On 2013-05-17 18:18, Peter Saint-Andre wrote:
[..]

It doesn't really normatively reference XEP-0246. I'd propose the
following wording change:

OLD
Once discovery has been completed, the clients are able to negotiate
an XML stream between themselves (as generalized in End-to-End XML
Streams [2]) and then exchange messages and other structured data
using the XMPP <message/> and <iq/> stanzas.

NEW
Once discovery has been completed, the clients are able to negotiate
an XML stream between themselves and then exchange messages and other
structured data using the XMPP <message/> and <iq/> stanzas.

XEP-0246 was a generalization of how things work in such environments,
but it's certainly not necessary here.

Did you already change this in the currently published version? I cannot see the old version of the text, and I also don't see why we wouldn't point to XEP-0246. Maybe even normative.

It is a nice, broader explanation of how things work. XEP-0174's description on how to set up the connection is pretty minimal. XEP-0246 goes into detail and, for example, specifies the values of the addressing information in the stream header. I am not entirely sure why that document never got further along in our standards process and maybe we should reconsider that.

--
ralphm

Reply via email to