On Monday 22 October 2007 13:41, Ugo Bellavance wrote: > Chris Kratz wrote: > > Unfortunately, in this case, neither up nor down ever goes into the VOIP > > Queues. > > > > So, it would be really helpful for me to be able to figure out why these > > packets aren't getting caught by these 4 rules. Any ideas? Am I missing > > something stupid? > > > > It's hard to tell for sure with other traffic on the T1, but it appears > > that the "Up" traffice goes through the qwandef queue which is fed by > > rules further down the list. > > Are you sure traffic shaper works even with bridge? I think I saw > somewhere (in the wizard i think) it doesn't. > > Ugo
Hello Ugo, Yes, there is a warning in this release cantidate that traffic shaping doesn't work. But our VOIP is definately better then it was when our T1 is under heavy load. The web interface indicates data is flowing through the various queues. So, I believe it's working. I guess the larger question is that it seems like it's really hard to figure out why a particular set of packets are not flowing into a queue. You can put logging on a queue, but there doesn't seem to be a way to have a log for why a packet doesn't match a rule. Is there a better way to debug traffic shaper rules? Would pfsense 1.0 be better for this task? Monowall? Something else? We are looking for transparent bridge w/ traffic shaping. Thanks, -Chris --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
