Has South Sudan Sovereignty been compromised?
Dec. 08 Featured <http://www.southsudannation.com/category/featured/>,
Uncategorized <http://www.southsudannation.com/category/uncategorized/> no
comments
<http://www.southsudannation.com/has-south-sudan-sovereignty-been-compromised/#respond>

BY: Dr Lako Jada Kwajok, DEC/08/2015, SSN;

The downing of the Russian SU-24 bomber by the Turkish F-16s on 24/11/2015
brought to the forefront the issue of sovereignty and inviolability of a
country’s territory. Some reports stated that the Russian warplane was only
17 seconds in the Turkish airspace when it was downed.

To many it may appear that the Turks were quite overzealous in defending
their airspace but it’s a matter of principle that any encroachment needs
to be dealt with straight away. Those who shot down the warplane must have
been under strict orders to do so without hesitation.

Here is Turkey that possesses the fourth largest army in the world and
though in itself not a superpower; still will not be cowed by a superpower
violating its territory.

It was a dangerous encounter that led some pessimists and exaggerators to
quickly point out that this could be the triggering event for the would-be
Third World War.

Obviously they have been looking at a single incident on 28/06/1914 that
led to the first world war. It was the assassination of Archduke Franz
Ferdinand, the heir to the Austro-Hungarian Empire in Sarajevo by a Serbian
nationalist (Gavrilo Princip).

But things were quite different then and there was no nuclear powers or the
concept of mutual destruction.

Furthermore the world was less democratic and more dictatorial allowing
some rogue leaders to plunge countries into avoidable wars.

Turkey is an important NATO member guarding its southern front. Technically
, it’s not a nuclear power but has been given nuclear bombs by NATO only to
be used with NATO approval.

In theory, the situation could spiral out of control leading to a nuclear
confrontation and the inevitable total destruction of planet Earth. As one
would expect, the NATO Secretary General came out in support of the Turkish
position.

The ball is now in Russia’s court, if it chooses to escalate the situation
by military retaliation, then the world would draw closer to a third world
war than it ever has been. The central point though remains that, Turkey
has exercised its right as a sovereign state in accordance with the
international law.

Back home, Dr Luka Biong was dismissed from his lecturing post at Juba
university and reportedly expelled from the country. This was the result of
direct instructions from president Kiir himself.

The cause was a public lecture organised by Biong’s Centre for peace and
development studies at Juba University. The subject of debate was the
constitutionality and legality of the presidential decree 36/2015 expanding
the current 10 states to 28 states.

The views expressed by several participants were against the unilateral
creation of more administrative units by the president. The debaters
demonstrated the unconstitutionality of president Kiir’s decree and that it
has no legal basis.

It was also reported that Ambrose Riing Thiik, the head of the Jieng
Council of Elders ( JCE ) stormed out of the venue after being cornered by
Dr Lam Akol in the debate. Apparently, he went straight to the president
and requested dismissal of Dr Luka Biong from Juba university.

President Kiir later said, I quote, “Whoever is undermining our sovereignty
and the demand of our people will have to answer. Those who have been made
who they are today by this country and then turn around to turn their backs
against the very country can be dealt with, if proven they are playing a
negative role.”

It appears Dr Luka Biong has been accused of compromising the state’s
sovereignty by organising that debate hence prompting reprisal from the
president.

To understand the whole matter it’s worthwhile knowing how the term
“sovereign state” originated. Westphalian sovereignty is the principle of
international Law which states, each nation has sovereignty over its
territory and domestic affairs to the exclusion of all external powers, on
the principle of non-interference in another country’s domestic affairs,
and that each state ( no matter how large or small ) is equal in
international law.

The doctrine is named after the peace of Westphalia was signed in 1648
which ended the 30 years war in Europe.

One fundamental aspect of sovereignty is that it’s not enough for a
particular state to declare it, it has to be recognised by its neighbours
and the international community. Sovereignty can be lost when the state
loses certain criteria and regained when they are re-instated.

Contemporary political thinking has challenged the doctrine and rendered it
a non-absolute right of the state. This can be exemplified by the fact that
no sovereignty exists in failed states and international intervention is
justified on humanitarian grounds and by the threats posed by failed states
to neighbouring countries and the world as a whole.

The global impact of refugees fleeing conflict areas is undeniable. For
example the Syrian refugee crisis has affected countries up to several
thousand miles away from the Syrian borders.

The debate organised by Biong, if anything, has provided the authorities
with the result of a mini-opinion poll in regard to the presidential decree
36/2015.

It was also a sort of a snapshot into the minds of an elite group in the
republic of South Sudan and served as a means among others to gauge public
opinion. Those people are among the groups that form the vibrant part of
our society and their opinions can not be regarded as alien to the general
trend in the country.

While in other parts of the world, leaders pay much attention to public
opinions as it’s in their best interests to be in people’s good books, in
our part of the world, those who express opposing opinions get harassed,
tortured, imprisoned or even liquidated.

Biong’s effort was a honest attempt by a concerned citizen to give the
rulers the opportunity of knowing what is in people’s minds. Unfortunately
instead of being commended for his effort to bring people together and fend
off divisive actions, he ended up one step away from being charged with
treason.

People could argue that what Biong did was indeed an effort to safeguard
our sovereignty as the consequences of the decree would ultimately lead to
disintegration of South Sudan.

The question is; has the president done his duty in the way of preserving
our sovereignty and national pride?

In chronological order the following events would show to the readers how
our sovereignty has been consistently undermined since the inception of the
government of South Sudan.

The presence of the Ugandan People’s Defence Force ( UPDF ) on South
Sudanese soil: The UPDF has been stationed within our borders before
declaration of independence.

We were made to believe that a deal has been struck between the South
Sudanese government and the Ugandan counterpart that paved the way for the
UPDF to enter South Sudan in the quest to defeat the Lord’s Resistance Army
(LRA ).

Whatever they have agreed upon, makes our sovereignty questionable. The
mere presence of the UPDF in South Sudan is an insult to our sovereignty.

The two countries could have coordinated their efforts to combat the LRA
without the UPDF crossing the borders into South Sudan. The Ugandans have
been talking of a sort of a buffer zone within South Sudan to keep the LRA
out of Uganda.

It’s an unusual situation; probably unheard of where a country moves forces
across the borders into a neighbouring country to block attacks on its
citizens from its own rebels.

People must realise that the LRA is Uganda’s internal problem and allowing
the UPDF to operate on South Sudanese soil, means that our government has
agreed on turning our country into a battlefield for settling Uganda’s
internal conflict. No sovereign state would do such a thing.

The implications are many, for instance, it’s belittling as it shows the
world that we are unable to defend our territory against intruders.

Also it implies that the safety of Ugandan citizens is more important than
ours by making our land a buffer zone to seal off attacks on Uganda.

The regime hasn’t spared a thought to the fact that war brings unwelcome
consequences wherever it’s fought. Collateral damages, effects on local
economy and the impression on the international community that the country
is a war zone, are just few to mention.

The irony is that, Uganda is now considered by the international community
a war-free country while South Sudan continues to bear the consequences of
the Uganda’s civil war.

It led to a boost in Uganda’s economy by encouraging foreign investments,
promoting trade and attracting tourism. It’s the Ugandan interests that are
being served here.

The Sudan Air Force ( SAF ) aggression: The bombing raids carried out by
SAF’s Antonov’s in Northern Bahr El Gazal state and other states, have been
largely downplayed by the regime in Juba. There has never been or will ever
be retaliations for these raids under this government.

This stands in stark contrast to what the Turks did to the Russians. Less
than 20 seconds violation of their airspace led to the shooting down of the
Russian warplane.

Our response to SAF aggression was and still remains a joke. The Chief of
General Staff, Paul Malong, even had the audacity of saying that the Sudan
is trying to drag us into war.

It means the regime will continue to avoid responding to any future
bombings by SAF for fear of triggering a war with Sudan!

It’s a disgraceful attitude that is unbecoming of proud people. This has
embolden the SAF and on few occasions it carried bombing raids deeper into
South Sudan as far as Bentiu in Unity state.

The SAF incursions into South Sudan have turned into picnic trips or
training exercises for its pilots. It’s clear that our northern neighbour
does not recognise our sovereignty and our government on the other hand did
little to make it take notice of it.

