Dear John and all,

Quite an interesting idea!
I wondered how the terminator on a sea-side building looks like. In 
particular, is it sharp enough to enable the proposed observations?
Is there perhaps a YouTube movie showing the terminator?
And would atmospheric refraction come into play somehow?

Best regards,
Frans Maes

JOHN DAVIS wrote:
> 
> Dear Dialling Colleagues,
>  
> I'm forwarding this message from another mailing list as I believe it 
> may be of interest to all sun-watchers. Mathematicians amongst you might 
> like to work out the details of the 'fudge factor'.
>  
> Regards,
>  
> John
> ---------------------------------------
> 
> Dr J Davis
> Flowton Dials
> 
> --- On *Sun, 1/3/09, Brian Whatcott /<[email protected]>/* wrote:
> 
>     From: Brian Whatcott <[email protected]>
>     Subject: [rete] Experimental Method for Earth Radius
>     To: [email protected], [email protected]
>     Date: Sunday, 1 March, 2009, 4:38 AM
> 
>     I am relaying this note from a physics teachers list, believing it may be 
> of
>     interest to you.   For me, it carried the same kind of frisson as reading 
> about
>     Harrison's stellar transit method  for timing chronometers.
> 
>     Brian W
> 
>     David Bowman wrote:
>     > I've come up with a fairly simple means of measuring/calculating
>     > the size of the earth using only local measurements (not requiring
>     > multiple sightings at far away locations like Eratothenes' method
>     > needs).
>     >  The idea is to observe and time the motion of the terminator at
>     > sunset/sunrise ascending or descending the face of a building,
>     > pole, or other tall structure with an exposed vertical face.  It
>     > is a fairly simple exercize in trigonometry to realize that if one
>     > is situated on the equator during an equinox that the terminator
>     > ascends vertically at sunset and descends vertically at sunrise
>     > with a constant acceleration that is related to the rotation rate
>     > of the earth and the radius of the earth.  In this situation it is
>     > a high school-level calculation to see that if a is the vertical
>     > acceleration of the terminator then the radius R of the earth is
>     >  R = a*(T/(2*[pi]))^2
>     >  where T is the duration of one solar day.
>     >  If the observing location is not on the equator then there is a
>     > correction for the local latitude of the observer.  And if the
>     > time of observation is not during an equinox then there is another
>     > correction involving the declination of the sun due to the
>     > tilted path of the sunrise/sunset at the horizon.  Figuring out
>     > these corrections is *not* at the high school level, but they
>     > don't involve anything more than a lot of complicated
>     > trigonometry.  The date/place corrected formula involving these
>     > corrections is
>     >  R*F = a*(T/(2*[pi]))^2
>     >  where F is a fudge factor that depends on the complications.
>     > According to my calculations, the explicit value of F is
>     >  F = cos^2(D) + sin^2(L)*(cos^2(D) - tan^2(D))
>     >  where D is the declination of the sun on the date of observation
>     > and L is the local latitude of the observation.
>     >  The actual value of a, being only a few cm/s^2, is plenty slow
>     > enough for easy observation of motion of the terminator up or down
>     > the observing wall using a wristwatch.  To get the acceleration only
>     > a few timings are needed between some fiducial marks on the wall
>     > whose separation distance is measured.
>     >  BTW, in order for the method to work properly the horizon needs
>     > to be an unobstructed 'true' horizon that accurately represents
>     the
>     > effectively smoothed surface of the earth.  This means that the
>     > observation ought to be done along a seacoast or the coast of a
>     > great lake that can't be seen across from the top of the observing
>     > wall.  For those whose budgets are unlimited this means that a field
>     > trip to Miami Beach for the purpose of observing the sunrise on the
>     > beachfront hotels would make a very nice educational experience.
>     >  David Bowman
>     > _______________________________________________
>     > Forum for Physics Educators
>     > [email protected]
>     > https://carnot.physics.buffalo.edu/mailman/listinfo/phys-l
>     > 
>     >   
> 
> 
>     Do not reply to this message UNLESS you want to reply to the whole list.
>     ---------------------------------------------------------------------
>     To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
>     For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
> 
> 
> 
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
> 
> ---------------------------------------------------
> https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial
> 
---------------------------------------------------
https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial

Reply via email to