Hi Roger & all:
I agreed with everything Roger said. Translucent stone is bad and shiny stainless steel is bad. Ive seen that with my own eyes. But my highly polished non-translucent (opaque) beige and brown sandstone dials show a great shadow! So maybe shiny stainless steel has some quality that makes shadows less visible than shiny opaque stone. Shiny porcelain and shiny opaque glass also show great shadows. But watch out for shiny transparent glass! There is no shadow at all! I was reminded of that by this sad story- When I saw this photo of a really nice new stained glass sundial at at Móra Ferenc High School in Kiskunfélegyháza Hungary I immediately saw the disaster. Its Hungarys first SGS and it is our Sundial of the Month at Stained Glass Sundials: http://www.stainedglasssundials.com <http://www.stainedglasssundials.com/> I felt so sorry for all the people involved in making this handsome dial, because after it was all installed on an expensive iron base and a beautiful stone tower, they all quickly realized that there was no shadow because they had used transparent clear colored glass. If only they had shadow tested the glass before they made it! Look at the photo- You can see there is no shadow. But Realizing this, the designer has recently corrected the problem by adding an opal lacquer layer to the top side. (I think a layer of frosted glass would have been better since its more durable than laquer). Here are some links to more photos of it: Photos Origin: courtesy of Géza Marton taken June 14, 2006 Original Photos: a <http://www.advanceassociates.com/Sundials/Stained_Glass/sundials_files/Stai nedGlassSundial146aoriginal.jpg> , b <http://www.advanceassociates.com/Sundials/Stained_Glass/sundials_files/Stai nedGlassSundial146boriginal.jpg> , c <http://www.advanceassociates.com/Sundials/Stained_Glass/sundials_files/Stai nedGlassSundial146coriginal.jpg> , d <http://www.advanceassociates.com/Sundials/Stained_Glass/sundials_files/Stai nedGlassSundial146doriginal.jpg> , e <http://www.advanceassociates.com/Sundials/Stained_Glass/sundials_files/Stai nedGlassSundial146eoriginal.jpg> , f <http://www.advanceassociates.com/Sundials/Stained_Glass/sundials_files/Stai nedGlassSundial146foriginal.jpg> , g <http://www.advanceassociates.com/Sundials/Stained_Glass/sundials_files/Stai nedGlassSundial146goriginal.jpg> , h <http://www.advanceassociates.com/Sundials/Stained_Glass/sundials_files/Stai nedGlassSundial146horiginal.jpg> , i <http://www.advanceassociates.com/Sundials/Stained_Glass/sundials_files/Stai nedGlassSundial146ioriginal.jpg> , j <http://www.advanceassociates.com/Sundials/Stained_Glass/sundials_files/Stai nedGlassSundial146joriginal.jpg> , k <http://www.advanceassociates.com/Sundials/Stained_Glass/sundials_files/Stai nedGlassSundial146koriginal.jpg> , l <http://www.advanceassociates.com/Sundials/Stained_Glass/sundials_files/Stai nedGlassSundial146loriginal.jpg> , m <http://www.advanceassociates.com/Sundials/Stained_Glass/sundials_files/Stai nedGlassSundial146moriginal.jpg> John L. Carmichael Sundial Sculptures 925 E. Foothills Dr. Tucson AZ 85718-4716 USA Tel: 520-6961709 Email: <mailto:[email protected]> [email protected] My Websites: (business) Sundial Sculptures: http://www.sundialsculptures.com <http://www.sundialsculptures.com/> (educational) Chinook Trail Sundial: http://advanceassociates.com/Sundials/COSprings/ (educational) Earth & Sky Equatorial Sundial: http://advanceassociates.com/Sundials/Earth-Sky_Dial/ (educational) My Painted Wall Sundial: http://www.advanceassociates.com/WallDial (educational) Painted Wall Sundials: http://advanceassociates.com/WallDial/PWS_Home.html (educational) Stained Glass Sundials: http://www.stainedglasssundials.com <http://www.stainedglasssundials.com/> (educational) Sundial Cupolas, Towers & Turrets: http://StainedGlassSundials.com/CupolaSundial/index.html From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Roger Bailey Sent: Tuesday, March 17, 2009 8:43 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Translucence You may think, as I did, that white marble is an ideal base material for a sundial. The rock is relatively easy to engrave; the white surface should provide good contrast for the shadow. This is not necessarily so. I found from tests with a prototype that the translucence of marble, that wonderful milky quality so favoured by sculptors, does not show high contrast shadows. The light from the bright areas seems to diffuse to the shaded zone and the shadow contrast can be greatly reduced. The effect is similar to the shadow formed on a hazy day when thin clouds diffuse the sunlight. My prototype was a marble tile, 30 cm square, 1 cm thick. I could see the outline of my hand through the rock. One side was polished and glossy, the other a rough matte finish. The glossy surface of the translucent material did not show high contrast shadows even in bright sunlight. The matte finish was significantly better but still the contrast was lower that the shadow of a white piece of paper. The prototype was a sunset sundial and the shadows approaching sunset tend to be diffused. The translucent base made them invisible. This experiment reminded me of a previous experience with stainless steel. Again the shadow contrast on the shiny surface was poor. Shiny and translucent? Both are bad for shadow contrast. Regards, Roger Bailey www.walkingshadow.info
--------------------------------------------------- https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial
