On 28 April 2011 14:16, Yann Leboulanger <[email protected]> wrote: > Le 28/04/2011 14:12, Remko Tronçon a écrit : >>> >>> I thought we had established "incoming" means incoming from the client's >>> POV. >> >> Right, i actually meant the whole chain, up to and including the >> server part (up to the stanza router). >> It doesn't make sense to filter out stanzas from your own server (not >> talking about the ones from other users on your server). But the XEP >> could use some more specification of what "incoming" really is to >> avoid this problem of shooting yourself in the foot. > > if that could be written in XEP-0016 that incoming iq is from a client to > another client, or at least not from user's server to user, that would be > perfect I think. > And probably that "clients should not send iq get|set to jid that are > blocked" >
Why not just clarify that privacy lists only block incoming iqs of type "set"/"get"? Doesn't that solve everything in the least surprising way? Regards, Matthew
