“Are we animals?” Nigeriens respond to Foreign Policy’s ‘Dead Man’s Market’
Posted on June 13, 2016 by Ibrahim Yahaya Ibrahim
Following in an age-old tradition of problematic journalism on Africa,
Keenan’s 4,000-word article on Zinder’s youth sensationalises
violence, exaggerates terrorist fears, and overlooks local actions.
Discussing youth violence in Zinder with members of Palais Super Mecs,
Credit: Ibrahim Yahaya Ibrahim.
Discussing youth violence in Zinder with members of Palais Super Mecs,
Credit: Ibrahim Yahaya Ibrahim.
In the last six years, the Nigerien city of Zinder – located some
900km southeast of the capital Niamey – has experienced a new
phenomenon of youth violence popularly referred to as the Yan palais.
In Hausa, this means members of the palais, which refers to a group of
youths who have adopted a distinctive street culture that mimics
American gang culture in terms of its members’ names, clothing styles,
musical tastes, drug consumption, sexual behaviour, and use of street
violence. The palais is an aberration of an older, peaceful street
culture where young men organise into “youth clubs” – called fada –
and meet to socialise, listen to music and play games.
This new palais phenomenon has drawn the attention of researchers and
journalists both locally and internationally. Many analyses have
resulted from this growing interest. Some of these have been helpful,
while others have not. Unfortunately, Jillian Keenan’s article
entitled ‘Dead Man’s Market’ and published in Foreign Policy earlier
this year falls into the latter category.
In this 4,000-word piece, Keenan provides an exaggerated and
oversimplified depiction of the palais phenomenon. She describes
Zinder as a city devastated by “days and nights of brutality” full of
street fights, murder, rape and armed robbery. Her narrative abounds
with images “cut bodies”, “sliced ears”, “slit throats”, “crushed and
broken bones”, fists covered in blood, and machetes “dull from years
of cutting into bodies”.
But for those who know Zinder, the article is nothing more than an
eloquent description of an outrageously distorted reality. The city
described is unrecognisable to its own inhabitants, and most
importantly, even to the journalist’s main informants.
“Are we animals?”
I translated the ‘Dead Man’s Market’ into Hausa and read it to a
number of people in Zinder, including members of palais. The reactions
varied from simple denials to outrage.
“It was true that there were fights between palais youths, and people
did use machetes, and there were deaths, but her description is much
exaggerated,” said Ohlala, a well-known palais leader. “One can count
the number of deaths on his fingertips! There were certainly less than
a dozen deaths in the whole 5 years [from 2010 to 2015] when violence
was the most intense.”
Oumoul Kheir, a resident of Zinder in her 50s, reacted angrily too.
“Are we animals? How do these people think of us? People do not slit
other people’s throats just like that in here!”
Saleh, a community leader, said: “the palais phenomenon was a painful
experience but, thank God, the violence has now calmed down, certainly
due to our Ulama’s [Muslim scholar’s] invocations, the work of
community leaders, and the authorities’ effort to improve policing”.
Finally, Idrissa Sani (aka Baho), Keenan’s principal informant and a
major character in the article, responded: “I have never told Keenan
that my machete was dull because of cutting into people’s bodies. I
have a machete that I use for self-protection because of the nature of
my work [driving a moto taxi by night can be dangerous in Zinder]. But
I have never cut anyone’s body with a machete, not to mention having
to buy a new one because the old ones were dull. This is not true. I
feel really betrayed because of what she said. This is not what we
talked about.”
In response to these reactions, Foreign Policy (who consulted with
Keenan) said: “With regard to Baho’s feeling betrayed, our reporter
sought to depict her main source fairly. He told her of his
experiences fighting other men and using his adda; we cannot account
for his telling you that the opposite is true.”
Bad Boyz, not Boko Haram boys
As Keenan points out, there is no doubt that the rise of the palais
phenomenon has occasioned an unprecedented surge of urban violence in
Zinder, a city that had until then been largely calm. In 2009, the
year when the palais first arose, the city’s police registered only
258 acts of violence. This number increased in 2010 and 2011 when
there were respectively 551 and 952 registered acts. Violence reached
its peak in 2012 with a total of 2,016 acts, before it dropped to
1,243 in 2013.
