> 2) PR #706 - Update BCP 14 language to comply with RFC 8174 - > https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/706
I have to wonder whether "an implementation must" could mean anything different from "an implementation MUST" -- how else could it be interpreted? Would 'must' mean it's actually not mandatory, but 'MUST' does? I've always considered the upper-casing as little more than highlighting/emphasis. Anyway, one dirty Python program later, and it doesn't look like the most fun task for anyone (even considering only 'current' XEPs.) But from a quick look, most usage doesn't appear likely normative. Dump follows… Format is: - one section per status (Active, Final, Draft, Proposed, Experimental) - list of RFC-2119 magic words (upper and lower-case versions), with total counts for the section - list of XEPs containing lower-case instances, and counts for each of those - (negated-phrase counts are not separated, e.g. "MAY" is for both "MAY" and "MAY NOT") ** Active ** MAY 102 MUST 145 OPTIONAL 4 RECOMMENDED 21 REQUIRED 3 SHALL 3 SHOULD 251 may 210 must 62 optional 5 recommended 17 required 12 shall 111 should 48 XEP-0001 required=1, should=10, must=31, may=43, shall=39, recommended=2 XEP-0002 must=1, may=4, shall=1 XEP-0019 should=1, may=2 XEP-0049 may=1 XEP-0053 should=1, must=3, may=7, shall=38 XEP-0054 should=2, must=1, may=3 XEP-0055 required=1, shall=1 XEP-0068 should=2, must=8, shall=1, recommended=1 XEP-0076 may=1, shall=1 XEP-0082 should=1, shall=1, recommended=1, optional=2 XEP-0083 should=3 XEP-0100 required=3, should=1, must=3, may=17, recommended=1 XEP-0114 may=1 XEP-0127 may=1 XEP-0128 must=2, may=4 XEP-0132 may=7, shall=11, recommended=2, optional=1 XEP-0133 may=46, shall=2 XEP-0134 should=1, must=5, may=3, shall=1 XEP-0143 required=3, should=5, must=1, may=8, recommended=1, optional=1 XEP-0145 required=1 XEP-0147 should=1, may=2, recommended=1 XEP-0148 may=5, shall=1 XEP-0149 should=1, may=9 XEP-0153 should=1, may=2, recommended=1 XEP-0157 required=1, should=1, may=9 XEP-0160 may=3, shall=1 XEP-0169 should=1, must=1 XEP-0170 may=2, shall=1, recommended=1 XEP-0178 shall=1, recommended=1 XEP-0182 required=1, may=3 XEP-0183 may=4, shall=2 XEP-0185 should=1, recommended=1 XEP-0201 should=1, shall=3 XEP-0205 required=1, must=2, may=12, recommended=2 XEP-0207 should=3, may=2, shall=1 XEP-0222 must=2, may=1, shall=1 XEP-0223 must=1, may=1, shall=1 XEP-0239 may=1, shall=2 XEP-0245 recommended=1 XEP-0263 shall=1 XEP-0286 should=8, must=1, may=3, recommended=1, optional=1 XEP-0295 should=3, may=3 ** Final ** MAY 75 MUST 195 OPTIONAL 8 RECOMMENDED 10 REQUIRED 7 SHOULD 143 may 41 must 6 optional 10 recommended 10 required 18 shall 8 should 19 XEP-0004 required=2, should=9, must=1, may=8, shall=1 XEP-0012 shall=2 XEP-0030 required=1, should=1, must=3, may=17, optional=1 XEP-0047 shall=2 XEP-0077 required=14, should=2, must=2, may=4, shall=2, recommended=1 XEP-0138 may=5 XEP-0174 required=1, recommended=7, optional=8 XEP-0199 should=2, may=2, shall=1 XEP-0202 should=3, may=5, recommended=1, optional=1 XEP-0203 should=2, recommended=1 ** Draft ** MAY 544 MUST 1499 OPTIONAL 53 RECOMMENDED 99 REQUIRED 44 SHALL 11 SHOULD 841 may 284 must 50 optional 19 recommended 25 required 64 shall 117 should 102 XEP-0013 required=1, should=1, must=1, may=2 XEP-0033 should=2, must=1, may=1, shall=1 XEP-0045 required=11, should=3, must=6, may=18, shall=19, recommended=1, optional=4 XEP-0048 should=2, may=2, recommended=1 XEP-0050 