Chagos Islands: 50 years on, Judgement Day is almost nigh
Posted on June 17, 2016 by Seán Carey   
Over the coming months, the long-term fate of the Chagos Islands could
become a lot clearer.
US troops engage in a live-fire training exercise at its base on Diego
Garcia, Chagos Islands. Credit: US Navy photo.

US troops engage in a live-fire training exercise at its base on Diego
Garcia, Chagos Islands. Credit: US Navy photo.

The clock is ticking on the fate of the Chagos islands. Located in the
middle of the Indian Ocean, the overseas UK territory has been the
site of a strategic US military base for the past half-century, but
the 50-year agreement that allows it to use the islands is set to
expire at the end of 2016.

At this point, the agreement for the military instalment will be
automatically extended by 20 years if neither side chooses to
terminate it. This is almost certainly what the UK and US hope will
happen, but the issue has been made significantly more complicated by
the demands of two other parties.

Firstly, Prime Minister Anerood Jugnauth has reasserted Mauritius’
claim over the islands. The archipelago was previously part of
Mauritius, and Jugnauth has reiterated his position that the UK’s
dismemberment of Chagos before it granted the former colony
independence in the 1960s was illegal.

In a tense meeting with the UK Foreign Office in Port Louis recently,
these demands reached a head as Jugnauth gave the UK an ultimatum: set
a date for the return of the islands by the end of June, or Mauritius
will seek a resolution at the United Nations General Assembly to refer
the matter to the International Court of Justice.

And secondly, adding further to the complexity of the situation, the
former residents of the Chagos islands are still fighting for their
right to return.

In what is often described as one of the most shameful episodes of
Britain’s post-war history, around 1,500 indigenous people were
forcibly removed from the islands between 1968 and 1973 to make way
for the US base on the island of Diego Garcia. Most were dropped in
Mauritius and some in the Seychelles, though many have since claimed
British citizenship and moved to the UK.

Particularly in the last decade or so, many Chagossians have been
engaged in a legal struggle for the right to return, and in the coming
weeks, the UK Supreme Court is set to make what could be an historic
ruling.

Keeping promises

Over the past 50 years, the US base on Diego Garcia – an “unsinkable
aircraft carrier” positioned off the coasts of East Africa, the Middle
East and India – has been a crucial node in the country’s military
activities. The US is therefore eager to keep a hold of the base and,
despite the many other unanswered questions regarding fate of the
Chagos islands after the end of 2016, it seems that this issue is
actually fairly assured.

>From Mauritius’ perspective, Jugnauth has insisted that the events
that led to the archipelago being removed from Mauritius and
effectively loaned to the US 50 years ago were illegal. And he has
also spoken of the UK’s long-standing promise that the islands will be
returned to Mauritius when it is “no longer needed for defence
purposes”.

According to a ruling by the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) in
The Hague in 2015, this assurance is legally binding, and now that the
Cold War is over, Jugnauth argues that these conditions have been met.
However, at the same time, the Prime Minister − like his predecessor
before him − has said that if Mauritius regains sovereignty of the
islands, the US would be allowed to maintain its presence.

In effect, Jugnauth doesn’t want to see the US military base
disbanded, but would rather like Mauritius to have direct talks with
Washington in order to negotiate the rent and terms of any extension.

This is unlikely to happen without the go ahead of the UK, however,
and if its past actions are anything to go by, it seems the UK will be
reluctant to hand over sovereignty. For instance, the aforementioned
2015 case at the PCA came in response to the UK’s unilateral
establishment of a Marine Protection Area (MPA) around the islands in
2010. This move seemed to assert the UK’s belief in its absolute
sovereignty over the territory and deprived Mauritius of its fishing
rights, prompting the island nation to take the matter to court.

In its ruling, The Hague judges deemed the MPA to have been illegally
imposed, and referred to “The United Kingdom’s undertaking to return
the Chagos archipelago to Mauritius”. The court suggested that the
UK’s promises to Mauritius 50 years ago were legally binding.

Nevertheless, an official at the UK Foreign and Commonwealth Office
responded to the judgment, commenting that “there is no question about
UK sovereignty in the British Indian Ocean Territory”.

This impasse is what has led Jugnauth to issue his ultimatum and
threat to take the issue to the International Court of Justice.

Fighting for the right to return

Over the past decade and a half, legal courts have also been the main
site of the Chagossians’ struggle for the right to return. In the
2000s, the exiled islanders led by Olivier Bancoult, head of the
Chagos Refugees Group, launched legal appeals and won cases in the UK
High Court and Court of Appeal. But they faced a setback in 2008, when
the matter was referred to the House of Lords, the highest court in
the land, which ruled against the group’s right to return in a split
3-2 ruling.

The House of Lords’ judicial functions have since been taken over by
the UK Supreme Court, however, and in the coming weeks, these judges
are set to review its predecessor’s ruling in light of new
developments. A key issue for the five-strong panel of justices is
whether the UK government’s redraft of an independent feasibility
study – from one that was favourable to the islanders’ resettlement to
one that wasn’t – materially affected the Law Lords’ verdict.

The Chagossian plaintiffs are optimistic that the Supreme Court will
reassert their right to return, and if this is the case, the practical
details of how their resettlement might work have already been
examined. A new KPMG feasibility study commissioned by the UK
government in 2012 established that the islanders’ return was entirely
possible and suggested a variety of differently costed resettlement
scenarios. The minimum was £63 million ($89 million) over three years,
the maximum £414 million ($580 million) over six years.

So far, the UK’s current Foreign Secretary, Philip Hammond, has been
wary of any long-term financial commitments and unsympathetic to the
islanders’ right of return – though even if the Supreme Court rules
against resettlement, it is not implausible that his position will
change in a bid to neutralise Mauritian claims for sovereignty.

In any event, Bancoult also met with the Commissioner of the BIOT on
his recent visit to Mauritius during which he was told “a decision on
resettlement will be made very soon”, not that that reassured him. “We
keep hearing those words ‘very soon’ and nothing ever seems to
happen,” says Bancoult.

Bancoult is also dismissive of concerns about the financial costs.
“There never seems to be a problem providing money for the British
Virgin Islands and other overseas territories so why should Chagos be
the exception?” he asks.

Half a century after the UK severed the Chagos islands from Mauritius
and forcibly removed 1,500 people from their homeland, the natural
moment to right these wrongs is fast approaching. But with a number of
uncertain and moving parts, whether this opportunity will be taken
come the end of 2016 remains to be seen.

Seán Carey is honorary senior research fellow in the School of Social
Sciences, University of Manchester.
If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or
subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your
feed reader.
This entry was posted in African Politics Now. Bookmark the permalink.

-- 
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/d/forum/southsudankob
View this message at 
https://groups.google.com/d/msg/southsudankob/topic-id/message-id
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout
--- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob.
To view this discussion on the web visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14ormkzScO04nJrapa%2BouS3%3DcyM64BtmkBmpTt5B1UJrRuw%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

Reply via email to