Arne wrote:

> David E. Ross wrote:
>> On 4/6/10 2:40 AM, Arne wrote:
>>> David E. Ross wrote:
>>>> On 4/5/10 9:14 AM, Walter wrote:
>>>>> I click on a pdf file and adobe reader loads it ok. directly
>>>>> behind it is a blank page. shouldn't it be the page from which I
>>>>> came? with the link to the pdf page?
>>>> 
>>>> I get this sometimes when the link is actually for JavaScript. 
>>>> The script tries to launch a new page (which in my case becomes a
>>>> new tab) as it fetches the PDF file.  It seems that the script
>>>> actually downloads another script (new page) that, in turn, gets
>>>> the PDF file.  Obviously, if this is what is happening, it's a
>>>> poorly designed Web site.
>>> 
>>> In my opinion there is no need at all for SM to open a blank
>>> tab/page when it's the PDF reader that is launched, no matter how
>>> the web page is designed! Why not just open the PDF reader?
>> 
>> It's not the launching of the PDF reader that throws up the blank
>> page. It's the JavaScript that thinks the PDF file will be viewed in
>> a browser window.  However, the PDF file is served by a MIME type
>> that instead requires a separate PDF reader.  As I said before, it's
>> the result of a poorly designed Web page.
> 
> Okay, then give me a link to a site with downloadable PDF-files where
> this don't happen. Sure there must be at least one you have found,
> and even that would be one more than I know about.

I publish monthly newsletters for a club website which the editor
supplies in PDF format. My pages use simple links to the files:

   <a href="../news/news201003.pdf">March 2010</a>

and no 'extra tab or window' is opened by SeaMonkey, Firefox, Opera.
When I click on the link, I get a dialog asking if I want to Open or
Download. Choosing Open loads it in my default PDF reader Evince. No new
tabs in the browsers.

I'd let you test, except these are in a passworded members only portion
of the web site.

> I have also still to find a PDF file that *requires* a separate PDF
> reader. Only in IE (v.8) I have no clue how to prevent PDF's from
> opening within the browser window, but since I don't use IE I don't
> care. ;) 

Tell IE to remove the PDF file association?

> I believe it is the code within SM that cause this, not the site.
> When SM can't decide if the pref settings are set to open within the
> SM tab/page or within the stand alone PDF reader.

I think it is the individual coding of the page containing the link.
Regardless of browser.



-- 
   -bts
   -Four wheels carry the body; two wheels move the soul
_______________________________________________
support-seamonkey mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/support-seamonkey

Reply via email to