constitutional Crisis burst into Political Upheaval Mar. 12 Politics <http://www.southsudannation.com/category/politics/>, Uncategorized <http://www.southsudannation.com/category/uncategorized/> 3 comments<http://www.southsudannation.com/south-sudans-constitutional-crisis-burst-into-political-upheaval/#comments>
*A quotable quote on constitutionalism: "...in drafting a constitution for a new state it may be unrealistic to begin with presumptions in favour of brevity and flexibility. Often it will be politically impossible to obtain general agreement on the new constitution unless it is both lengthy and fairly rigid. Those who do not expect to find themselves in power on Independence Day may well be profoundly distrustful of the majority party and its leaders and the price of their acquiescence in the new order is therefore likely to be a somewhat constitutional machine with built-in-resistances against subsequent modifications. The principal methods of constitutional entrenchment either: (a) Interpose a period of delay before a legislative proposal for constitutional amendment can have effect, or (b) Require that bills for constitutional amendments shall be passed by special majorities in the legislature itself or combine two or more of these requirements if they are to become law, or (c) Require the concurrence of bodies other than the legislature itself or combine two or more of these requirements".(Professor Stanley Anthony de Smith)* BY: Mabor Maker Dhelbeny, JUBA, MAR/12/2014, SSN; In light of the above-mentioned quote, the amendments of Interim Constitution of Southern Sudan (ICSS), 2005 by the Southern Sudan Legislative Assembly of the then Sudan, and hereinafter adopted as 'Transitional Constitution, 2011' for the transitional government of Independence Country had experienced difficulties to reach the general agreement. However, the Transitional Constitution of South Sudan (TCSS), 2011 enacted by the SPLM with majority of its members in the deliberation have concentrated a wide range of powers to the executive (presidency) as opposed to the legislature. But Dr Machar seems was not acquiescing as he presented his draft of transitional constitution to govern the post-independent State alongside the official version in the parliament. This trick might have depressed President Kiir in which he has been quoted as saying: "there is no country that can be run by more than one government." Taking into account, Art 101 of TCSS empowered the President with the 21 clauses, starting from (a)-to-(u) compare to Art. 105 with the only 4 clauses from (a)-to-(d) of the Vice President's functions have completely cast the shadow of doubt to all the constitutional makers. The Republic of South Sudan has more than one hundred legislations but due to lack of implementation as many culprits commit the crimes with impunity have raised a major concern. It seems that South Sudanese lawyers or both law makers, law implementers and law interpreters did something less about their laws. For example, take the case of corruption and Dura saga where some kleptocrats with motives have misappropriated public funds to their private ends without facing justice. Is it because these kleptocrats who misappropriated public funds have some reasons to suppress public exposure and criticism which come from their colleagues, opposition politicians, media groups, civil societies and citizens? Of course such suppression of criticism may take form of detention if not extermination of political opponents. This aspect of socio-political phenomenon which is known as corruption in the government has never been addressed since Anti-corruption Commission was teething. Subsequently, the kleptocrats may therefore seek any means to remain in office for fear of post incumbency prosecution or loss the privileges of office regardless of the existing laws in this country. But any popular move to oust them from power even by constitutional means may result in further violence and human rights abuses. This is what happened in South Sudan when the President had responded positively to the public outcry to reshuffle the whole cabinet in July last year, followed by the formation of a lean cabinet, not government. This demonstrates that South Sudanese people seem to thrive on the sleaze perpetuated by their politicians. If the current carnage goes on like this, then it'll make all adult males to be liable for conscription in order to resist the insurgency waged by the SPLA/M-In Opposition. The choice of reforming the Sudan's People Liberation Movement (SPLM) is confounding. Let's not encourage nor condone violence for the violence solves no problem but it causes destruction. So as a youth of this country, you must have dedication and sense of responsibility of a nation building and disengage from disgruntled politician's ideologies. Don't just gulp everything down without masticating it. Even eating a food, you need to chew it first before swallow. So this crisis needs analytical approach. However, if the truth is the basis of the epigram, then there's no need of shying away from it. CONSTITUTIONAL CRISIS Democratically, one of the rationales of the Constitution is to prevent the government from abusing its powers over the people of this nation. However, the government of South Sudan is supposed to promote good governance and welfare of the people irrespective of their race, color, creed, religious or gender. The recent case between the former S.G of the SPLM, Pagan Amum against Arthur Akuen, former minister of finance & economic planning have shown that South Sudan judicial system lacks impartiality by democratic standards. Again the dismissal of Pagan's case filed against the government by the Supreme Court in regards to restricting his freedom of movement further infringed the fundamental rights embodied in article 27 clauses (1) & (2) of the said Constitution. This has been established in the case of Joseph A. Garang & Others v the Supreme Commission & others (HC-CS-93-1965) SLJR. In this Sudanese Constitutional case, the plaintiffs contended that such amendments were unconstitutional because they infringed the fundamental rights embodied in article (2) of the Constitution. Moreover, in one of the Indian first constitutional cases namely; Gopolan v State of Madras (1950) A.I.R.S.C.27, in which it was pointed out that "in India it is the Constitution that is the Supreme, and that a statute law to be valid must in all cases be in conformity with the constitutional requirements and it is for the judiciary to decide whether any enactment is constitutional or not." This has raised a fundamental question as such: Is it because the model of judiciary's prosecution has been centralized in order to administer justice as opposed to political decentralization system? Some judges are still writing their judgments in Arabic language, contrary to what article 6, clause (2) of TCSS, stipulated as it reads: "English shall be the official working language in the Republic of South Sudan, as well as the language of instruction at all level of educations". While all the laws were in form of English text, I don't know how they cited them. Is it not a clear violation of the constitution from the law interpreters? Probably lack of judges and unfair recruitment of judicial assistants demonstrate that the judiciary organ might be incapacitated and can't adjudicate on political disputes. Although Act No.4 s. 26 (1) of the Judiciary Act, 2008 entails that "the appointment of judicial assistants shall be by way of selection or if the judicial assistant is in the possession of - good performance or a certificate of post-graduate in law". Hence the word 'selection' is not enough but it may mean 'hand-pick' to mollycoddle the candidate. Consequently, the situation in which a separate factions or disputants within the members of the SPLM-led government disagree over the interpretation of certain provisions in the TCSS, 2011 or the SPLM constitution or about the extent to which each other factions hold the affairs of sovereignty has resulted to the constitutional crisis that have now burst into the political upheaval. On January the 21st 2013, President Kiir had relieved the Lakes State's Governor Eng. Chol Tong Mayay from his duties due to the cycle of vengeance or sectional violence in Rumbek, citing Art 101, clause (r) of TCSS, 2011 which stipulated that 'the President shall remove a state Governor...in the event of a crisis in the state that threatens national security and territorial integrity'. Something that Chol's aides refuted to have been politically motivated. It's thus prompted Dr Riek to react negatively by writing a letter on March 13th 2013 to his Boss that, "I believe the main issue is the status of caretaker Governor. I think your comradeship will either relieve him and reappoint him or re-instate the elected governor Chol Tong Mayay to avoid the looming constitutional crisis." Subsequently Taban Deng Gai of Unity State who was the second elected Governor after Chol of Lakes State had also been relieved by the Presidential decree on July the 7th, 2013 without a clear reason. At this juncture, the politicking of governors' removal becomes extremely intense in which some of the political observers described that Kiir's action would aggravate the prevailing state of insecurity in the country that may lead to political instability. Critically, the President had appointed the two states caretaker governors of Lakes and Unity in accordance with the implementation of Art 101 clause (s) but partially violated it due to the absence of elections within 60 days in these two states where governors have been removed thereof. The same thing had occurred within the National Legislative Assembly where some MPs' posts fell vacant. But according to Art 64(2), by elections would have been held by the National Elections Commission (NEC) to fill the vacancies within 60 days following the vacancy's occurrence. Ambiguously Art 62 (1) (d) says that 'a candidate for membership of the National Legislature shall be literate'. This sub-clause (d) is vague because knowing how to read and write does not qualify a candidate to be an MP, unless certain level such as form four leaver or its equivalent must be included in the next text of permanent constitution. A primary two or three pupil can read and write, but does it mean he/she can comprehend the business of conduct or parliamentarians' hot debate. That's why some Mps do not even raise a motion or else pave the way of voting over the debated topic whether against it or in favor of it due to lack of knowledge. For many months, Dr Riek had been at loggerheads with President Kiir over running the government affairs but unfortunately the long-time VP got himself sacked by the President according to Art 104 (2) which specifically allows him to remove the Vice President and appoint the replacement. While during the whole cabinet reshuffle of July last year, Art 112 (1) reads together with Art 117 (1) grant the President to appoint and remove both ministers and deputy ministers of national government respectively. Less than four months after the cabinet reshuffled, the former deputy and his groups held a press conference in disguise of the SPLM reform but later turned into a catastrophe. In this case, many analysts blame both Kiir and Riek for the ongoing strife that have totally raged and devastated the Greater Upper Nile beyond repair. Many officials question the legality of their removal from power to have been illegitimate by the President, under the Transitional Constitution, not knowing that Act No. 1 section 38 (1) of Interpretation of Laws & General Provisions Act, 2006 stipulates that "where a written law confers or imposes upon a person the power or duty to make an appointment...unless a contrary intention appears, the person having that power or duty shall also have the power to remove, suspend, dismiss or revoke the appointment of, and to reappoint or reinstate a person appointed in the exercise or duty or to revoke the appointment, constitution or establishment of, or dissolve a board, commission, committee or similar body...". So President Kiir deserves to remove, suspend, appoint or dismiss any government official if necessary according to Transitional Constitution in conformity with South Sudan existing laws. In mid February of last year, a series of decrees were issued by President Kiir to reshuffle the national armed forces (SPLA) in which he fired more than 100 top senior commanders including deputies to the Chief of General staff, in accordance with Art 153 (2) of TCSS, 2011read together with the Act No.1 s.13 (b) of SPLA Act, 2009 which says that "the President & Commander-in-Chief shall commission, promote, retire or dismiss officers of the SPLA". Such move which sparked public fear in Juba was to transform the SPLA army. RECOMMENDATIONS AND CONCLUSION * There is need for both South Sudanese politicians and citizens to adopt the politics of accommodation and compromise in the sense that genuine consensus must be reached first within and between other political parties. But in cases where strong factions have emerged within the ruling party just like the SPLM-In Opposition to challenge the leadership from basically idiosyncratic system, there should be an application of conciliation. * Sustainability of good governance in order to strengthen the institutions that will fight against corruption, through capacity building must be in requirement of political will. Since corruption disrupts and confuses the adequate needs of populace, therefore strong laws on corruption must be enacted followed by an apparent strategy of implementation. Because lack of implementation has killed South Sudan. * The formation of South Sudan Inquiry Commission and Hybrid Tribunal will leave no room for war criminals in a democratic society. Those who will be found guilty with heinous crimes will be penalized as perpetrators and therefore denied a life in the new political order as well as exclusivity from the future building of this a new nation. * Because the significance of elections are to obscure the toughest task of nation building and discarding of incompetence politicians, thus the government of the Republic of South Sudan must re-schedule elections due to be held in 2015 to 2017 in order to allow the formation of interim government for two years in reception of peace and reconciliation. * For the SPLA to be a national and professional army, recruitment into it would be based on educational qualification as a merit. Demobilization of inactive soldiers must be encouraged instead of mobilization and therefore train the demobilized soldiers with farming, welding, carpentry, masonry and other activities of livelihood. One would borrow the argument of Professor Taban Lo Lylong that if the army is now for all to join then why not allot 1/3 to Greater Bahr El Ghazal; 1/3 to Greater Upper Nile and 1/3 to Greater Equatoria as the Anyanya government did, (Juba Monitor, Monday, March, 3, 2014 Vol.4 Issue No.37 pg.5). To me the allotment should be traced back from the origin of struggle by the old soldiers of the SPLA, ranging from the period of 1983-to-2005; then followed by those who have joined the army recently but with the exclusion of militias. * Republican guards of Tiger battalion must be recruited or selected from the army as educated soldiers, well trained, well disciplined, well equipped, well dressed, well oriented and etc who hailed from all 64 tribes of South Sudan in accordance with s. 6 (e) of the SPLA Act, 2009 in which 'the SPLA shall adhere to the principles that reflect the ethnic composition of the people of South Sudan;' but Dinkas (muonyjieng) or Nuers (Naath) should not only be left to the presidential palace to guard. For this presidency belongs to all the above tribes and it should not be misperceived to have belonged to these two largest tribes only just because they are/were there to govern. * In case of any changes, the National Constitutional Review Commission (NCRC) should not leave the Constitution to a special constituent assembly and legislative body due to the following factors: First a constituent assembly's representation of many elements within south Sudanese society may prevent any group dominating the process but in writing the permanent constitution by the constituent assembly will be too expensive and cumbersome. Second the legislative body may have special interests to be protected when writing the permanent constitution which will be a major setback. Hence the NCRC should stick on their guiding principles as representatives of the constitutional members in order to fulfill the mandate of the commission, according to article 202 of TCSS, 2011. * Government must reverse the policy of appointing governors from the states where they hailed from in order to avoid tribal politics and resort back to the idea of late Dr. John Garang de Mabior in 2005 of caretaker governors he had appointed as a symbol of good governance and unity of our people. * A country like South Sudan that remains always as a divided society, either ethnically or culturally must have a constitution with the 'power-sharing model'. This model of power-sharing may take different forms ranging from federalism like the case of Ethiopia. The NCRC however will be obliged to consult the expertise in some technical areas such as devolution of powers, financial management, auditor, independence of judiciary and etc. The late hero Dr. John Garang onetime said 'Sudan is too deformed to be reformed'. Similarly the Republic of South Sudan needs to be reformed early before it is too late otherwise its will remain more deformed than the Sudan. It seems that those who had amended the Interim Constitution of Southern Sudan (ICOSS) 2005 hereinafter adopted as the 'Transitional Constitution', 2011 aimed at strengthening the Executive at the expense of the other arms of government such as the Legislature and the