6 things we learned from Uganda’s presidential debate
Posted on January 17, 2016 by Rosebell Kagumire
Lesson 3: Underestimate the underdogs at your peril
uganda-debate
On the night of 15 January, Uganda held its first ever televised
presidential debate. The incumbent Yoweri Museveni skipped the
momentous occasion, arguing that the “majority of our voters may not
be able to watch the debate”, but his seven challengers for office
took bravely to the stage.
Former prime minister John Patrick Amama Mbabazi and leading
opposition figure Dr Kizza Besigye − seen as the two main rivals to
Museveni in the upcoming 18 February poll − were joined by the five
lesser known contenders in the race, namely: independent Maureen
Kyalya, the only woman in the contest; veterinary doctor Abed Bwanika;
Major General Benon Biraaro; evangelical pastor Joseph Mabirizi; and
Professor Venansius Baryamureeba.
Moderated by journalists Nancy Kacungira and Alan Kasujja, the debate
was full of surprises, humour and awkward moments that shed a light on
the candidates’ personalities, strengths and weaknesses.
Here are six of the things we learned from the eventful evening:
1. A poem can be about anything, even a TV debate, and still kill it!
The eloquent, gentle-spirited chair of the Uganda Judicial Service
Commission, Justice James Ogoola, never misses a chance to showcase
his poetical prowess. He has previously coined new terms to describe
the ugly violence Uganda has experienced, and as lead organiser of the
debate, he demonstrated his way with words once again as he began
proceedings.
His poem ‘The Debate is the Thing’ set the tempo for the evening, and
with it Ogoola left the audience enchanted. He declared that this was
the time for Ugandans to “choose the adept from the inept” and that
the debate would be “no cheap drama of the political rally, no idle
talk, no mundane politics, empty pledge or hollow promises”.
2. A killer line goes a long way
The debate began with the candidates making two-minute opening remarks
about why they should be president. The only female contender, Kyalya,
struggled to introduce herself at first, but after a false start, the
lawyer and former presidential aide bounced back to deliver a punch
line that earned her immediate applause as she observed: “there is
more teargas in police stations than there is medicine in hospitals”.
General Biraaro, who like Kyalya needed to explain to the audience who
he was exactly, drew similar noises of approval when he asserted in
his opening gambit that “the debate is [the] only level ground in this
election”. In one succinct phrase, he summed up the difficulties
facing opposition candidates, including physical violence and
intimidation, as they try to campaign in the face of Museveni’s
disproportionate access to the state machinery and resources.
Amama Mbabazi also started off well by taking the attention away from
the other candidates and to the electorate as he asked: “do you want
change or do you want more of the same? “ With this short critical
question, Mbabazi helped set the framing for the whole debate.
3. Underestimate the underdogs at your peril
Five of the candidates would have been little-known to most viewers
and the televised debate offered them the biggest platform they’re
likely to get in their campaigns. Some took the opportunity better
than others.
Kyalya, for instance, scored some points on education and brought her
social worker’s passion to bear by focusing on women’s rights, but
consistently veered off topic. Meanwhile, Baryamureeba was not
particularly convincing on policy issues, was incoherent at times and
didn’t ask particularly exciting questions.
By contrast, Mabirizi was the life and soul, though often for the
wrong reasons. The youngest candidate in the race routinely provided
answers that sent the room into roars of laughter to the point that
some in the audience started to burst out laughing even before
Mabirizi had started answering. From oil to female representation to
debt, Mabirizi provided comic relief in a tense evening.
At the other end of the scale, Biraaro and Bwanika were both eloquent
and composed on debt, the economy and unemployment. Their assured
performances will no doubt have surprised many and given some of the
electorate food for thought.
When it came to the two frontrunners, Besigye and Mbabazi both had
high and low points.
Besigye was best when focusing on governance, accountability and
healthcare. He faced some sticky questions about his flip-flops on key
pronouncements, including a promise not to run again for president
without electoral reform, but overall seemed comfortable.
