Hello Detlev,

DH> I read very often, it is better for the perfomance to disallow
DH> autonegociation.
It might be "better" to reduce lags at link-up events,
but since autoneg takes under a second, this bonus can
usually be disregarded.

What's usually more noticeable is the 15- or 30-second
lag due to spanning-tree protocol (STP). It checks at
link-up event whether you have ethernet loops (i.e.
the newly-up device is a hub), because the standard
Ethernet topology is a star, and STP disables the
least-priority port in the loop (if there is one).
This allows to have redundant physical links while
not breaking classic ethernet logic (link-aggregation
is usually better, though).

For example, recent Cisco Catalyst switches have
spanning-tree checks enabled by default. This often
causes DHCP-boot timeouts (the client gives up before
the port actually begins transmitting). For this
reason STP can be disabled on per-port basis by:
  spanning-tree portfast trunk
or
  spanning-tree portfast
depending on the link's switchport mode (VLAN trunk
or access mode).

It's meant to be disabled only on the ports which are
known to be end-user devices and nobody would plug a
hub or switch into a couple of these "portfast" ports.

If you do use manual speed/duplex settings instead of
autonegotiation, make sure both sides use the same
settings, otherwise expect the autoneg device to drop
down to half-duplex - as per standard. This can usually
be noticed as the connection still works, but is very
lossy and slow (local downloads run at approx 1Mbps
on 100Mbps network).

In fact, half-duplex settings (either manual or due
to autonegotiation vs fixed settings) can be used in
short term to work around broken NICs or cables.
We had some cables chewed by mice or stamped by
heavy furniture in the university campus network
I managed. While it was not always quick to lay
down new cable (because of manual-negotiating with
the hostel management ;) ), it was often helpful to
re-crimp RJ45 jacks and perhaps revert to half-duplex
if only 2 wires of the cable remain intact.

-- 
Best regards,
 Jim Klimov                            mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

_______________________________________________
SunRay-Users mailing list
[email protected]
http://www.filibeto.org/mailman/listinfo/sunray-users

Reply via email to