Judiciary. Hence, the present Executive organ has become too powerful of all knowing institutions. This however has reduced the other organs like Legislature and Judiciary as rubber-stamping authorities thus negating the rule of law which depends on the doctrine of separation of powers. The current more powers of the President enshrined in the Transitional Constitution need to be reduced in the next amendments if not discarded. This dictates in the eye of the law that the ruling elite did corrupt the constitution with the aim of consolidating their cling on power. Indeed such a scenario lends credence to the notion of John Stuart Mill's contention that power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely (1860). Conclusively, let the next permanent constitution be an essential element of nationhood. In other words, it must be an encompassing nature of a constitution that focuses on both the long and short term objectives of sustainable systems promoting human rights, accountability & transparency, leadership style, rule of law, stability and prosperity of all South Sudanese people. Yes the constitution must therefore be the only embodiment of the political values that set forth the basic rules including the procedures of good governance. Since South Sudan is a multi-party system of governance as its has more than 21 political parties, many political analysts viewed multi-partyism with a lot of skepticism. But a renowned scholar known as Giovanni Sartori (1976:258) argued that "in Africa, multiparty exists only because no part is strong enough to eliminate its counterparts that are simply on account of a situation of powerlessness of piecemeal fragmentation of power...the African lack roots in multi-partyism. Instead of multipartyism, Africans reap multiplicity and internal division." In relevance to the above quotation, the presence scenario where leaders of the same ruling party SPLM end up criticizing themselves publicly has caused a deep internal division; and the inability of other political parties with their leaders to form a coalition party would suffice. In other words, leaders from different political parties are unable to debate, discuss and clarify the national issues that concern the general public for one reason or another. Furthermore, lack or absence of strong and efficient opposition political parties in the country to keep the ruling party SPLM in its toes not to go for sleep on government businesses is a major factor. In fact the instability that South Sudanese people have witnessed thereof means that achieving certain policy of government's objectives such as health services, improvement of poor infrastructure, creation of jobs or employment, water sanitation, education, and fight against corruption etc, remains a mirage country wide. During this crisis which has mostly engulfed our country many people have commiserated with us, especially the people of Uganda, for instance the crucial role played by the UPDF in protecting Juba city from the white army belligerents in the corridors of Bor deserved to be appreciated. Although there is a considerable impatience with the slow pace of political change as IGAD's mediators are trying their best to install the deal, South Sudanese need an uneasy truce between the two warring parties. The author is a Legal Practitioner who lives in Juba. Email him at [email protected] << Older<http://www.southsudannation.com/press-statement-the-ethnic-cleansing-in-malakal-chollo-shilluk-villages-upper-nile/> Newer >><http://www.southsudannation.com/the-unmiss-additional-crisis-for-south-sudan/> 3 Comments 1. Mojwok A dENG March 13, 2014 at 11:13 am<http://www.southsudannation.com/south-sudans-constitutional-crisis-burst-into-political-upheaval/#comment-63402> The constitution to bear principle of legality and supermacy for its legitamacy must be drawon from the diversity of any human customs which respect human dignity and its humanity. But in the country like South Sudan, the constitutional norms had been brought from the laws of inhumanity, corruption, tribalism, nepotism, Nuerism and Dinkaism mostly which cuased so-called Kirr V Riak War of primitives Tribes of eating with out producing any thing----- Reply<http://www.southsudannation.com/south-sudans-constitutional-crisis-burst-into-political-upheaval/?replytocom=63402#respond> 2. Bentiu today March 13, 2014 at 11:53 am<http://www.southsudannation.com/south-sudans-constitutional-crisis-burst-into-political-upheaval/#comment-63406> dinka professionals are always full of tribalism, what are you trying to say here? why did your president kill Nuer civilians in cold blood? where will dinka go if Uganda army leave south sudan? you will see our true colors. we are not cowards and won't stop fighting until we kill 10000 dinka. Reply<http://www.southsudannation.com/south-sudans-constitutional-crisis-burst-into-political-upheaval/?replytocom=63406#respond> 3. Thonyankiir March 13, 2014 at 4:32 pm<http://www.southsudannation.com/south-sudans-constitutional-crisis-burst-into-political-upheaval/#comment-63428> thank very much Maboir. everybody out of that system are very sorry about what happen in the leadership of the SPLM political party. the two leaders Reik macher and our president Kiir they create wrong war in south sudan..all two tribs they don ,t belive counrty . Dinka belive kiir is dinka not president of country Nuer belive that Riek was send by goundeng not V p. we confueed what kind of the goverment in south sudan 8 years no change they . basic thing like schools, healthcare, clean , water , Roads, and why we fighting for 50 years with Arabs. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "South Sudan Info - The Kob" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. To post to this group, send email to [email protected]. Visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14opKCZEQYoMZgLVJxFaf%2BcO8zjJE7%3DA87_r1P8f7yCNraQ%40mail.gmail.com. For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.
