-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 On 9/23/13 7:21 AM, Alexey Melnikov wrote: > On 21/09/2013 03:34, Peter Saint-Andre wrote: >> To my chagrin, I just realized that this header field is in fact >> registered: >> >> http://www.iana.org/assignments/message-headers/message-headers.xhtml#prov-headers >> >> >> >> It's been so long since I looked into this issue that I must have >> forgotten. >> >> However, I do plan to get an RFC published so that there is >> stable documentation for the Jabber-ID header field. > Hi Peter, Some comments on -10:
Hi Alexey, Thanks for the feedback. When I submitted this I-D to the ISE, I said that you'd be a potential reviewer. It seems I was right. :-) > Your ABNF in Section 2: > > Jabber-ID = SP *WSP pathxmpp *WSP CRLF > > And your example in at the end of 3.2 is: > > Following the rules in [RFC5122] and the Jabber-ID header field > syntax, the resulting header field might be as shown below (note > that this representation includes folding white space, which is > allowed in accordance with the ABNF): > > Jabber-ID: ji%C5%99i@%C4%8Dechy.example > > I think this doesn't match your ABNF I think the ABNF should be: > > Jabber-ID = SP [FWS] pathxmpp [FWS] CRLF Thanks for the correction. Do most of the header field definitions allow folding white space? I was trying to make it consistent with general practices, but I admit that I last looked at this almost 6 years ago. I'll check some of the header fields that are registered with IANA. > For your convenience, the definition of FWS is quoted below: > > FWS = ([*WSP CRLF] 1*WSP) / obs-FWS ; Folding white > space > > I would also make the leading SP optional. While Netnews spec > decide to make this explicit, software should cope with the lack of > it. (But I don't feel strongly about the leading SP, most software > always insert it anyway.) I agree that applying Postel's law here would be appropriate. Peter - -- Peter Saint-Andre https://stpeter.im/ -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG/MacGPG2 v2.0.19 (Darwin) Comment: GPGTools - http://gpgtools.org Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://www.enigmail.net/ iQIcBAEBAgAGBQJSQFPyAAoJEOoGpJErxa2pjMIP/08rovIor+/qvsxM+1O7Z8IP tvGhvH6eIaLHmpVJ7fNyjc778BGP67dXcEKNsA5wh2HoLX5+kXwModTnp7BrhD3f S41UGYdmf6wAbsw7GUUvHrCSKEDPxRDKREfCIyI3AidElR4CqJbZz+sF1iPznlkB l+Ao+F/V/H0PChxhmD7WsRRn1c+EArnNfL5MNTh65wN3n1qrpV/QxBk2LZd6z7Ql QLlSm0LVy12nYSqmB+3ba4RGA6zMk27WrghqWlfhu49BvGroLG4gA+kEBfUKve+v j6dy1QatiiLI+CfM3Y0/UoyjPJvKUIvvayxobGGEZ+9ZKE6wlkMNuu3YIFrx/ukI SfEWvkCSxB+upo8TuX5XdtySrVvGYZd7N/pYXdHYYssERpEKuMZF3EcQF5I63Irx E0rO5rExPlhDAmaUkwV6g3weddJH3+W4OI4Que74F/5gAhWRe1g1tZ/8Sfq+3ax4 /C4N2YOMyRE7DyqvD30EU7S38/YaJBLTmCt5QNaSEx95dXQ47IXwPlN41cCHuVK5 UgsbMZgKo2gtzG94YXSP+xepYV9SAYX1Mp4T7B0p5zuwq1KzX5inUxsBFqzTrSv6 XJa0M3t6LZD2Qb0Ze2wvqlR5PVnyBUVbTKgckLXYm2zNjjSr3Zv1wpD9VpxYn3oF BG/+xbWWyD0Tr3GxGFBq =4Ar2 -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