Mbabazi was strong on maternal health, humanising and reiterating the
urgent need to tackle Uganda’s high maternal death rate, but it was
far from plain sailing all the way for the former PM.
4. You can’t have your cake and eat it
With President Museveni’s seat left empty at the debate, the burden of
answering for the government deeds and misdeeds rested on Mbabazi, who
worked closely with Museveni for several years and was prime minister
from May 2011 to September 2014. Running as an independent but still
not denouncing his party membership, Mbabazi put himself in the
awkward position of having to both attack and defend the government.
He understandably received some of the most difficult questions of the
night and gave some of the least satisfactory answers.
When asked about allegedly calling for striking teachers to be fired
when he was in government, for example, Mbabazi wobbled and meandered.
This unconvincing response fed into existing doubts about whether the
former PM can be relatable among low-income earners, a group to whom
he twice referred to during the debate as “those peasants”.
When asked about state repression meanwhile, Mbabazi failed to
distance himself from the ruling NRM’s alleged history of election
theft, political persecution, stifling of the media, arbitrary
killings, and corruption, most of which thrived when he was a central
figure in government. Mbabazi wanted to concentrate on the
disappearance of his top aide Christopher Aine and other recent
violations against opposition politicians, but he couldn’t shake the
perception that he was on the receiving end of a machinery he himself
had helped build.
5. The gutter is not an attractive platform from which to run
Gay rights were expected to make it to the debate and on this issue
Mbabazi seemed surprisingly ill-prepared. When asked a question about
this controversial topic, he immediately took it personally and as an
opportunity to attack female politicians he claims have been spreading
rumours about his sexuality. Mbabazi challenged these MPs to “try him
out” to see if he is gay, but didn’t even stop there. He continued by
saying that a certain female politician − whom everyone knew to be
Speaker of Parliament Rebecca Kadaga − has no basis to call him gay
because he is married with children while she is unmarried and
childless.
6. Absence doesn’t necessarily make the heart grow fonder
President Museveni’s refusal to stand on the same stage as his
opponents says a lot about how superior he feels and some say it shows
his paranoia when it comes to anything over which he does not have
control. With two tough moderators marshaling the debate, Museveni
would certainly not have had an easy ride, but he may nevertheless
come to regret his decision when he sees how certain candidates −
particular the fringe ones − seized the chance to change voters’
perceptions and present an alternative vision.
Whether this debate will change how people actually vote next month
remains to be seen of course, but one thing is for sure. This was a
great occasion, even without the incumbent, and while discussions over
which candidate performed best will continue for some time, one big
winner was Ugandan democracy itself.
Rosebell Kagumire is a media and communication specialist, digital
strategist, public speaker and award-winning blogger. Follow her on
twitter at @RosebellK.
For more on this subject, see:
Uganda’s 2016 elections: same same but different?
AAP#8: Who will win Uganda’s 2016 elections?
If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or
subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your
feed reader.
This entry was posted in African Politics Now. Bookmark the permalink.
8 thoughts on “6 things we learned from Uganda’s presidential debate”
Mark Oundo says:
January 18, 2016 at 5:19 am
Good morning.
The Debate was marvelous thaugh next time moderators should
consider allocating enough time to Candidates as very crucial..
The 2 Minutes including moderators pitching in wasn’t favourable
at all and never allowed any candidate satisfactorily wind up their
explanations.
Atleast 4 or atmost 5 Minutes each wd work much better..
Also, Most Key Questions should be uniform to evenly assess
comparisons amongst them, the way it was done in UK and in Kenya and
elswhere.
Otherwise, Thanks to them and moderators ,being the very first of
that nature they deserve an applause and we expect a much Hotter and
Decisive Debate come 10th Feb.
