On 18/1/20 7:15 pm, Sebastian S. wrote:
I think the discussion regarding damaged is good, however I feel that
this is a too fine grained quality for mapping from satellite images.
I would use ruined. Ruined can be fully destroyed or partially.
Ruined to me would be beyond economic recovery.
If damaged my next question would be how much? A little? Very
subjective to quantify.
Damaged would be cheaper to repair rather than rebuild.
And yes there will be some that are hard to judge.
But a large number can easily be place into one category or the other.
Where it is hard to judge I'd be conservative and go for ruined.
Already have hard to determine ruined or destroyed, so I think damaged
is far easier to determine.
On 18 January 2020 9:34:58 am AEDT, Warin <[email protected]> wrote:
On 17/1/20 10:08 pm, Mateusz Konieczny wrote:
17 Jan 2020, 11:42 by [email protected]:
I'm all for using the lifecycle prefix,
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Lifecycle_prefix. I
agreed that if there's still remains there use ruined or
destroyed, not sure what the difference is though.
ruined implies that ruins still remain, destroyed may mean that
or that there is no trace at all
in practice difference is minor if any
Most of these will still have foundations in place, they may not
be fit for reuse but they are there. Some fire places and chimneys
too remain.
I'll use ruined. Unless there are other ideas?
If there is no trace at all then 'razed' could be a better word. Of
course there will be those that say OSM should not have that, but it
does avoid some one adding it from old imagery.
Once it's been cleared you could use demolished, removed or
raised
Probably razed, not raised. I see not real difference.
, again not sure what the difference is. While damaged is not
documented it seems the perfect fit since there is no other
suitable tag for this on the wiki.
damaged seems to me a poor fit as prefix, damaged building is
still a building,
and I would expect building=something tag to be used.
By damaged I mean part of the building is intact but another part
has been damaged .. e.g. a truck has run part way through the
building.
_______________________________________________
Talk-au mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au
