Exposing Rwanda’s war on journalism
Posted on January 15, 2016 by Oscar Penn
In Bad News: Last Journalists in a Dictatorship, Anjan Sundaram shows
how the Rwandan government tightly controls the national narrative
through intimidation, oppression and violence.
A press scrum in Rwanda. Credit: Graham Holliday.
A press scrum in Rwanda. Credit: Graham Holliday.
Once in a while, a book comes along with the potential to alter our
understanding of a place and its history. Anjan Sundaram’s Bad News:
The Last Journalists in a Dictatorship, which exposes the repression
endured in one of the world’s poorest countries, is one such work.
There has been plenty written about post-conflict society, but in the
case of Rwanda, we rarely get such a cogent view of life inside an
oppressive state bent on controlling the public narrative.
While he spends little time on Rwanda’s complex historical context and
doesn’t even try to explain the country’s precarious place in one of
Africa’s most contentious regions, Sundaram’s portrayal of this
repressive society is spot on.
Sundaram is passionate about journalism, having turned down a job at
Goldman Sachs to travel to the Democratic Republic of Congo where he
became a stringer for the Associated Press. After years in the DRC,
Sundaram shifted to Rwanda where he taught an EU-funded course
training local journalists in the basics of news reporting.
Sundaram suggests that anyone who is not an undying fan of President
Paul Kagame and Rwanda’s ruling party is attacked and labeled as
either a thief, a racist, ignorant or all of the above.
Kigali’s initial response to his book seems to prove him right.
A piece in one Rwandan paper attacking Sundaram’s book on the very day
it was published holds all the elements of good propaganda: it’s
printed in a pro-government newspaper and centres on the words of a
reporter who, if the book is accurate, would be under duress. But most
frightening is that the article goes as far as to name people who were
kept anonymous in the book (including the author’s wife). Perhaps less
chilling but even more absurd is the suggestion that Sundaram
orchestrated the escape of an endangered reporter to create content
for this book. (After all, what quicker path to wealth and fame for a
Yale grad than to travel to a small African country and cook up
controversy around an almost unknown journalist.)
All of this serves as a reminder that the Kigali elite is in complete
and utter control of the Rwandan dialogue. That propaganda piece meant
to refute Sundaram’s assessment actually serves to make his point: in
Rwanda, no critical reportage goes unchallenged and no hard questions
go unpunished.
Of course, the Rwandan spin machine will also use ad hominem attacks
and try to paint Sundaram as either misguided or wicked. The problem
for Kigali is that, with the way he tells this story, Sundaram is just
a little too credible. Like the kid in the old tale who points out
that the emperor has no clothes, Sundaram points to things that are
right in front of us in a way that exposes the obvious. Once we have
seen the illusion for what it is, we cannot un-see it.
There has been an unusual amount of criticism of President Kagame of
late as he reneged on his promise to step down next year and instead
run for another term in the 2017 elections. (And maybe again in 2024,
and then again in 2029.) Thanks in large part to an acquiescent media,
Kagame has managed to cloak this erasing of democracy as the
protection of it. He is simply adhering to the will of the people, he
says. And there’s not much debate to be had in Rwanda about who should
lead the country. Kagame is popular, especially when compared with the
alternative, because there is no alternative.
Rwandans don’t have a choice, but do those outside the country such as
the Western donors whose foreign aid accounts for almost 40% of
Rwanda’s budget? Bad News forces us to ask if these international
actors really have no choice but to support and fund repression.
Kigali senses the beginning of the end of donors’ willingness to prop
up this totalitarian regime. Yet when concerns are expressed by human
rights groups and even the US State Department, the response from
Rwanda is always the same: 1) Stop asking questions 2) Just give us
the money.
And even after billions in aid from the US and EU, Rwanda, like some
of its neighbours, is increasingly turning for support to China, the
Middle East and even Russia. They are eager to find allies without a
lot of concern for pesky things like democracy.
Make no mistake about it: there is a war going on against legitimate
journalism the world over. Oppressive regimes and their PR firms are
winning that war. But with Bad News, Sundaram boldly strikes back at
the powers that be and his aim is true. Sundaram has pulled back a
weighty veil and exposed layers of manipulation that are – for most of
us – almost impossible to see.
Bad News might seem like a book only relevant to Rwanda, but African
leaders and others are already learning from Kigali and are attempting
to replicate Kagame’s style of complete control. Rwanda may be the
canary in the coltan mine (so to speak) warning us of what is to come
elsewhere.
Oscar Penn is an experienced journalist whose work from Africa has
been published in several major news outlets.
[Correction (15/1): the article originally implied Sundaram went to
Yale and MIT. He went to Yale but not MIT. This has now been
corrected.]
If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or
subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your
feed reader.
This entry was posted in African Politics Now. Bookmark the permalink.
2 thoughts on “Exposing Rwanda’s war on journalism”
Aimable says:
January 16, 2016 at 10:37 am
Thank you so much for the article. This article describes a book
that will play a big in the history of my country Rwanda. As a
Rwandan, I had always worried that we will continue to be killed and
jailed by General Kagame forever without anyone noticing, with
everyone continuing to sing his praises only. I am happy to see that
the eyes of the world are opening. I cross my fingers that one day we
Rwandans will find a way to peacefully remove this Kagame dictator.
Nathaniel says:
January 16, 2016 at 8:40 pm
It is really sad!
It is sad to see an ambitious young man who claims to work for the
betterment of humankind close ayes on the plagues that have gnawed his
own society to ferociously pretend fight others’.
The world would like to know what’s being done to fight rapes,
slavery, human trafficking, cast caused inequalities, lack of hygiene,
… in a society of over a billion people rather than lies about Rwanda.
All this is because the lad is greedy and is manipulated by an
equally covetous Canadian wife.
The great lakes region is unstable so it is a journalist’s gold
mine. When things are good or improving the stories lack the salt and
pepper required to sell to the world and thus must be spiced to sell.
Africa has been lagging behind the rest of the world and has
contributed very little to the human industrious development. People
like this journalist work to maintain that latent state by maintaining
divisions and hatred as well as undermining any progress made. He does
not do what he did for love for Rwanda and it’s people.
From the little i know about that small country and it’s people,
he won’t break their spirit! Not now.
Nate.
--
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
[email protected]
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/d/forum/southsudankob
View this message at
https://groups.google.com/d/msg/southsudankob/topic-id/message-id
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob.
To view this discussion on the web visit
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14oqtfebjJHJw%2BkyuEyjpO7VVtdtdgNrDi2%3D-HkgvAenoUg%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.