W dniu 02.10.2016 18:10, Topographe Fou napisał(a):
To summarize quickly: It says that railway=station should only be a
node (not an shape or a polygon or even an area) and that you should
use landuse=railway and building=* to represent the physical
infrastructure in other objects.
Whatever we think about this page, I agree with you that
railway=station does not imply that it is a building.
I also think that it's just a wiki limitation and area=yes or
landuse=railway tag should not be needed. Does the adding area and
relation as possible choices needs some formal steps or it's just an
edit one could do any time, if nobody here would disagree?
There's also another tagging problem I see: with building=train_station
we're not sure if this building is still used as a station building,
used in a different way - like cafe - or just abandoned? For churches we
have "amenity=place_of_worship", what tag should we use to know a
station building is active in this role?
BTW: the "node-only problem" is more universal, I've seen some other
wiki entries neglecting possibility that we could know object
dimensions. Sooner or later I would refresh them too.
--
"To co ludzie zwą marskością wątroby/ Tak naprawdę jest śmiercią z
tęsknoty" [Afro Kolektyw]
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
