Fellow Shadow Watchers

John Carmichael raised the issue of passing on the skills needed for dial 
making in 'resistant materials' and gave me cause to reflect on how I do what I 
do.

Forty five years ago I received an extremely thorough training for my job 
within a tradition that began with William Morris and the British 'Arts & 
Crafts Movement' of Victorian times. As a teacher I began my career engendering 
enthusiasm in schoolboys (no girls in those days - they were learning Domestic 
Science) for the application of skill in the working of wood and metal.  In 
wood it was usually some aspect of furniture making but I could never resist 
more exciting things and I recall one intense midnight session with pupils and 
parents viewing the moon through our newly-completed astronomical telescope. 
(made and figured the 6" mirror - boast, boast!!) It had an octagonal wooden 
tube supported on zinc alloy castings and drive mechanism melted from scrap car 
door handles in an iron saucepan on a gas ring contributed by a pupil's 
grandmother.

In metalwork it was was a struggle to progress from 
'tools-to-make-tools-to-make-tools etc.' but eventually 'Technology' was born 
in which the 'brightest and best', studying Maths/Physics/Chemistry at 'A' 
Level, sought real application for their scientific knowledge in live project 
work.  It was making printed circuits for the necessary electronic content 
which interested me in photo-etching at that stage.

Over the following twenty years training teachers to do likewise I witnessed a 
mass exodus from skills teaching in schools and then in the University 
department where I contibuted some teaching - which was once staffed by highly 
skilled craftsmen at both lecturer and technician level.  Today it is 
struggling to find any kind of trained practitioner so that it now employs last 
year's students as this year's teachers and has reached the point where a 
member of staff in charge of workshops freely admits he has no experience of 
the equipment for which he is responsible.  There's no safety problem however 
because machines now stand idle while students pursue solutions in cardboard 
and car body filler!

Skills 'babies' were 'thrown out with the bathwater' of a new 
'all-design-and-no-craft- dogmatism' in schools.  Nowadays boys and girls 
'design' (for me 'the highest activity of the cultivated mind') things which 
are rarely makeable, from a knowledge/experience base of little or nothing on 
how things go together. This skills vacuum is evident at many levels and has 
probably only been concealed by the fact that CNC machines are now doing much 
that craftsmen did hitherto.

In areas where output is miniscule, such as sundial making, computers are not 
yet a viable option so it falls upon we 'skills dinosaurs' to keep a flickering 
flame alive.  But how to do it?  Motivation is the primary factor as the road 
is neither short nor easy.  There is, however, one worldwide community of 
similar 'skills dinosaurs' which can help in the remaining years before their 
own feared extinction comes about.  I refer of course to 'model engineers' who 
are typically retired craftsmen, with the odd consultant surgeon etc. thrown 
in, who now have the freedom to make things for their own pleasure.  They have 
generated a market for small-scale machine tools and necessary hobby magazines 
which support it. e.g. 'Model Engineers' Workshop' (UK but available in US).  
As a group they are approachable and always willing to pass on what they know 
through local clubs etc.  Take care however or you may find yourself building 
steam engines rather than sundials as their enthusias!
 m is infectious.  There is a Model Engineer email 'mailing list' but it is so 
busy I couldn't afford the time to read all the postings.

It crossed my mind that a series of short videos actually showing the different 
stages and processes involved in metal dial making (and stone too John C.) 
might have a rĂ´le to play but that will have to wait until I retire for the 
third time. Would such a package even recover the cost of production I wonder?  
I'd be interested to have some responses.

If this all sounds rather negative I think there is due cause.  The answer lies 
with those who are motivated to pick up the flickering torch, re-kindle it and 
pass it on to keep precious skills alive.  How I would love to spend a week in 
the workshops of Yeates & Son, Instrument Makers of Dublin back in the 1800s to 
see how they did it!  I can only guess!


Tony Moss. 

P.S.  There was one positive thing that came out of the exodus by schools from 
'the dark satanic mills' of engineering, blacksmithing and the like. I 
purchased several of my own machine tools from their unwanted workshops for 
less than the price of a new hat for my wife for the whole lot!  Almost-new 
shaping machines were being sent to the rubbish tip.  "Anvils? - blacksmith's 
tools?  Just bring a truck and help yourself! - they're free!"  I could have 
wept!

Reply via email to