Às 17:16 de 10/06/2020, Jack Armstrong escreveu:
From: Clifford Snow
To help me understand, below are three schemes for crossings.
Which one(s) best describe your suggested way of mapping.
1. Tagging both the crossing and a node on the highway.
https://mycloud.snowandsnow.us/index.php/s/YEFoYcTgR2gtW3j
2. With no crossing ways, just a node on the highway to mark the
type of crossing
https://mycloud.snowandsnow.us/index.php/s/4ad5wLzMNcE3sNo
3. With just crossing ways and no node at the intersection of the
crossing and highway.
https://mycloud.snowandsnow.us/index.php/s/tHF62pH5txPEX55
Well, since you asked, as to my own personal preference,
#1 is not my preference. Crossing tags are placed on the way and on a
node for a single pedestrian crosswalk. I feel this violates OSM's
"one feature, one OSM element" rule.
#2 seems acceptable, but it's not my personal preference. (Again, I
started this thread not in order to express my preferences, simply to
have the wiki compliant with approved OSM canon)
#3 has no connecting node between the two ways represented by the red
dot? This would not be correct. There should be a connecting node.
This is an example of how I prefer to map pedestrian crossings (this
is common throughout downtown Denver):
https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit#map=21/39.72565/-104.98501
Here are two methods I mapped as a demonstration of mapping that I
feel is correct, as well. Mapped here are two different methods that
seem reasonable, tagging either the connecting node or tagging the
way; but not tagging both the node and the way. Tagging both the node
and the way would seem to violate the "one feature, one OSM element"
rule.
https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit#map=21/39.71293/-104.98038
Cheers
Jack Armstrong
(chachafish)
Using footway=sidewalk on a highway crossing is not a legit way of
mapping this. You can not substitute something that seems wrong for a
certainly wrong tag.
I understand your issue, as I always had the same problem about
footway=crossing, and that's why I only use it when creating routable
ways for pedestrians, but unless you can convince routing software to
recognize a highway=crossing point as a crossover to pedestrians (with
out a line) I don't see how this can be undone.
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
