On 8/12/2013 6:55 AM, Lloyd Hilaiel wrote:
Now that some of the other challenging threads have died down, let's have 
another one.

As I think deeply (at least as deeply as I am capable of) about how users will 
log into different firefox products, and how we can really achieve a high level 
of integration, I am reminded just how challenging this problem is.  I'm at the 
point in my meditation where I have distilled things down to a single most 
important question.

What are the cons of reducing the security of recoverable class A data such 
that it could be accessed with a persona assertion asserting ownership of the 
email address stored in your account?

Note:
I realize that we've taken some shortcuts in email verification, and that a 
verified email address in firefox accounts isn't as rigorously verified as one 
in persona.  Ignore that for now.  Think just about the security delta from 
competing products and our current design.

/me braces self
lloyd

This would mean that Mozilla has potentially easier access to the user's data? I've tried to digest but am having a difficult time.

From a product perspective, the overwhelming majority of our users do not care about protecting their data from Mozilla. They trust us. For the few users who do not trust us, we provide user options to store their profile information as class B data, right?

What are the *benefits* to making class A data more easily recoverable?

- A
_______________________________________________
Sync-dev mailing list
[email protected]
https://mail.mozilla.org/listinfo/sync-dev

Reply via email to