This rise in violence was certainly grave for Zinder, but comparing
these figures to those of other cities suggests that the levels of
crime Keenan describes are most noteworthy in that they occurred
against a historically peaceful backdrop. After all, the levels of
violence in absolute numbers are unremarkable. Taking 2012, the worst
year of violence, Zinder’s crime rate (in a population of 321,809) was
6.28 crimes per 1,000 inhabitants. The 2012 crime rate in Edison Park,
the safest neighbourhood in the US city of Chicago, was 1.5 times
higher at 9.24 per 1,000 inhabitants.
As well as exaggerating the violence in Zinder, however, the Foreign
Policy article also makes a considerable yet unsuccessful effort to
link the palais phenomenon to Islamist militancy. The subtitle of the
piece – “Impoverished young men have menaced the city of Zinder with
rapes and murders. Now Boko Haram wants to turn their ultra-violence
into a weapon of war” – summarises the easy connection drawn between
Niger’s demographic boom, poverty, and terrorism.
Because of their poor and desperate conditions, suggests Keenen, Yan
palais constitute a potential reservoir of recruits for Boko Haram.
And she even suggests that the group has already established contact
with Zinder’s gangsters. Yet, as evidence, the article only mentions
the story of two anonymous cars with no license plates entering the
neighbourhood of Kara Kara. There is no mention of who was in the car,
who they met with, or what they talked about. Like many others
journalists and researchers before her, Keenan failed to find evidence
of the much expected presence of Boko Haram.
Indeed, there is so far no clear link between Boko Haram and Yan
palais. Though what is clear is that despite the spread of militant
Islamist ideology over the last decade, Zinder’s youths are inspired
much more by American gangs and pop celebrities than militant
Islamists. The palais graffiti on Zinder’s walls makes reference to
DMX, Bad Boyz, Outlaw, Black Power, and Gangsters City, while the Yan
palais wear sagging trousers, dreadlocks and crest hair styles
associated with American ghetto culture.
And so, as with other Nigerien cities, Zinder’s stability defies
simplistic theories that associate poverty, religion, and terrorism.
According to these reductive perspectives, it must be quite puzzling
that a “poor and dusty” city like Zinder, with a 95% Muslim population
and located at the confluence of multiple Islamist groups – Boko Haram
around Lake Chad, ISIS in Libya, and Al-Qaeda in the Islamic Maghreb
in the Sahara – has not seen any active cells of jihadists emerge.
Instead of trying simplistically to link poor disaffected Muslim
youths to terrorism, researchers should embrace the complexity of the
situation and ask questions like: Why, despite significant
similarities among Sahelien cities, does terrorism prevail in some
places and not others? And why are certain disaffected youths in the
Sahel inspired by Western gang culture to express dissent, while
others take their inspiration from ISIS and Al-Qaeda?
However, this might be too complicated and un-sexy for an audience
primarily concerned with whether the faraway poor constitute a threat
to Western safety and prosperity.
Erasing African agency
Keenan’s description of the Yan palais phenomenon also reflects a
wider and persistent problem with some Western journalists’ coverage
of African realities. The frequently stereotypical and formulaic
representations of African societies in the Western media all too
often reflect, in a veiled form, the same colonial discourses that
characterised the previous encounter between Western and African
societies.
In certain imaginations, Africa constitutes a black hole where
barbarian, primitive, and savage populations live according to the law
of nature. And the shocking images and stories of wars, famines, and
disasters make the narratives within ‘Dead Man’s Market’ seem
immediately understandable to readers.
Typically, journalists come to places like Zinder on the hunt for
shocking stories of human suffering. And it is telling that the only
times in recent years when Zinder has drawn the attention of
international journalists has been during the famine of 2005, the
Charlie Hebdo riots of 2015, and now with the phenomenon of Yan palais
violence.
This state of affairs leads to inaccurate depictions of Africa, but
there is also crucially a latent power relation enmeshed in such
narratives. Describing things not only imposes meaning on them, but
also determines practices. For instance, Keenan ends her article on a
note of hope regarding the decline of palais violence, but in her
telling, one of the only actors that seems to have played a role in
this decline is UNICEF.
