Roland wrote; Having said that, JOHN, what is your read on whether Chap 5 allows barriers to be used to increase the floor area for a single building?
If you mean Fire "Barriers" or Fire Partitions, NO ! 2006 IBC 506.1 addresses Area Modifications. The commentary says it all; "Besides increasing the fire resistance (utilizing a higher construction type) of the building structure, in general there are TWO circumstances that would decrease a buildings fire hazard. These are: 1) Isolating the building from other structures 2) Equipping it with a fire suppression system" Number 2) is a no brainer. Lets look at # 1, Isolation. Just how is this accomplished ? a) 506.2 Frontage Increase - Frontage on streets, or open spaces adjoining or having access to the public way. This gives the fire service access to the building and limits exposure to other buildings on the side(s) taken as "open frontage" credit. Remember the starting point for open frontage credit is "where a building has more then 25% of its perimeter on a public way or open space having a width of 20 feet", the first 25% is a given, thus the maximum credit for open frontage is 75%. If=[F/P]-0.25](W/30) Thats it. No mention in the code of fire barriers providing area increase benefits. Sure a firewall (705.1) or party wall (705.1.1) will help because each structure gets treated as a separate building when using Table 503, but not if the designer intents to use them as fire barriers or partitions, i.e. openings and penetrations. If one uses a firewall or party wall they must do so in compliance with 705.1/705.1.1 and not 706/708. Designers simply cant mix and match since the intent of the fire separation interacts with other provisions of the code. I think the fire area provisions of Chapter 9 get confused with the area provisions. They are different. Before we get to Chapter 9 one needs to get past Chapter 5. And remember if a Chapter 5 area increase was accomplished with sprinklers one can't squash the sprinklers by chopping a building up using fire areas pursuant to Chapter 9. Lastly be careful of area increases and double dipping. 2006 IBC Table 601/602 note e. has been known to wreck many an architects day. The moral to note e., dont get greedy !. PS- With sprinklers fetching 300% (single story) and 200% (multiple story) area increase "incentives" concurrent with height increase the sprinkler "option" is winking at you. John Drucker Fire Protection Subcode Official (AHJ) New Jersey -----Original Message----- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Roland Huggins Sent: Tuesday, March 11, 2008 2:42 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: Horizontal Exits Part 88 Since the building code is not my claim to fame, I am expressing OPINIONS just like any other FPE. Having said that, JOHN, what is your read on whether Chap 5 allows barriers to be used to increase the floor area for a single building? 502.1 seems rather explicit (and it complies with the underlying philosophy) that it's bounded by either exterior walls or fire walls. Just because another chapter mentions barriers dividing the area of a floor, that's for a different purpose (such as overall exposed area that triggers sprinklers as in chap 9). Location has meaning as mentioned on the fire alarm impacting sprinkler zoning misconception. This will be my last message on this topic since we've beaten this thing to death. There is a moral to this thread. Be careful when you casual accept providing code guidance just because the owner doesn't want to hire an engineer or the architect doesn't realize they know nothing about fire protection. Roland On Mar 11, 2008, at 10:54 AM, John Drucker wrote: > > While that may be true, providing a firewall where a fire separation > assembly will do is unusual. The question needs to be asked of the > architect as to the purpose of same, i.e., fire areas or separate > buildings. The truth is in the answer which will be memorialized. The > end result will be when the owner tries to sell the building or > building(s). > > John Drucker _______________________________________________ Sprinklerforum mailing list [email protected] http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED] (Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field) _______________________________________________ Sprinklerforum mailing list [email protected] http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[EMAIL PROTECTED] (Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)
