Le 09/07/2010 17:59, Richard D Shank a écrit :
On 07/09/2010 07:50 AM, Ekinox wrote:
No, I don't.
We believe that symfony 1.4 is just a little under CakePHP, but
Symfony2 is two kilometers higher. So we had to choose between those
two. Symfony2 is not ready, so subject closed, CakePHP.
Sorry for bringing up a closed subject, but the emails took place over
the course of an hour, and I'm just reading them :).
I have a site I am updating that I started with 1.4 but as soon as we
release this first major update, we are moving everything over to
Symfony2. I say that just as a reference point of where I am coming
from. Since 1.4 is not an option, I won't get into the whys of
deciding to go with 1.4 over Cake. I will speak directly to Symfony2.
If you guys are truly thinking of migrating to S2 after the API
stables, it might be better to go ahead with S2 and make the
incremental changes as it evolves. Then you are doing the migrating
"on the fly" instead of a complete conversion at a later point.
Using, submodule in git for updating S2 and creating branches as you
go, you should be able to keep up with the changes that are happening
on the framework. Just a hint, look at
http://github.com/fabpot/symfony for things that are coming. As far
as stability, I read somewhere (can't remember where, right now),
there is is a S2 site in the wild, doing just fine.
The ORMs are pretty stable at this point. Doctrine2 is my drug of
choice, but it seems that Propel1.5 is also pretty solid and the
changes coming to it are incremental. There are a number of
components that S2 uses that have been released as separate projects
http://components.symfony-project.org/ so those parts of the framework
are pretty stable.
Also, the community is really jumping in behind S2, with 4 patches
submitted in the last week and a site dedicated to S2 Bundles
http://symfony2bundles.org/ (written with S2 and not the site I was
thinking of above). As you can see from the site, there are already a
few bundle being created for S2. Also, if you guys used S2, thats
more eyes looking and contributing to the project :).
>From what you stated above, I don't need to convince you that S2 is
the better choice over Cake. I just want to shed a different light on
things from someone who made the decision to go with S2, over 1.4 and
initially Cake.
Richard
I am sorry, but I informed the project's chief and he decided CakePHP.
So, now, it's too late. We will use CakePHP until the website's release
and the Symfony2's release, and then will migrate the whole website.
Sorry for having disturbed you and thank you for the answers,
Ekinox
--
If you want to report a vulnerability issue on symfony, please send it to
security at symfony-project.com
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google
Groups "symfony users" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
[email protected]
For more options, visit this group at
http://groups.google.com/group/symfony-users?hl=en
