On 9/6/2011 10:15 PM, Greg Hellings wrote:
On Tue, Sep 6, 2011 at 11:01 PM, Chris Little<chris...@crosswire.org> wrote:
The utils tend to choke when you throw data at them in a radically wrong
versification system. Specifically, they'll choke if you give them texts
with extra chapters. Joel only has 3 chapters in the KJV versification,
which you're using, so you get a segfault when you feed imp2vs a Bible with
four chapters in Joel.
Well that explains that phenomenon.
There is a bug somewhere, but fixing the bug still isn't going to make this
the correct versification.
An error message would at least be nice. "Hey, not sure what to do
with this verse."
One of the Catholic versifications is probably the closest we have. I'm not
sure about the "endlessly repeating messages of linking different verses
together." Are they literally endless and repeating the same linkage? That's
not a bug that I know of in any of the tools. (If it's the same verse
repeating, which verse is it? And have you checked that there isn't some
sort of error in the verse numbering in/around that verse?)
I would just like to reiterate - the files are freely available for
anyone to take a look at and test out. This way anyone can see what
is going on and hopefully help come to an informed decision about what
is going on.
http://dl.thehellings.com/SL_FR_BI_PDV.thml.lorem
http://dl.thehellings.com/SL_PG_BI_TPC.thml.lorem
These are the two files in question. I have now uploaded a copy of
the output of this command
$ imp2vs SL_FR_BI_PDV.thml.lorem -4 -o SL_FR_BI_PDV -v Catholic 2>&1>
SL_FR_BI_PDV.thml.lorem.err
to the above location as well for you to check out. It is a 95MB file
that resulted from allowing the above command to run for about 20 or
30 seconds before doing a keyboard break. I'm looking at about 2.25
million lines of output there which start out perfectly normal
from file: Ge 1:1
adding entry: Genesis 1:1 length 240/240
from file: Ge 1:2
adding entry: Genesis 1:2 length 149/149
from file: Ge 1:3
adding entry: Genesis 1:3 length 136/136
...
And then turn into
adding entry: Amos 9:15 length 2159/2159
from file: Ob 1
adding entry: Obadiah 1:1 length 823/823
linking entry: Obadiah 1:2 to Obadiah 1:1
linking entry: Obadiah 1:3 to Obadiah 1:1
linking entry: Obadiah 1:4 to Obadiah 1:1
<snip>
linking entry: Obadiah 1:21 to Obadiah 1:1
from file: Ob 2
adding entry: Obadiah 2:1 length 492/492
linking entry: [ Module Heading ] to Obadiah 2:1
linking entry: [ Testament 1 Heading ] to Obadiah 2:1
linking entry: Genesis 0:0 to Obadiah 2:1
linking entry: Genesis 1:0 to Obadiah 2:1
linking entry: Genesis 1:1 to Obadiah 2:1
linking entry: Genesis 1:2 to Obadiah 2:1
linking entry: Genesis 1:3 to Obadiah 2:1
<snip>
linking entry: Jonah 1:14 to Obadiah 2:1
linking entry: Jonah 1:15 to Obadiah 2:1
linking entry: Jonah 1:16 to Obadiah 2:1
from file: Ob 3
adding entry: Obadiah 3:1 length 465/465
linking entry: [ Module Heading ] to Obadiah 3:1
linking entry: [ Testament 1 Heading ] to Obadiah 3:1
linking entry: Genesis 0:0 to Obadiah 3:1
linking entry: Genesis 1:0 to Obadiah 3:1
linking entry: Genesis 1:1 to Obadiah 3:1
linking entry: Genesis 1:2 to Obadiah 3:1
linking entry: Genesis 1:3 to Obadiah 3:1
<snip>
linking entry: Jonah 2:8 to Obadiah 3:1
linking entry: Jonah 2:9 to Obadiah 3:1
linking entry: Jonah 2:10 to Obadiah 3:1
linking entry: Jonah 2:11 to Obadiah 3:1
from file: Ob 4
adding entry: Obadiah 4:1 length 438/438
linking entry: [ Module Heading ] to Obadiah 4:1
linking entry: [ Testament 1 Heading ] to Obadiah 4:1
linking entry: Genesis 0:0 to Obadiah 4:1
linking entry: Genesis 1:0 to Obadiah 4:1
linking entry: Genesis 1:1 to Obadiah 4:1
And so on. I don't see what's so special about this point in the
module, but maybe someone else can? Again, I encourage you all to
take a look at the files yourself and see if you all can see something
I'm missing.
I would guess that you can fix these issues by adding a chapter number
(1) to all of the verses in books with only one chapter (Obadiah,
Philemon, 2 John, 3 John, & Jude).
--Chris
_______________________________________________
sword-devel mailing list: sword-devel@crosswire.org
http://www.crosswire.org/mailman/listinfo/sword-devel
Instructions to unsubscribe/change your settings at above page
