Nigeria: Buhari’s 2016 budget continues use of secretive ‘security votes’
Posted on January 14, 2016 by Matthew Page      
Nearly $50 million has been set aside in unaccountable items notorious
for being misdirected.
Nigerian security forces in Kaduna. Credit: Mr Ulster.

Nigerian security forces in Kaduna. Credit: Mr Ulster.

Under President Muhammadu Buhari, the fight against corruption in
Nigeria has unquestionably turned a corner. Shortly after taking
office in May, he vowed to “plug revenue leakages”, made sweeping
changes in the notoriously corrupt Nigerian National Petroleum
Corporation (NNPC), and took steps to tighten control over public
spending. He gave the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission free
rein to pursue former officials, several of whom have been arrested.

However, despite these advances, Buhari’s 2016 budget raises awkward
questions. According to official details just released by the Nigerian
government’s Budget Office, the 2016 budget contains over 30 so-called
“security votes”.

In theory, security votes are catch-all line items inserted in the
budget to give recipients the flexibility to cover ad hoc security
expenditures. But in practice, they are opaque slush funds that
officials have long used to embezzle state funds or redirect them for
political purposes. Security votes are distinct from the type of
extra-budgetary defence spending that may have been misdirected or
stolen by the previous government, but they resemble them insofar as
they are spent with scant legislative oversight or outside scrutiny.

In light of his record and rhetoric, Buhari’s decision to use security
votes raises doubts about whether his anti-corruption strategy is
comprehensive enough to put Nigeria back on track.

Thinly-veiled theft

A relic of military rule, security votes were used to siphon public
funds during Nigeria’s Second Republic from 1979 to 1983. In fact,
when the military overthrew the government and Buhari became a
military head of state in 1983, he arrested former officials and
investigated fellow military officers for embezzling security funds.

Max Siollun suggests that these actions contributed to Ibrahim
Babangida’s decision to topple Buhari in 1985. And under Babangida and
later Sani Abacha, the use of security votes as a tool for
self-enrichment was perfected and institutionalised.

Following Nigeria’s 1999 return to civilian rule,
soldiers-turned-civilian officials such as President Olusegun Obasanjo
and former National Security Adviser Aliyu Mohammed Gusau ensured that
security votes survived.

Although it makes sense that a few select military and intelligence
expenditures should remain classified even in a democracy, the
widespread use of security votes by federal, state, and even local
officials is anathema to norms of transparency and accountability. Yet
top politicians have long turned a blind eye to the practice or even
attempted to excuse it.

As one now-opposition party heavyweight recently griped: “Why are we
probing security votes now? You see, security votes to my
understanding can be used for native doctors, it can be used to hire
Alphas [soothsayers] and it can be used for churches to pray for the
country. It can be used for even sponsoring things.”

And the winners are…

In Buhari’s proposed 2016 budget, the top ten security votes amount to
about N9.3 billion ($46.5 million), which his 25% less than the
equivalent amount tucked into his predecessor President Goodluck
Jonathan’s 2015 budget. Although these votes make up less than
one-half of one percent of overall recurrent expenditure in the 2016
Appropriation Bill, they represent huge windfalls for the handful of
top officials entrusted with spending them.

The 2016 budget contains a N576 million ($2.9 million) security vote
for the National Security Adviser, even though the last NSA, Sambo
Dasuki, allegedly diverted up to $2 billion from the security budget
in office. Although 10% less than Jonathan gave Dasuki in 2015, the
amount indicates that the political and financial pre-eminence of the
NSA among Nigeria’s top brass will continue.

As it did under Jonathan, the shadowy State Security Service (SSS) is
set to receive the largest security vote in 2016: about N2 billion
(roughly $10.4 million) or 10% less than last year. Since Buhari took
office, the SSS has been increasingly assertive under the leadership
of Lawal Musa Daura, who hails from the president’s home town. Daura
has purged officers accused of misconduct and corruption from the top
ranks of the SSS.

Nigeria’s small foreign intelligence arm, the National Intelligence
Agency (NIA), will enjoy a N1.2 billion ($6 million) security vote in
2016, a little less than it received last year. Buhari has retained
Jonathan’s NIA director, Ayo Oke, who even joined the new president on
his July 2015 visit to the US. Nevertheless, his stewardship of NIA
finances have been called into question. A recent documentary showed
evidence that the agency received a suspicious disbursement of $289
million from the NNPC on the eve of the 2015 election, an amount more
than twice its annual budget.

Last but not least, the Ministry of Defence and the three branches of
the Armed Forces are set to receive security votes totalling
approximately N5 billion (roughly $25 million). This amount is about
half of what they received in 2015. This reduction might reflect
Buhari’s concerns about alleged financial malfeasance by the military
under President Jonathan.

Looking ahead

President Buhari is undeniably working to root out and deter
corruption from the top down. Nigerians elected him to do so and, to
an unprecedented degree, he and his government are making progress.
Yet the unfolding Dasuki affair should be a reminder that secretive
security slush funds can easily end up paying personal, rather than
operational, dividends.

If the Buhari government continues to use security votes, it could at
least work with the National Assembly to better monitor how such funds
are spent. It could also enable citizen oversight by declassifying how
the money was spent after two years.

Having said that, even if he wants to maintain the use of these
secretive funds, Buhari may soon find that as more embarrassing
details of security sector corruption emerge, he has no choice but to
address security votes, one of the most durable forms of corruption in
Nigeria today.

Matthew Page is an international affairs fellow at the Council on
Foreign Relations. This article represents the views of the author and
do not represent the official policy of the Department of State or the
government of the United States.  You can follow him on Twitter at
@MatthewTPage.
If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or
subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your
feed reader.
This entry was posted in African Politics Now, The Nigeria Forum.
Bookmark the permalink.
One thought on “Nigeria: Buhari’s 2016 budget continues use of
secretive ‘security votes’”

    James Ojiabo says:  
    January 16, 2016 at 9:20 pm

    Security vote is most abuse d by state and local government
officials. State Governor of a South East state pocket ed more than
one-half of federal allocation every month and the state remain most
unsafe that army has remained on roads
    Immunity and security vote will be the barn of Nigerians
    Waiting for the House(s) that will have the courage to put an end to them

-- 
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/d/forum/southsudankob
View this message at 
https://groups.google.com/d/msg/southsudankob/topic-id/message-id
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout
--- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob.
To view this discussion on the web visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14oogETs2kT5KP%3D0FsyPGu77RNaY0Btwp4apOBF1iCPekcA%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

Reply via email to