On 21/07/09 16:39, Mark Williams wrote: > My 2p; > > He has been very active around "my" area and I have had to put in some > work righting wrongs; there are more out there than I have fixed& I > believe the original was better than the fixed version in some cases. > Although some of my time has gone into re-edits, I would prefer to see > him reverted completely. If I lose an occasional addition, it will be > worth it. > > If he's a bored teenager in London, there's a Dartford mapping party > coming up next weekend; I'll even offer a lift&/or mentoring! It's the > summer holidays now so if he likes b*ggering about in OSM, the next 6 > weeks could be problematic! If he's not interested in being > constructive, +1 for a ban. > I wonder if some kind of soft ban might be a good way to deal with this. The idea being that the next time the user logs in they are presented with a message to the extent that there has been some concern over their edits, with some kind of explanation of what they have done and a offer of assistance. And a warning that further unwarranted edits might lead to further action and an Agree and Continue button.
If further edits are still not productive then we would have a clear audit of a warning being issues and assistance being offered. Cheers Chris _______________________________________________ Talk-GB mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb
