Hell and healing: Rwanda twenty years on - By Kris Berwouts
Posted on March 21, 2014 by AfricanArgumentsEditor
OrphanageRwanda
Drawing of the orphanage Yyundo, near Gisenyi, Rwanda (copy right
Jeroen Janssen).
In the early morning of April 7, 1994 all hell broke loose in Rwanda.
A few hours earlier, President Habyarimana's plane had been shot down
and crashed in the garden of his own palace. He was returning from a
regional summit in Tanzania about the implementation of the peace
agreement between the regime, based on the Hutu majority, and the
Tutsi rebels of the Rwandan Patriotic Front (RPF), who had grown up in
the Rwandan refugee camps in Uganda and had started an armed struggle
in October 1990. Habyarimana's death triggered an unprecedented
massacre of around one million Tutsis and moderate Hutus. The genocide
ended when the RPF came to power in July 1994. Two million Hutus fled
to Congo. Rwanda stabilized but the violence continued on Congolese
soil and eventually led to what later was later called The Great
African War.
The horror
Rose remembers it all too well, even though she was only six: " We
lived in Cyangugu, not far from the border with the Congo: my parents,
my little brother and I. I even have memories from the period just
before the genocide: noisy people waving machetes on the bus. And the
political assassinations. One day, one such corpse was found just in
front of our doorstep. When it became known that the President was
dead, a Tutsi neighbour came to us: "This is the end, we all are going
to die soon." Not long after that, a militia man from the Interahamwe
started to scream from behind the fence: "Be prepared, we will soon
come to do our job." "What job are you talking about?" father asked.
"Finish your friend off. And your wife too!" Because my mother was
Tutsi, my father decided to bring her as soon as possible to the
Congo. That Tutsi neighbour was slaughtered the same day. His wife as
well, but not before she was brutally raped. I was left alone with my
brother, my father didn't think it would take a long time. But then
people attacked our house too. Someone tried to slash a machete into
my head, but I parried the stroke with my arm. I was seriously injured
but we were still alive. A neighbour rescued us: "Let those kids go.
Their father is a Hutu, like us." Four days later, dad picked us up
and brought us to the Congo too. I stayed in the hospital for months.
They first wanted to amputate my arm because it was entirely inflamed.
Eventually they managed to save it. Father remained with me all the
time. When I was finally better, we returned to Bukavu and joined my
mother and my brother."
Beatha was not in Rwanda when the genocide started. She had left the
country fifteen years earlier. She was ten. Her father directed the
administration of the municipality in Gisenyi. The family was Tutsi .
"In those days, Tutsi children had hardly any access to secondary
schools. I was a good student in primary school but there was no
chance that I would have the opportunity to continue with my studies.
Because I had a physical disability, it was not obvious what to do in
life. Eventually my parents decided to send me to Belgium as an
adopted child. I went to Bruges in 1979 and became part of a Belgian
household. I kept in touch with my family in Rwanda. My mother came
over a few times and in 1989 I returned to Rwanda to celebrate my
brother's wedding. Funnily enough I still understood Kinyarwanda but I
couldn't speak it anymore. Still, I was definitely coming home. The
bond with my childhood was very strong.
A year later the war broke out. We didn't worry very much. A lot
seemed to happen, but very far away from Gisenyi. In May '92 , my
mother visited Belgium again for what turned out to be her last trip.
She stayed until September 23rd. I wanted her to seek asylum but she
refused categorically. "If I have to die, let me rather die at home."
Not that we thought there was an immediate threat, we still believed
that the war was far away. But from then onwards, I called her every
week.
In April 1994 the horror erupted. At first we managed to remain in
contact by phone. By chance, most family members were outside Rwanda
when it started. Only my mother and one of my brothers were there, and
they were hidden by the neighbours. He was the one we talked to, and
he tried to reassure us. But on May 15th he called us to say somewhat
cryptically that my mum and my brother had been brought away. I
heard he felt very uncomfortable and was choosing his words carefully.
But we understood: it was all over. He had hidden them for three
weeks, but eventually they were denounced by the house staff. Some
family members considered accusing the neighbour of complicity, but I
thought that was unfair: the man had taken huge risks, hiding Tutsis
in his house. It's been half a miracle that he has not been killed
himself.
In 1995, I returned for the second time. That was a very alienating
experience. So many people were dead. Six years before I found my
classmates whom I used to hang around with, but they now were no
longer there. When I came back to Belgium, I thought: "I'm through
with Rwanda. This was the last time."
