frédéric gontier wrote: > I love this framework too and in production mode i use only 1.0 version. > I'm really afraid that Symfony could not be the success that it > deserves. > why? because backward compatibility is not supported with different > version of the framework, critic behavior's interface like email or > configuration are changed on every version. Maybe, it would be safe to > slow the releases and trace a stable roadmap for a LTS version. > I think that this discussion is really critic, so i hope that someone > like fabien would react.
I have just answered to the original email. Fabien > > Le mercredi 28 octobre 2009 à 17:23 -0400, Tom Boutell a écrit : > > I understand that support for Symfony 1.2 is supposed to end in > > November with the release of Symfony 1.3. > > > > What practices, if any, in Symfony 1.2 code are expected to be > > incompatible with Symfony 1.3? > > > > I know Symfony 1.3 won't be the huge change that Symfony 1.1/1.2 were. > > But I still don't think it's wise to drop support for practices > > considered valid in 1.2 the moment 1.3 appears. > > > > Other long-established open source projects do not do this on such a > > scale. Valid PHP 5.0.x code runs on PHP 5.3.x, with deprecation > > warnings sometimes, but it runs. And 5.2.x is definitely still being > > actively supported after the release of 5.3.x. > > > > It is very difficult to make responsible proposals to clients without > > ongoing support for at least the previous minor version series for > > Symfony. > > > > I know Symfony 1.2 wasn't supposed to be an LTS release but the > > reality is that it was the first stable-enough-to-use release of > > Symfony since the end of the 1.0.x series, and people have migrated > > long term projects to it out of necessity. I strongly feel it should > > be supported for at least a year after the release of 1.3. > > > > I also think it is appropriate to fix serious bugs like > > http://trac.symfony-project.org/ticket/6937 in the 1.2 series, making > > features work substantially as advertised unless the only possible fix > > is a backwards incompatible change. But I can live without embedded > > M2M relation forms ever working in 1.2. What I find difficult to live > > without is enough stability that the Symfony releases page doesn't > > frighten clients off. > > > > BC breaks in a mature system should be a major-version thing (2.0, not > > 1.0), and there should be ongoing support of the previous major > > version for quite a while when they happen. > > > > I love this framework - please help me sell it to my clients as > > something that will continue to work for at least a year. (: > > > > > --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "symfony developers" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/symfony-devs?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
