It is interesting to extend Fritz's calculations to t=120 sec when A=0.5 deg and H=804 ft. Assuming that the diameter of the sun is 0.5 deg, this indicates the extent of the sun's penumbra so that any portion of the building above 804 ft in the original problem would be fully illuminated as the green flash is observed from ground level. This suggests that the very gradual transition from light to shadow would make the proposed method impracticable. However, the timing of the green flash or more probably the disappearance of the upper limb of the sun by two vertically-separated observers should work. This would be an excellent school project for the International Year of Astronomy.
Geoff -----Original Message----- From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Fritz Stumpges Sent: 04 March 2009 18:34 To: [email protected]; JOHN DAVIS Cc: [email protected] Subject: RE: Experimental Method for Earth Radius Hi All, I apologize if someone has already answered this thread, here or in previous posts; and even more if it has nothing to do with the green flash and seeing it again on another floor a short time later. I think that one way to see it is that the earth is turning at an approximately constant 15 degrees per hour, or A degrees / T time. The shadow going up the building will be rising up in relation to the cosine of this angle. For simplicity all of this has to be imagined at the equator, because at the poles the sun might not be rising or setting. Imagine two lines, R, coming from the center of the earth, one follows or stays with the sun's point of tangency, the other line stays at the building and grows H in height. The formula is simple: R/(R+H)=cosA OR H=(R-R*CosA)/cosA Where R = 4,000 miles (approx at equator) or 21,120,000 ft and A deg = T sec * .00416667, (15deg/hr) Then at T = 60 sec; A=.250deg and H = 201ft 30 sec; A=.125deg and H = 50ft 10 sec; A=.041deg and H = 5.6ft So it does seem that someone could climb a 5 story, 50 ft building in 30 seconds and see the green flash again (or still). I wonder if one were in a programmed glass elevator at the beach and it started up at the right speed in a 20 floor building, you could watch the same green flash for 1 minute! I hope I'm not way off on this thread or calculations, I'm supposed to be working!! Fritz -----Original Message----- From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]]on Behalf Of Frans W. Maes Sent: Wednesday, March 04, 2009 1:00 AM To: JOHN DAVIS Cc: [email protected] Subject: Re: Experimental Method for Earth Radius Dear John & all, Imagine a building on a west-coast seaside resort. As the sun sets, the terminator (the shadow of the horizon) creeps slowly up its wall. It takes only two lines of elementary geometry to proof that the height of the shadow increses with the SQUARE of the time. Mathematically expressed: the terminator travels up at a constant acceleration. That is the basic idea behind David Bowman's procedure quoted in John Davis' posting. So far, so good; if not brilliant! What I find counter-intuitive, though, is the following. Standing beside the building, we see the sun disappearing behind the horizon at a CONSTANT rate. On the other hand, if we would want to keep the last sliver of sun in sight, we would have to climb the building's stairs at an ever INCREASING rate. So, where is my intuition led astray? Best regards, Frans Maes JOHN DAVIS wrote: > > Dear Dialling Colleagues, > > I'm forwarding this message from another mailing list as I believe it > may be of interest to all sun-watchers. Mathematicians amongst you > might like to work out the details of the 'fudge factor'. > > Regards, > > John > --------------------------------------- > > Dr J Davis > Flowton Dials > > --- On *Sun, 1/3/09, Brian Whatcott /<[email protected]>/* wrote: > > From: Brian Whatcott <[email protected]> > Subject: [rete] Experimental Method for Earth Radius > To: [email protected], [email protected] > Date: Sunday, 1 March, 2009, 4:38 AM > > I am relaying this note from a physics teachers list, believing it may be of > interest to you. For me, it carried the same kind of frisson as reading about > Harrison's stellar transit method for timing chronometers. > > Brian W > > David Bowman wrote: > > I've come up with a fairly simple means of measuring/calculating > > the size of the earth using only local measurements (not requiring > > multiple sightings at far away locations like Eratothenes' method > > needs). > > The idea is to observe and time the motion of the terminator at > > sunset/sunrise ascending or descending the face of a building, > > pole, or other tall structure with an exposed vertical face. It > > is a fairly simple exercize in trigonometry to realize that if one > > is situated on the equator during an equinox that the terminator > > ascends vertically at sunset and descends vertically at sunrise > > with a constant acceleration that is related to the rotation rate > > of the earth and the radius of the earth. In this situation it is > > a high school-level calculation to see that if a is the vertical > > acceleration of the terminator then the radius R of the earth is > > R = a*(T/(2*[pi]))^2 > > where T is the duration of one solar day. > > If the observing location is not on the equator then there is a > > correction for the local latitude of the observer. And if the > > time of observation is not during an equinox then there is another > > correction involving the declination of the sun due to the > > tilted path of the sunrise/sunset at the horizon. Figuring out > > these corrections is *not* at the high school level, but they > > don't involve anything more than a lot of complicated > > trigonometry. The date/place corrected formula involving these > > corrections is > > R*F = a*(T/(2*[pi]))^2 > > where F is a fudge factor that depends on the complications. > > According to my calculations, the explicit value of F is > > F = cos^2(D) + sin^2(L)*(cos^2(D) - tan^2(D)) > > where D is the declination of the sun on the date of observation > > and L is the local latitude of the observation. > > The actual value of a, being only a few cm/s^2, is plenty slow > > enough for easy observation of motion of the terminator up or down > > the observing wall using a wristwatch. To get the acceleration only > > a few timings are needed between some fiducial marks on the wall > > whose separation distance is measured. > > BTW, in order for the method to work properly the horizon needs > > to be an unobstructed 'true' horizon that accurately represents > the > > effectively smoothed surface of the earth. This means that the > > observation ought to be done along a seacoast or the coast of a > > great lake that can't be seen across from the top of the observing > > wall. For those whose budgets are unlimited this means that a field > > trip to Miami Beach for the purpose of observing the sunrise on the > > beachfront hotels would make a very nice educational experience. > > David Bowman > > _______________________________________________ > > Forum for Physics Educators > > [email protected] > > https://carnot.physics.buffalo.edu/mailman/listinfo/phys-l > > > > > > > Do not reply to this message UNLESS you want to reply to the whole list. > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] > For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected] > > > > ---------------------------------------------------------------------- > -- > > --------------------------------------------------- > https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial > --------------------------------------------------- https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial --------------------------------------------------- https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial --------------------------------------------------- https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial
