On Mon, 2015-03-30 at 17:05 +0900, johnw wrote: > camp_site:restaurant=yes > camp_site:water=yes > camp_site:space_water=no > campsite:kitchen=yes > camp_site:space_bbq=no
John, this model would work fine if the end user was using a interactive tool where he could say "show me all the camps that comply with this list of facilities". But we very quickly identified twenty or so characteristic of a camp and I reckon we could easily extent that to 50 to a 100 if we really tried. So, its not possible to show that on a flat map, even a fairly specialised one. Thats where the idea of identifying a very small set of key characteristics arose. Thats map-able and is a key to a subsequent list of characteristics. So the proposed new keys, camp_site= and camp_type= do not exclude all the other things you mention and others. They could be seen as more a top level filter, that an end user can use to narrow down their search. Its in response to the very wide range of possible camp types you might find. Locally important facilities, tent/van issues, details of pitch facilities and so on are all still usable and should (but not must) still be mapped. David _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