UPDF intervention in the recent conflict: We were told that the basis for
intervention was an agreement between the two governments. Well, what sort
of an agreement is it?!

Around the world, countries do enter into defence pacts, most notable is
the NATO alliance mentioned above. The purpose is mutual defence against
foreign aggression.

This may entail stationing of forces or particular weapons within each
other borders. Examples are the American Trident nuclear missiles in
Scotland, American bases in Germany and NATO nuclear bombs in Turkey.

However, the world has never heard of a defence pact against an internal
insurgency or a rebellion. There is also issues about the constitutionality
and legality of the UPDF invitation by the government as the National
Legislative Assembly was not consulted.

Again inviting a foreign force to intervene in an internal conflict is a
breach of sovereignty and a recipe for division of the country. After all
the opposition is not a foreign force, they are South Sudanese opposing a
failed regime.

Uganda is not immune from the same ills plaguing South Sudan. It is not
impossible for a similar conflict to happen in Uganda. Would it be prudent
for South Sudan or any of the Uganda’s neighbours to intervene on the side
of the government against the opposition?

Justice and Equality Movement ( JEM ) mercenaries: There is an abundance of
evidence that JEM forces were used by the government to shore up its war
effort against the opposition.

Again this kind of policy undermines our sovereignty as no sovereign state
would allow a rebel group to work freely within its borders. The usual
practice is to support foreign rebels in order to attack the country’s own
rebels outside the borders.

The UN Drones: The UN security council has approved the deployment of
unmanned aerial vehicles ( Drones ) in South Sudan against government
opposition. It’s a confirmation that the international community now sees
South Sudan as a country that lacks sovereignty.

A sovereign country would not allow let alone be forced to harbour foreign
Drones on its soil or airspace.

So what sovereignty is president Kiir talking about?! The track record of
his administration has greatly contributed to the erosion of our
sovereignty and what is left is partial at best.

There is a window of opportunity coming up with the formation of the
transitional government of national unity ( TGoNU ) and it should be used
to fully restore our sovereignty.

Firstly, the UPDF should go home for good. Now that the LRA has
disintegrated and ceased to be a threat, UPDF presence in South Sudan has
become more unjustifiable than ever.

Even if there are still some small pockets of LRA in the depths of the
jungle, their level of activities will not be beyond common banditry and
local security forces should be able to tackle it.

Secondly, SAF bombing raids should not be allowed to continue with
impunity. The helicopter gunships that were shamefully used against
civilians in Wonduruba , Mundri and Maridi areas, could now rightly be used
to retaliate against SAF aggression.

Thirdly, JEM and other rebel movements should be booted out of South Sudan.
The regime has forged an unholy alliance with the most unlikely partner.

Some of you know that the deceased leader and founder of JEM, Dr Khalil
Ibrahim, was the [ Amir (prince) ] of the so-called ” Dabbabeen ” in South
Sudan before his rebellion against Bashir’s regime. He and some of his
colleagues who are currently the leaders of JEM, were responsible of
killing many South Sudanese.

Fourthly, freedom of speech should be observed and respected by the
government. We ought to realise that sovereignty also relates to how the
government treats its people.

A rogue state attracts the interference of the international community into
its domestic affairs. This is because misrule and mishandling of its
internal affairs leads to spilling over of its problems into neighbouring
countries and countries beyond its borders.

An opinion expressed publicly by a citizen or by a group of citizens does
not constitute a “threat” to sovereignty for the following reasons.

If the said opinion is shared only by a small portion of our population,
then it will remain a minority opinion which poses no threat to the
government and the country as a whole.

On the other hand if that opinion is supported by the majority of the
population, then it means it stands for the common good and will be a
threat to the government if it does not reverse course but never a threat
to the country.

Governments do fall, and new ones get formed – People don’t!

Dr Lako Jada Kwajok

-- 
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/d/forum/southsudankob
View this message at 
https://groups.google.com/d/msg/southsudankob/topic-id/message-id
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout
--- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob.
To view this discussion on the web visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14ooUpjREnU5uHxnegeAh0_GLyu_SdM7Cr8UJ%2BZfB01bGtQ%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

Reply via email to