Hello Matt, council & rest of standards community Thanks for your comments.
Regarding your comments on the color field type: >>> 3) ProtoXEP: Data Forms - Color Field Type < >>> http://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/color-parameter.html > >>> Accept as Experimental? >>> >>> RM, TM, MW have no objections. MM has objections (prefixing of XEP-0122 >>> elements). Author(s) to submit a revision correcting XEP-0122 use. >>> KS have one fortnight to note objections. >> >> I'm unsure what you mean by this. Could you provide an example or reference >> into the XEP-0122 that clarifies this point? >> >> In XEP-0122 I read: "The use of namespace prefixes is RECOMMENDED for large >> forms, to reduce the data size." >> >> Why do you feel this is not done in this XEP? >> > >I apologize for my misreadings, and lift my objections. Ok. If there are no further objections, could the council approve this XEP as experimental? Regarding the HTTP over XMPP XEP: >> 2) Regarding the HTTP over XMPP XEP posted earlier. I have still a couple of >> questions posted to the council and the standards list, that have not been >> answered. Could you please take a look at my latest comments again so that I >> know how to proceed? > > >While I still have some concerns about the non-IBB chunked model, that is not >holding it up. > >The biggest outstanding issues are the unclear copyright ownership around the >SOAP examples. The appear to be from W3Schools, > but it is unclear if you have rights to place them into a XEP, which then > requires you to assign those rights to the XSF. We cannot accept this > proto-XEP until the copyright issues are resolved. I thought it would be instructive to use common or known examples. It would fall under "fair use" in copyright law. (It is also sufficiently changed to not be a literal copy.) It's also clearly attributed, with reference to originator. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_use To make sure however, I'll send a question to W3school to get their approval. If not provided, I'll change the examples. Would it be OK with the council with such examples, if w3school gives a written approval? Regarding non-IBB chunked model: I believe it would be a big performance loss if IBB would have to be used on relatively short chunked responses. However, I have no problem in seeing the value of using IBB in the streaming case, where data streams are indefinite. Would the Council approve the XEP to experimental if I changed the streaming part, but left the other chunked mode as is? Sincerely, Peter Waher
