On 2/28/18 2:49 AM, Kevin Smith wrote: > On 27 Feb 2018, at 16:21, Peter Saint-Andre <[email protected]> wrote: >> >> On 2/27/18 5:40 AM, Tedd Sterr wrote: >>> For reference, XEPs that list the given XEP as a dependency (to what >>> extent they actually make use of it is another matter): >> >> Thanks. Further comments inline. >> >>> *XEP-0020 (Feature Negotiation; Draft; 2006-11-21)* >>> - XEP-0041 (Reliable Entity Link; Retra) >>> - XEP-0052 (File Transfer; Retra) >>> - XEP-0116 (Encrypted Session Negotiation; Defer) >>> - XEP-0155 (Stanza Session Negotiation; Draft) >>> - XEP-0187 (Offline Encrypted Sessions; Defer) >>> - XEP-0217 (Simplified Encrypted Session Negotiation; Defer) >> >> Encrypted sessions should be obsoleted, too. > > +1 > >>> *XEP-0048 (Bookmarks; Draft; 2007-11-07)* >>> - XEP-0387 (XMPP Compliance Suites 2018; Draft) >>> >>> *XEP-0059 (Result Set Management; Draft; 2006-09-20)* >>> - XEP-0060 (Publish-Subscribe; Draft) >> >> We could look at the usage in pubsub and see if it's really needed. But >> I seem to recall a dependency in XEP-0045 too. > > I thought we were talking about Finalling 59, not Obsoleting it. It’s > absolutely core to 313.
Right. >>> - XEP-0136 (Message Archiving; Depre) >>> - XEP-0313 (Message Archive Management; Exper) >>> - XEP-0329 (File Information Sharing; Defer) >>> >>> *XEP-0066 (Out of Band Data; Draft; 2006-08-16)* >>> - XEP-0129 (WebDAV File Transfers; Defer) >>> - XEP-0158 (CAPTCHA Forms; Draft) >> >> The XEP-0158 reference was there for backward-compatibility and could be >> removed if we want to modernize CAPTCHA forms. > > We do we need to remove the reference from 158 if we’re moving 66 to Final? > Draft specs depending on Final is fine. Moving 66 OOB Data to Final seems good. >>> *XEP-0092 (Software Version; Draft; 2007-02-15)* >>> - (none listed) >> >> This is widely implemented AFAIK. > > Yes, may as well Final. > >>> *XEP-0122 (Data Forms Validation; Draft; 2004-09-22)* >>> - XEP-0325 (Internet of Things - Control; Retra) >>> - XEP-0326 (Internet of Things - Concentrators; Retra) >>> - XEP-0331 (Data Forms - Color Field Types; Defer) >>> - XEP-0350 (Data Forms Geolocation Element; Defer) >> >> Safe to obsolete. > > I think in your other mail you suggest Finalling 122, not obsoleting it. It’s > used, so I think Obsoleting would be wrong. > >>> *XEP-0141 (Data Forms Layout; Draft; 2005-05-12)* >>> - XEP-0325 (Internet of Things - Control; Retra) >>> - XEP-0326 (Internet of Things - Concentrators; Retra) >> >> Safe to obsolete. > > I don’t see why we’d obsolete 141 either. Because I thought people wanted to aggressively prune the list of specs that developers need to wade through. Moving these to Final instead seems OK. Peter
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________ Standards mailing list Info: https://mail.jabber.org/mailman/listinfo/standards Unsubscribe: [email protected] _______________________________________________
