> On Sep 20, 2018, at 3:25 PM, Andy Townsend <ajt1...@gmail.com> wrote: > > Certainly here in the UK many formerly "civic" services have been privatised > and are run for out-and-out commercial gain
Parliament's landuse isn't landuse=retiail, right? You are thinking of *amenities and services* - not buildings and landuses. That's what I am talking about. Mapping shop pins and civic buildings are different. If you live in a town where your city council office is in a mall store front, please feel free to drop a pin on a mall building. But we aren't talking about that. We already have plenty examples of Civic services in commercial / retiail buildings. For example: A DMV "registration reneweal" office in a strip mall is a point on building=retiail, landuse=retail, amenity=shopping_center. You can find post offices and other government services in a store front in a mall (La Mesa, CA post office in Grossmont Center mall, for example off the top of my head). There might be other government admin/services in commercial/ retail office complexes - but that is a commercial building, on a commercial landuse! What about public city hall buildings on dedicated land? Legislative body meeting buildings? What landuse do they get? The Same one as a chip shop? Similarly, almost every large city hall or regional government building in Japan has a convenience store in the basement. They are required to be there, so there is a 3rd party cashier for revenue stamps. It is a tenant in a little 4x5m room in city hall. Our regional city government office has 4 (private) restaurants on the 32nd observation floor. Those are pins on the building too. The convenience store or restaurant is a pin in the city hall building on a civic_admin landuse. A standalone public town hall **building with external amenities that belong to the building**, let alone town hall complex of many Civic buildings should never be on landuse=retiail. Yep, never ever ever on landuse=retiail. Never. Which is why I am proposing Landuse:Civic_admin. Javbw. _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