Rose also returned in 1995: "We didn't dare to go back earlier. Daddy
was a Hutu; he had been a judge under the old regime. We were afraid
that he would be persecuted by the new leaders. And that was exactly
what happened. He spent a year in jail without being charged. Mum
fought like a lion for her husband, just as he had done for her during
the genocide. But no matter how small I was, I understood that the
Tutsi part of my family had been killed by the Hutu regime, and that a
large part of my father's family had been assassinated by the new
Tutsi regime . I lived in a world of orphans. In our household, there
were eight of them, from both mum's and dad's side. All the parents
had been killed.
I realized even then, at the age of seven, how unjust it is if one
part of the community can mourn its dead, while a huge taboo is
maintained over the dead of the other part. We were not allowed to
talk about the victims of the army, as if only the victims of the
Interahamwe had died. I grew up with that sense of injustice. The
fault line ran right through my heart."
A total makeover
I contact Marc Hoogsteyns, a Belgian independent journalist and
documentary maker. As a journalist, he covered most of the violence in
Rwanda and later in Congo from the field. He established personal
relationships with nearly the entire RPF leadership since the days
that they were rebels. Through his marriage, he has family ties within
the Tutsi community on both sides of the border. He remains an
independent observer, but he knows the developments and feelings
within that community very well and has a lot of empathy with their
perspective. Has Rwanda changed a lot, I want to know.
"The country has gone through a real metamorphosis. A total makeover,
so to speak. The basis of the culture has changed. Socially and
economically Rwanda has improved a lot. In terms of education and
health, for example, the results are spectacular. But as far as human
rights and democracy are concerned, there has been very little change.
It used to be a one-party state, and even though they do their best to
embellish it, essentially it still is."
I call Aloys Habimana. We have known each other for more than ten
years. He was one of the leading personalities in Liprodhor, perhaps
the bravest human rights organisation Rwanda has had. Several
generations of their activists had to leave the country because the
authorities reacted very strongly against their watch dogs and
criticism. Aloys left too, but he later reappeared in other places. In
New York, for example, where he held executive positions at the
headquarters of Human Rights Watch. Today he coordinates the programs
of the international human rights organisation, Front Line Defenders,
in Sub-Saharan Africa.
"Rwanda has indeed changed a lot in all these years, in the most
diverse fields. There have been a lot of positive developments. The
post-genocide leadership has been quite effective in transforming
society, but the issue has been where it placed its priorities. We
should not underestimate what a complex, nearly impossible task it is
to rehabilitate an entirely destroyed country from scratch and to
rebuild a society which is deeply traumatised. But I believe the first
priority should have been to address past grievances, the root causes
of conflict and genocidal violence. Have we solved the issue of
refugees for instance? Today, more Rwandans than ever live abroad
because they do not feel safe in Rwanda..."
Beatha also noticed the change. In 1995 she had returned from Rwanda,
determined that she would never go back. In 2011 she went anyway.
"There was a wedding. I did not want to go but they nagged me so long
that I finally ceded. Once more it was alienating. Honestly, I did not
recognize anything. The mentality and lifestyle had completely
changed. There was no place for ordinary people. Everything was so
clean. Fantastic of course, but I couldn't find the poor. So many
houses and land had been expropriated, but where did the people go?
The ordinary people apparently vanished in the decor. I felt very
uncomfortable about it. Anyway, I never regret that I went, though I
am still convinced that it was my last time. Next year there is
another wedding. I hope I will resist better to the pressure. I am not
looking forward at all to go back to Rwanda. I simply want to stay at
home."
The whole truth
"The regime is very ambiguous about the division between Hutu and
Tutsi," says Rose. "For years and years, they explained to us that
Hutu and Tutsi were categories that the Belgians had invented to
silence and divide us and to maintain their control. It became a crime
even to pronounce the words Hutu and Tutsi. They labeled you as a
divisionist. You wanted to divide the community. Or worse, you became
a nostalgic for the old regime and still adhered to the ideology of
genocide. But now they come forward with their new program Ndi
Umunyarwanda ("I am Rwandan). They want individual Hutus to ask for
forgiveness on behalf of all Hutus, and individual Tutsis to forgive
them in the name of all Tutsis. Even ministers are forced to do it. I
must admit I can't follow anymore. Do Hutu and Tutsi exist, or are
they mere inventions?"
"Programs like Ndi Umunyarwanda now and the gacaca courts before... They
all exposed one side of the story. They don't help our country to move
forward and they do not bring the people closer together. The citizens
are aware of this. I really think the community participates in these
programmes just because they are forced to; not because they believe
they can help," comments Alloys Habimana. "Whichever way you look at
it, every attempt to deal with the past which is not based on the
entire truth has no chance to succeed."