required=5, should=7, may=5 XEP-0059 should=2, may=4, shall=3 XEP-0060 required=7, should=2, must=4, may=79, shall=14, recommended=1, optional=1 XEP-0065 required=2, shall=2, optional=1 XEP-0066 must=1, recommended=1, optional=2 XEP-0070 should=1, may=3, shall=3 XEP-0072 required=8, should=5, must=3, may=17, recommended=2, optional=1 XEP-0079 should=3, may=5, shall=5 XEP-0080 may=1, shall=5 XEP-0084 may=1, shall=1 XEP-0092 required=1, may=1 XEP-0106 required=1, should=4, may=14, shall=2, optional=2 XEP-0107 should=1, may=1, shall=1 XEP-0108 should=1, may=2, shall=1 XEP-0115 required=2, should=2, must=9, may=7, shall=2, recommended=1 XEP-0118 should=2, may=2, shall=1 XEP-0122 should=5, may=5, shall=6 XEP-0124 required=3, should=3, must=1, optional=1 XEP-0131 must=1, may=13 XEP-0141 required=1, may=4 XEP-0144 required=2, should=6, may=4, recommended=2 XEP-0152 shall=1 XEP-0155 required=6, should=1, must=5, may=26, shall=3 XEP-0156 shall=1 XEP-0158 required=3, should=4, must=3, may=8, shall=2 XEP-0163 must=2, may=4, shall=5 XEP-0166 shall=7, recommended=10, optional=1 XEP-0167 shall=8 XEP-0171 required=3, should=5, must=1, may=1, recommended=2, optional=1 XEP-0172 may=1, shall=1 XEP-0176 shall=2, optional=1 XEP-0177 required=1, shall=1 XEP-0184 shall=2 XEP-0191 required=2, should=2, must=1, may=1, shall=6 XEP-0198 should=1, may=1 XEP-0206 required=1, should=1, may=1 XEP-0220 should=2, must=1, shall=1 XEP-0221 may=1, recommended=1, optional=1 XEP-0227 should=1, may=5 XEP-0231 must=1, may=1, optional=1 XEP-0233 should=3, must=1, may=1, shall=1 XEP-0249 shall=2 XEP-0258 should=12, must=1, may=26, optional=1 XEP-0260 shall=6 XEP-0288 should=1, may=2 XEP-0293 required=2, should=1 XEP-0297 should=10, must=1, may=2 XEP-0301 required=2, must=2, may=7, shall=1, recommended=3, optional=1 XEP-0308 should=1, must=1, may=3 XEP-0319 shall=1 XEP-0368 should=4, may=1 XEP-0387 should=1, must=3, may=1 ** Proposed ** MAY 32 MUST 77 OPTIONAL 7 RECOMMENDED 5 SHOULD 46 may 8 must 2 optional 1 required 6 shall 21 should 6 XEP-0186 required=1, shall=5 XEP-0234 required=1, shall=4, optional=1 XEP-0280 required=2, should=1, must=1, may=3, shall=1 XEP-0352 required=1, should=1, must=1, may=2 XEP-0363 required=1, should=1, may=2, shall=1 XEP-0381 should=3, may=1, shall=10 ** Experimental ** MAY 169 MUST 374 OPTIONAL 7 RECOMMENDED 12 REQUIRED 9 SHALL 6 SHOULD 128 may 80 must 27 optional 8 recommended 6 required 14 shall 3 should 59 XEP-0283 should=1, may=2, shall=1 XEP-0300 should=1, must=1, shall=1, recommended=1 XEP-0313 required=3, should=10, must=4, may=16, optional=1 XEP-0335 should=3, must=1 XEP-0369 should=2, must=1, may=7, recommended=2, optional=4 XEP-0373 required=3, should=10, must=2, may=8, optional=1 XEP-0384 may=2 XEP-0385 should=2, may=3, recommended=1 XEP-0391 should=1, must=1 XEP-0392 should=5, must=4, may=4 XEP-0393 required=2, should=3, may=18 XEP-0394 may=3 XEP-0395 shall=1 XEP-0396 must=1 XEP-0397 required=2, should=2, must=5, may=1, optional=1 XEP-0398 should=1 XEP-0399 may=3 XEP-0400 required=1, should=3 XEP-0401 should=6, must=3, may=3 XEP-0402 should=2 XEP-0403 required=1, should=1, must=2, may=4 XEP-0404 may=1 XEP-0406 required=2, must=1, optional=1 XEP-0407 should=2, may=2, recommended=2 XEP-0408 may=1 XEP-0409 should=1, must=1 XEP-0410 should=3, may=2
_______________________________________________ Standards mailing list Info: https://mail.jabber.org/mailman/listinfo/standards Unsubscribe: [email protected] _______________________________________________
