to all.

I had the pleasure of being allowed to drive an Accucraft Garret at Sinsheim. A 
beauty in any language. I wonder if anyone has noticed that for some reason 
many models seem to get the "simplified Walschaerts" valve gear upside down. eg 
the K-27 and the K-28 models have the radius rod at the top of the die block 
when the loco is the direction usually run. On the two mentioned locos this is 
of course forwards.  The prototype would be at the bottom of the block. The 
Garrets usually had the second engine (the one under the cab) also with the 
radius rod at the bottom when running forwards even though compared with the 
front engine it runs backwards. The model from Accucraft has one up and one 
down.  Aster seem to have got it right on some of the engines I have seen 
except the Garret which is also one up and one down.  The engines run super and 
the valve gear can easily be corrected by moving the return crank 180° where 
needed.  They were so set that the comparatively straight line of the valve 
gear when set at the bottom when running in the direction usually run to avoid 
wear.!  

Now the question. Does anybody know if there is a reason for the "slip up" or 
is it intentional, and for which reasons? I must admit I have not met anyone 
who has noticed this point in the modelling world and as said the engines all 
run first class and I further realize this can be classed as "Rivet counting", 
but I'll take the risk. 



Bert
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: 
http://postfix.45mm.com/pipermail/sslivesteam/attachments/20070123/58205471/attachment.html
_______________________________________________
SSLiveSteam mailing list
Send messages: [email protected]
Cancel subscription: http://postfix.45mm.com/mailman/listinfo/sslivesteam
Rules: http://www.45mm.com/sslivesteam_guide.html

Reply via email to