Hopefully ,President Museveni will be more Partriotic , do a self
check on peoples expectations; be more Accountable and come- 30 years
given to him by people deserve a more reasonable attention for a more
a better
Uganda…
Mark Wycliffe
Kannyeke Kenneth says:
January 18, 2016 at 7:57 am
I don’t think that Museveni’s both the physical and intellectual
fitness would withstand him. No no, He has gone numb of his
intellectual needs to an extent of promising sanitary pads. This
debate was not about vulgarly like leopard anus but issues that bring
a hopeless voter to life. Museveni’s politics well fits the scientific
theory of a deciduous tree, it shades off in Autumn and comes back to
life in winter. But my big concern is he is not even coming back to
political life, he is dying. Well he was with the voters whom he says
have TVs hhhmmmm!!! for30 years, isn’t that ridiculous? What mixes poo
in pee, he delivers state of the nation address on TV, His nomination
was live on TV, when he launches a water tap down in Mukono, it is on
TV, what a cock-doodle-do!!!
mkive says:
January 18, 2016 at 7:59 am
Dr. KB represented my interests especially on the economy policy
and governance.
Am for federal and a mixed economy where the private sector is
mainly national not foreigners
Hussein says:
January 18, 2016 at 9:54 am
One would wonder why M7 says the majority would not watch the
debate yet he delivers the state of the nation address on Tv and
radio-both of which the debate used.
He must have feared embarrassment over his failures and overstay in power.
Bugsy says:
January 18, 2016 at 11:28 am
In my opinion, M7’s boycotting of the event was the smartest
decision of his career. It would have been a firing squad for him 3:-)
davidrusa says:
January 18, 2016 at 3:51 pm
I am impressed by Rosebell Kagumire’s quite objective summary of
the debate. I concur with her on many points. However save for Benon
Biraro and Abdel Bwanika the other candidates seemed either ignorant
or uninterested in the specifics of their electoral programmes. Kizza
Besigye was as usual interested in bashing his nemesis President
Museveni. Actually Besigye exposed himself as a man only interested in
ousting Museveni and everything else was secondary. He never made any
pretensions as to what kind of policies he would pursue that would be
different from the current regime. All he would repeat over and over
was that the current regime is out of power everything would
automatically be rectified
davidrusa says:
January 18, 2016 at 4:07 pm
Continuation of my comment. This appears like an obsession with an
individual called Yoweri Museveni and betrays the true intentions of
Besigye’s continued desire to stand as presidential candidate for four
consecutive times now. Is it the desire to serve the country or the
nagging urge to settle an old score?
As for Amama Mbabazi he seemed to be unprepared for the kind of
questions he got and could not adequately respond. He was particularly
confused in some instances whether to defend his record in Government
or to act as an opposition leader and bash the Government. Such was
his dilemma that in some instances he practised selective memory and
selective hearing to evade some questions!
The debate was very entertaining but just like the USA where the
idea was born it is doubtful whether it will have any bearing on the
elections. My considered view is that it may not especially when the
popular candidates had very dismal performances. Besides how many of
our people watched those debates and how many could fully follow the
debates? Hence the major purpose of the debates might just be a public
relations one to bring all the major candidates together in one hall
and also to expose some who were bragging about their debating skills
which in some instances were found badly wanting.
Diego Izizinga says:
January 18, 2016 at 6:40 pm
Mr. Mbabazi proved to us that one person he wants to bring down is
Honorable Rebecca Kadaga! For years he has fought the speaker of
Parliament as one person who is standing in his way for the
presidency. Since he is bent in destroying Kadaga, we will work very
hard to ask the electorate to deny him votes especially in the Busoga
Region.
--
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
[email protected]
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/d/forum/southsudankob
View this message at
https://groups.google.com/d/msg/southsudankob/topic-id/message-id
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob.
To view this discussion on the web visit
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14orH1GubjYfz5D02Gh5aVX2y2_y-4OBda-GkG686VSFB6g%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.