The verdict on Somalia's new draft media law - By Annisa Omar
Posted on March 19, 2014 by AfricanArgumentsEditor      

AnnisaOmarIt is not everyday that UK Somali journalists meet in London
to discuss a law in Somalia - a country known for its lawlessness and
for being the epitome of a failed state. But this is not any law, but
a law which could potentially be a pillar for democratic progress in
Somalia.

Somalia's new draft media law has come under much criticism by Somali
journalists and international agencies such as the United Nations
Human Rights office. They argue it is vague, violates freedom of
expression and curbs freedom of press. For instance, the law
stipulates that journalists cannot release information against Somali
or 'Islamic tradition' and would be forced to disclose sources if
publications stir up public sentiments. Nor does it comprehensively
address safety and the protection of journalists.

Last year the Somali Ministry of Information opened up a public
consultation on the new draft media law following this criticism. It
was an opportunity for stakeholders within the media to give their
comments and recommendations about the new law. Consultations took
place in Somalia, Kenya and the UK, marking a serious step towards
greater transparency and collaboration with civil society by the newly
formed Somali Federal government.

There is a strong and vibrant media sector in Somalia with an avid
audience of news consumers. Somalia is arguably one of the most media
literate of African states. However, this success has been threatened
by the perpetual killing of its journalists. According to the
Committee to Protect Journalists, since 1992 over 50 Somali
journalists were reported killed, making Somalia one the most
dangerous places in the world to practice journalism.

Prior to the overthrow of the Siad Barre regime in 1991, the
government controlled all domestic publications and broadcasting
outlets. With the advent of global communication technologies, media
in Somalia grew tremendously, particularly radio and news sites. The
Somali diaspora were greatly responsible for the opening of
independently owned media stations, and to this day a quarter of radio
stations in the country are diaspora owned.

At the same time, diaspora-led media outlets headquartered in for
instance London, Amsterdam or Kenya supply media content about Somalia
to Somalia, operate in the Somali language and are very popular in
Somali cities. Such television, radio and news sites possess their own
correspondents and/or small production services  that technically may
need to operate under Somali media law.

Despite geographical distance, the diaspora have always maintained
strong political, economic and cultural links with their homeland.
They often acquire government and political party positions, use
diaspora media to exert their political and cultural influence and
send remittances worth an estimated US$2 billions or one-third of the
country's GDP.

The diaspora and their media have therefore become part of a
transnational community, and as a consequence diaspora journalists
worry the Somali government may not recognize their unique stake and
voice in Somali media reform.

The development agency 'Integrity Research and Consultancy' identified
the need for the Somali government to hear UK-Somali journalists'
recommendations about the law.  A five-week consultation entitled
'Xog-Sugan', a shortening of the phrase 'Xog saxaafadeed u heelan
garsoor aaminsan nabad', which means 'informed and accurate media that
reinforces peaceful governance' was launched in October 2013 and the
findings came out last week.

The consultation was led by Somali researchers, and involved
interviews, peer-led focus groups, video interviews and an online
forum, with a mix of veteran male and female journalists, working
journalists and young budding journalists. Some interesting
recommendations and comments were made, a few of which I will share
and comment on here.

Perhaps the most controversial aspect of the law is the stipulation
that journalists cannot publish or broadcast information against
Somali or Islamic tradition. UK Somali journalists voiced how religion
and culture guided them personally and professionally in regards to
ethical standards. For instance, in Islam one must be truthful and not
take part in bribery, so many felt that greater adherence to Islam
could positively impact the media environment. At the same time they
acknowledged that international freedom of expression and press
freedom standards should be upheld, including the right to protect
sources.

The guarantee of protection for journalists in the new law was a prime
recommendation. In 2012 alone over a dozen Somali journalists were
killed, largely without any action taken against their killers. This
includes diaspora journalists who have fled and traveled back to the
country to undertake their work permanently, or visit frequently as
correspondents. UK Somali journalists are making a clear call to end
this culture of impunity towards the killing of Somali journalists.

The need to train government actors, regional authorities and law
enforcement to better understand the role of media in development and
governance was another concern. Journalists working for government-run
media outlets are often seen as an arm of the government and thus a
target for opposition groups. Independently owned media outlets are
susceptible to producing partisan clan-based media content, and the
common acceptance of bribes in the sector creates great barriers to
ethical journalism.

However, after two decades of conflict, economic instability and
widespread poverty, such a media landscape should be expected. Veteran
Somali journalists highlighted the fact that the Somali civil war
caused the exodus of the country's prominent journalists and with them
went high ethical and journalistic standards. The journalists also
identified a need for constraints on media such as curbing hate speech
given the post-conflict environment.

Furthermore, current Somali journalists are often not professionally
qualified, and enter the field simply for paid work given the lack of
other job opportunities in the country. Many produce poor quality
work, enjoy no employment rights and are generally below the age of
30. The Somali government, it was suggested, needs to work with media
owners and universities to give budding journalists access to
professional training, through for instance skill exchange programmes
with the diaspora.

Other recommendations mirrored those made in the wider international
debate such as the fact that the regulatory body of the National Media
Council needs broad and balanced representation and checks imposed by
an independent press complaints commission

The recommendations of UK Somali journalists, and comments about the
new draft media law will hopefully foster greater dialogue with their
homeland government. The creation of Somali media law is a positive
step towards the re-establishment of media ethics and standards, and
the safety and freedom this provides journalists.

As a Somali myself this consultation shows UK Somalis accepting that
for most of us our dream of returning to Somalia will not come anytime
soon. Thus we must work in these new ways to influence and contribute
to our homeland right here from Britain.

Annisa Omar is a British-Somali who worked as communications
consultant on this Xog-Sugan UK Diaspora Media Consultation and is a
freelance journalist on look out for new opportunities. Tweet her
@annisaomar

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob.
To view this discussion on the web visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14oodZ3NGm0dUtkWtFD04jt_2VAAFX_EVr8CNy%3D2-GnykAQ%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

Reply via email to