We are thankfull for your corrections but we want to make clear that this is NOT an automated import tool, it is a HELP tool to improve the information. These fixme are put in order to OBLIGATE the local mapper that is ussing the tool to correct the mistakes BEFORE upload.
WE INSIST, THIS IS NOT AN AUTOMATIC IMPORT TOOL. [sorry for the upper case, but it seems that it is easily forgot...]. We aswer below. > I see lots of FIXME keys, and also FIXME values on that page. I don't > think that there's much merit in automatically adding fixme tags. For > things like "landuse=commercial, office=fixme" then the lack of an > office tag will be picked up by QA tools. This is exactly the objetive of these tags. > As for particular sections: > > * Commercial - (C) - I would find it unusual to see both a landuse and > shop tags on a particular feature - if it's a shop, then the landuse > tag is either redundant, or I would expect to find it on a separate > way surrounding a group of shops. > * shop=pharmacy should be amenity=pharmacy Perfect, we will change that. > * Turismo - (G) - "amenity=cafe, forks=4" I have no idea what forks=4 > means, but looking at hotels I think it's some sort of award rating. > An alternative key should be used, unless the cafe has only 4 items of > cutlery! This is what the spanish comunity have agreed. In Spain the Restaurant awars are "tenedores" (forks). Is you think that it would be better to put "stars" we can change this but it would collide with the Michelin "stars". Or you suggest using something like "cafe:awards" or similar? > * tourism=apartments, category=1 - again, a better key for the > "category" is needed. In Spain apartmens have a "Llave" (key) as a category. We have the same question, it is better to have a "key" tag, a "category" tag or use the "stars" tag (same as hotels)? > * Deportivo (K) - landuse=sports - that's not an in-use value for > landuse, so I wouldn't use it. Ok, we will change it for leisure=sport_centre. > * Oficinas (O) - similar to the commercial section, I wouldn't add > landuse tags to individual offices. Additionally, landuse=health isn't > a recognised tag Perfect, we will change that. > * Sanidad, beneficiencia y otros (Y) - I don't know what is meant by > "medical_system:western=yes", I'd suggest not using it > * "health_facility:type=clinic" - this just duplicates the information > in the amenity=clinic tag, so should be removed > * "landuse=health, health_facility:type=dispensary" - I suspect this > is better tagged with amenity=pharmacy, dispensing=yes > * health_facility:type=hospital - that just duplicates the > amenity=hospital tag, so should be removed Perfect, this is what local mapper have thought would be best, but reading you comments we think that your suggestion make sense. > * office=labor_union - we use en_gb spellings, so office=labour_union please OK > * landuse=farmyard, building=livestock - I'd say it's either a > building or an area of farmyard, but not both. See landuse vs office, > above Perfect. > Cheers, > Andy We will change that tags ASAP in the wiki and in the tool. Thankyou. -- Cruz Enrique Borges Hernández Email: [email protected] DeustoTech Energy Telefono: 944139000 ext.2052 Avda. Universidades, 24 48007 Bilbao, Spain _______________________________________________ Talk-es mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-es
