> How would you tag: > Here are my reformulated answers. Note that the answers do not apply to all countries, and most certainly not to the US, where to my knowledge there are no distinctions between bicycle and pedestrian use of sidewalks and cycleways. More specifically, I believe my replies are correct in Germany and Italy
1) Picture 1 with the blue traffic sign > My answer: highway=path; foot=designated; bicycle=designated; segregated=yes. In addition you may want to specify which side is the footway and which side is the cycleway by lanes=2 and bicycle:lanes=yes|no and foot:lanes=no|yes You may also add colour:lanes=red|grey > 2) Picture 1 without the blue traffic sign > My answer: Anything of the following, depending on context: highway=unclassified/track/pedestrian/cycleway/... But none of foot/bicycle=designated/official/yes > 3) Picture 2 with the blue traffic sign > My answer: exactly as in case (1) for the cycle-and-foot-way and in addition bicycle=use_sidepath on the street > 4) Picture 2 without the blue traffic sign > My answers: Alternative (a) highway=residential sidewalk=both Reason: If there is no sign whatsoever, I would consider both sides as sidewalk (Buergersteig in German). Alternative (b) Use separate ways on both sides of the street with: highway=footway, but none of foot/bicycle=designated/official Without additional signs the paths on both sides of the road are sidewalks (i.e. pedestrian use) In all four cases there are in addition all the other tags like surface=; smoothness=; lit=
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