Time to bring in my last interlocutor, David Himbara. Himbara once was
one of the closest collaborators of president Kagame. He left the
regime and the country in 2010, together with other key people from
Kagame' inner circle of power, with General Faustin Kayumba Nyamwasa
as their leader. It was an awful moment for the regime. All of a
sudden the biggest threat did not come from its traditional enemies,
the armed opposition in the Congolese bush or the opposition parties
in Kigali, but from within. The regime was struggling to prevent its
own disintegration.
Since then David Himbara has lead a public life as one of the most
critical and best documented sources on Rwandan politics, but he has
never joined one of the opposition parties in the diaspora: "Under the
current regime in Rwanda reconciliation is no option, because the
climate is intoxicated. Reconciliation can only be the result of a
process in which two parties enter into a dialogue. Such dialogue
cannot exist in a paranoid North-Korean style state that is afraid of
itself.
But it is outdated to be obsessed by the Hutu - Tutsi issue. Rwanda is
a violent state, but there is a strict policy of equal opportunity
violence: we all get our fair share of the whip. Of course Hutu are
marginalized today, they are barely represented in the institutions
that govern the country. And when they are, it is not because they are
elected but because they are appointed as window dressing. But does
that make the regime a Tutsi regime? I don't think so. Kagame juggles
with individuals to mobilise the two groups against each other. It
narrowed down the state from a one party state to a one man state."
And what about the ordinary people, I want to know. "The repression
and intimidation are organized to the level of nyumbakumi, the cell of
ten households as the lowest level of government. The fault lines run
through families. For example, my father was an old school Tutsi
patriarch. I have thirty siblings. Several still live in Rwanda. Some
even do not want me to call them. They fear that I could put them in
danger. I basically want to say this: all society has vanished from
Rwanda, mistrust is complete. It has turned Rwanda into a time bomb. "
Marc Hoogsteyns is much milder in his judgment: "Rwanda is a beautiful
country with many strengths and opportunities, but at the same time it
is some kind of African version of Brave New World. People are afraid
to talk. But they live more comfortably and safely than ever before,
they enjoy high quality education and health care. They are very happy
with that. The Tutsi community stands almost entirely behind Kagame
and also most Hutu can live with it. They obviously don't like the
fact that they do not count on the political scene, but they can do
what they want in all other spheres of live. They can study and do
business etcetera. They can deal with the level of repression, because
they know that countries such as Burundi, Congo or Kenya are not the
slightest bit more democratic. Honestly, if we would have known twenty
years ago, just after the genocide, that Rwanda would achieve this in
two decades, we would have signed for it immediately."
Lessons from the past
So how should Rwandan society move forward from here, I ask Aloys
Habimana. In many ways, the country seems ready for the future, but
how to deal with the shadow the past throws over today?
"The common people on the hills and in the suburbs have found a
certain balance, a way to live with the past. For example, you see
more and more mixed marriages. Time is the best healer. When people
live in the same community for long, sharing their problems and
successes and finding common interests, they end up finding a way out.
There are opportunities that bring people together and consolidate
social ties. Churches and charity organisations are trying to create
such moments, often with some results. But the potential for violence
did not disappear, it is only kept under the surface with much
pressure and intimidation. Looking at what led to past waves of
violence, you wonder if our leaders have learned anything at all from
the past. This country went through the hell as a result of a policy
of exclusion. The elimination of political opponents and critical
voices in general. Greed. These still are important features of our
political system. As long as we do not effectively deal with them, we
will not get the risk of violence under control. The priority should
be on consolidating responsible leadership and building strong
institutions. They do not exist today. Leadership is the key issue.
It's not because you managed to silence everybody that you are
effective. Decision making is an extremely top down process and the
ordinary citizen is silenced, infantilized. It is most important that
the space for public debate is opened up so that people can air out
their grievances."
Kris Berwouts has, over the last 25 years, worked for a number of
different Belgian and international NGOs focused on building peace,
reconciliation, security and democratic processes. Until 2012, he was
the Director of EurAc, the network of European NGOs working for
advocacy on Central Africa. He now works as an independent expert on
Central Africa.
This article was first published in Dutch in Mo Magazine (March 2014)
and has been written with the support of the Pascal Decroos Fund for
Investigative Journalism.
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob.
To view this discussion on the web visit
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14orOb0LaBWPRvFofyLYTj7zdwaDG09CZjJYBKSG46%2BQS%2BQ%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.