On 1/8/22 13:04, Graeme Fitzpatrick wrote:
On Tue, 26 Jul 2022 at 17:31, Warin <[email protected]> wrote:
I have a similar difficulty with club=surf_life_saving,
emergency=lifesaver, lifesaver=base ... as that does not render.
If put
on the building then the name of the club renders.. Having gone
along the coast of NSW and put them to nodes and entered a few
more off the DCS Base Map .. I am now going along and setting the
details on the associated building... sigh.
Warin & I have discussed this topic recently on a changeset:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/123785819, & are sort of in
two minds about it, so it's probably a good idea to put it out to get
everybody's thoughts.
I've recently finished tidying up & adding details right along the GC
beaches, including all the Surf Clubs.
As most of you would know, Surf Clubs & SLSCs are, more or less, two
separate things - the Surf Club is the social side of things, which
houses the bar, restaurant & Gaming Room, is usually open to the
public, seven days/week, from morning till late at night, & is usually
upstairs in the building.
The actual SLSC / lifesavers are downstairs in that building, where
the First Aid room is located, are usually only present Sa-Su 8-18
between Sept - April. They will frequently have a different contact
number / website/page to the Surf Club.
I have been tagging them like so:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/41751839, as a building named "xxx
Surf Club", tagged as a club= surf_life_saving; together with a
separate node for the SLSC:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/5419450227, named "xxx SLSC",
tagged as emergency=lifeguard + lifeguard=base + leisure=sports_centre
(which I know is certainly not great, but is the only way I can find
to render the name as lifeguard doesn't render :-(), together with
their operating hours & contact details.
So, what do we all think is the best option for having, & showing, 2
lots of info for the same premises?
That particular premises carries the name "Tugun SLSC" across the top of
the building as can be seen on their website http://www.tugunslsc.com.au/
The name "Tugun Surf Club" appears on
http://www.tugunslsc.com.au/bar-gaming/, but the URL says tugunslsc and
the banner at the top of the page says "Tugun Surf Life Saving Club".
I am of the view that the "Tugun Surf Club" is a simple shortening of
the "Tugun Surf Life Saving Club".
-------------------------------
The reason for placing the 'life saving' aspect on the building is one
of rendering .. it gets the SLSC name to appear.
The bisatro cold be entered as a simple node with amenity=restaurant ,
this does render, see http://www.tugunslsc.com.au/bistro/ for contact
details.. note no "Tugun Surf Club" appears here
The bar could be entered as amenity=licensed_club .. does not render.
The gambling as amenity = gambling, I don't know if this renders I
suspect not.
The email addresses are all @tugunslsc.com.au and they all share a
common phone number.. thus I think they are not 2, 3 or 4 separate
'clubs' but one club with a few features. Much like a bowls club, an
RSL, a golf club .. etc etc.
_______________________________________________
Talk-au mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au
