-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 On 6/3/13 3:12 AM, Dave Cridland wrote: > Ooops, managed to send my reply only to Kev. > > On Sun, Jun 2, 2013 at 8:07 AM, Kevin Smith <[email protected] > <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote: >> All of these involve changing what is currently specified, which >> isn't what I'm suggesting - but I'm happy with a note saying "It >> is known that some existing implementations require you to join >> the room" along with the note saying that you don't need to. > > I could support this if: > > 1) It described how to recover from this - which error would be > given - and: > > 2) If implementations do actually give a useful error. My reading > of XEP-0045 is that it ought to be <not-allowed/>, but I've a > feeling that existing implementations give <forbidden/> instead, > which clashes which "You are not an owner". > > I'm fully in support of the notion that actions not requiring a > particular role should not need to be invoked only by an occupant > (ie, you can configure and destroy rooms without joining them), I'm > just hesitant given the history and existing deployment that this > isn't a de-facto change to the specification.
IMHO this might be a feature for the MUC service administration spec, not XEP-0045. Peter - -- Peter Saint-Andre https://stpeter.im/ -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG/MacGPG2 v2.0.19 (Darwin) Comment: GPGTools - http://gpgtools.org Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://www.enigmail.net/ iQIcBAEBAgAGBQJRuTlyAAoJEOoGpJErxa2pt+MP/jL0PRpe/bLZWgP6vCJEUb6Q pLNsfSp9p8va6SOYp5NyrIlz0qVzKUTKauxxZTUByAG4xbqzDolP5J6oArixg5hW OxkAaXwr1/ctvH1GRBy0Q1FoE2LatlCRhLBQIzMngTSQ8kq/4MIFV1iP+u5Msyge 7kwU+JcXYfbHg9t9HaCXKl2+HTAAnF30AuNK+IEGKKA7yCIsSie9jlAb4ojXoK8z 7Fxst80rjwjA90bq+11s6IJlU+h4CAKzRh/I9REmfW8Ps2+v9YGvf4cFvI4+kulp yDlCDq9+5OWo0ygl6DKgyHHSwsUu6vjGOJBm3uBa03xC6u7XQna+ESSaNfCzfGBr ctP/czzptW35tSVSZ+LxiKFOjq+Lu7vpZu7TzGIQh/hBwi0m0br0O/iIZ8zfayxp WCBrr7e09QfjVVakVnxHEQiUj/0qD4OVBCHqfEMIGQCr5ul+Lla9YHO+FTaANquM JKdjj/eS+y6tfUSRPT/KproqcjXBaNava3h7oGv0LB2nGTYb6S02/ekzZ3xIfVUy XZedy4RkhKPBWjf8xsssSkEpWQWULtAESfZBu8XdOkSnTHYu0KNJNN6CVvqmVKrF ZlQbzwdlgw7uVXED9dvbQpdrwu2rfOtonfOg2T1ryU8KmOLVJ3zL5KuGFKaJc4cO 4BCkJfffJr7h7gecT341 =pR6l -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
