Re: [Tagging] change bicycle_parking=floor to surface

[pangose]

>
>I don't think the solution of using surface will do.
>
>
>surface=paved says nothing about if the bicycle can be secured and what
>too.
>
>Nor does it say anything about how the bike is held.
>
>
>The bicycle_parking key is used for lots of things...
>
>buildings/sheds
>
>stands/racks
>
>A very poor key!
>
>
>I think the key should be replaced.

I agree. It is a bad idea to lump different concepts in one key.

>
>
>Buildings and sheds already have a key building=* so those values can
>be 
>depreciated.
>
>
>Stands/racks are all indications of how the bike is held while parked.
>
>bicycle_holding=stand/rack/bollard/post/* ?

I like this. 

>
>
>Then the issue of securing the bicycle?
>
>bicycle_secure=lock,supervised,provided_lock,*

Could you elaborate what each of these mean?

I think bicycle_security is better

_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
Tagging@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging