http://www.studio360.org/2011/apr/29/adventures-3d-sound/
"Video: The Science behind 3D sound"
Here, the demonstration works, but this is "180º horizontal surround".
Or should we call this "wide-stereo"?
The recording might be (technically) a binaural recording (actually, it
is :-) ), but this doesn't change the results. The table conference is
just in front of the dummy head < and > testing person.
As there is no significant 3D element and the tester just has to point
to some horizontal position, the question is: why is everybody trying to
call good ol' suround sound "3D audio", nowadays?
:-D
Best,
Stefan
Robert Greene wrote:
I think one has to distinguish here various factors.
First of all, if one subtracts the effects of head movements
on perception and also assumes that the listener is
willing to keep their head absolutely still, then
there would seem to be no problem with producing any
sound one cared to at the entrances to the two ear canals.
This will produce if properly done the effect of headphones,
and as I suppose everyone has experienced, headphones
can indeed produce the effect of a fly buzzing around your head
and so on. (cf the "Oscar" experiments of Sennheiser).
Robert:
I think you are right, in theory. But in practice, there will be
certain artifacts!
The X-talk cancellation itself is not perfect, and it is hard to have
some real "perfect" solution.
The loudspeakers will show phase errors, and different behaviour at
different frequencies. There will be room reflections. The room
reflections will depend on the spacial/directional behaviour of the
loudspeakers. (You will move your head, but you shouldn't. :-) )
I probably forgot a lot of things...
Now, to the practical test:
http://www.studio360.org/2011/apr/29/adventures-3d-sound/
I have listened to the "3D Audio Demonstration for Speakers" on my
laptop, and I can't say there is any real "3D effect" here. There is
some confusing (I am serious!) sound "in front" or "under" me, and
maybe I am at the same time within "something". But nothing comes ever
from "behind" me, and there is nothing whatsoever "up".
The bird in the end is especially interesting, because the position
seems to shift during a frequency shift. (The sound shifts to the
right when the frequency is dropping. This is what I am hearing, so
this might be a subjective test result...)
I would say that this is an interesting demo, but nothing "commercial"
at all. It is also very possible that different people will hear
something quite different here. But if so, this is not any "stable"
sound presentation at all.
Even SRS TruSuround seems to be a lot better than this supposed new
and "super" technology, but maybe I am wrong on this.
I didn't listen to the headphone demo yet, which should be a lot
better. (Well, I hope so.)
Best,
Stefan
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL:
<https://mail.music.vt.edu/mailman/private/sursound/attachments/20110708/3aaa9981/attachment.html>
_______________________________________________
Sursound mailing list
[email protected]
https://mail.music.vt.edu/mailman/listinfo/sursound