This means that the efforts of Zinder’s residents – those whose lives
were most affected by the violence – go largely unnoticed. The
government’s efforts to improve policing, which has led to the arrest
of the most violent palais leaders and contributed to pacifying the
palais youth, are not mentioned. Job training programmes, the funding
of youth entrepreneurial projects, and the creation of an inclusive
consultation group called Fadas and Palais Movement for Youth
Promotion, which offers youths an alternative and peaceful venue to
settle disputes, are ignored. The role of religious leaders in
organising public prayers and preaching for peace in mosques and
churches and on the radio and TV are overlooked. And the participation
of parental associations and women’s movements’ in calling on parents
to better educate and monitor their children are discounted.
The fact all these local initiatives are disregarded while foreign
initiatives are emphasised brings to mind the condescension that
sometimes characterises Western journalism and disaster tourism in
Africa. All too often, Africans appear as helpless victims, lacking
the initiative to address their own problems, always waiting
desperately for others to come to their rescue.
Ibrahim Yahaya Ibrahim is a resident of Zinder. He is PhD candidate in
Political Science at the University of Florida where he is also a
research associate with the Sahel Research Group. His research focuses
on the recent rise of political contestation in Zinder, of which the
palais phenomenon constitutes a crucial aspect.
If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or
subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your
feed reader.
This entry was posted in African Politics Now. Bookmark the permalink.
9 thoughts on ““Are we animals?” Nigeriens respond to Foreign Policy’s
‘Dead Man’s Market’”
tyler says:
June 13, 2016 at 6:31 pm
Snap!
I think your critique applies to many a modern journalist who are
looking to produce prolifically but without (sometimes) a profound
understanding of the subject matter they are referring to. I see this
in Canada when pundits are called upon to opine on matters relating to
indigenous populations – and the product is almost always garbage. Of
course people with more context-specific information will produce
better insights, but as you say, Westerners are looking for a handful
of different narratives when they think about Africa. Keenan simply
delivered!
azav says:
June 14, 2016 at 11:53 am
It’s Nigerians, not Nigeriens. Try to get the name of the country
you are writing about correct.
You might want to fix that. It just looks bad.
AfricanArgumentsEditor says:
June 14, 2016 at 12:19 pm
Thanks, azav. If the article were about Nigerians, you’re 100%
correct that it would be ‘Nigerians’, not Nigeriens. But this article
is about Nigeriens so it’s right that it’s ‘Nigeriens’ not Nigerians.
On a separate note, neither is actually the ‘name of a country’, but
thanks for commenting.
Mwafrika says:
June 14, 2016 at 5:11 pm
Fantastic piece Ibrahim Yahaya Ibrahim. I could take this article
and just change the country and city names and it would be true for so
many Africa reports in the Western press.
The last point is particularly potent. The infantalization of
African people seems to be an incurable problem among Western journos.
I am always amused how White journalists land in an African
country and immediately go seeking an ‘expert opinion’ from the first
white person they can find ignoring dozens of indigenous intellectuals
with a far deeper knowledge of the subject matter.
Ibrahim Yahaya Ibrahim says:
June 15, 2016 at 12:54 pm
Thanks Mwafrika!! Unless we stand up for ourselves, and tell our
own stories others won’t stop telling lies about us!!
Phyrne says:
June 15, 2016 at 2:28 pm
You did a fantastic piece of verification ,which was a great fresh
reality read ,may i be so bold as to give you a tip,Mr Ibrahim, try to
gather entusiastic would be local photographers because backing up
facts with photos tend to imbedd(?) stories more in memories than just
written anylisis and if you can offer them too,they open more
avenues.i say this in memory of Gigi Giannuzzi of trolleyology
MALAM MAMANE SANI says:
June 15, 2016 at 11:44 pm
Article percutant et édifiant !
Abdoul M. N. says:
June 16, 2016 at 6:16 pm
Thanks Ibrahim! This is a beautiful, relevant and well argued
answer to one of those thousands of “exaggerated and oversimplified”
analyses.
Tom Minney says:
June 17, 2016 at 1:40 pm
Good article, and thanks for the effort to bring us Zinder
people’s (“Zinderenes”?) views. Western media should give more spaces
to local journalists. As a journalist in Africa long ago, it was great
to work in local (national) newsrooms. It was good feedback from
domestic readers, and from news colleagues if I sold freelance writing
abroad.
--
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
[email protected]
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/d/forum/southsudankob
View this message at
https://groups.google.com/d/msg/southsudankob/topic-id/message-id
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob.
To view this discussion on the web visit
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14oqm1BCaPNM93jBtmX1o1HET%2Bo5rs4ys2-USTLXGyarKSg%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.