Thanks Mateuz, That is helpful.
On 16 November 2019 7:27:47 pm AEDT, Mateusz Konieczny <[email protected]> wrote: >Note that CC 4.0 is not significantly helpful, without special waiver >it is also incompatible with ODBL >See https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/ODbL_Compatibility > >AFAIK: > >(1) planning survey may be done based on even fully copyrighted data >without trouble >(2) data incompatible with ODBL is by definition incompatible with ODBL > >Creating notes based on a copyrighted source sounds OK (I am not a >lawyer!) >as long as people will not use them more than for planning survey. >Note that confirming note to be true is not sufficient. > >I would suggest notes in form >"according to an official source on licence incompatible with OSM there >is a new speed limit here since X" >to ensure that somebody will not copy copyrighted data by accident or >due lack of understanding. > >Or getting needed waiver, what would make data ODBL compatible. > >15 Nov 2019, 21:26 by [email protected]: > >> I have since signed up to the service. >> Clicking on the link in the email takes me to a page on the website, >which is explicitly CC 4.0. I suspect this means it is OK to manually >add a note or FIXME requesting resurvey. >> >> I don't think that should cause trouble with the ODBL, because you're >not importing the data. >> >> (Open to correction here) >> >> Regards, >> David Wales >> >> On 14 November 2019 5:15:07 am AEDT, David Wales ><[email protected]> wrote: >> >>> A relevant paragraph from the terms of use: >>> >>> "The Service is intended for personal use only. You must not use it >for business purposes or re-supply the information to others." >>> >>> This seems at odds with the CC 4.0 license which the website itself >is under! >>> >>> I suspect you would need to either track down the original data >source behind the emails, or you would need to contact Transport for >NSW to get permission. >>> >>> Regards, >>> David >>> >>> >>> >>> On 13 November 2019 10:21:58 pm AEDT, Luke Stewart ><[email protected]> wrote: >>> >>>> In case you were not aware, there is a bi-monthly service from the >NSW government advising when and where new speed limits have been >introduced across the state, allowing us to keep our maxspeeds up to >date. >>>> >>>> https://www.saferroadsnsw.com.au/emailupdates.aspx >>>> >>>> I was considering adding a note to the locations that have been >changed each time the email is sent, but would this count as adding >non-copyrighted data, even though it would only request a resurvey? >>>> >>>> Interested to hear your thoughts, >>>> Luke >>>>
_______________________________________________ Talk-au mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au
