Robert Scott <li...@...> writes:

>>With all this talk of changing street names, can i just remind you to make 
>>sure
>>that if you are changing street names that there are no addresses liked to 
>>that
>>street.

>Perhaps this is the job of some other analysis tool that simply checks a nearby
>same-named highway exists for every stated addr:street.

Yes, this would be a good idea.  I'm not aware of any tool that does it;
Geofabrik's OSM Inspector has a 'street not found' check for addresses but I
believe this just flags where no addr:street tag exists.

In practice, where differences arise between OS and OSM data and it is necessary
to change OSM, this is in areas without addresses.  The more thoroughly-mapped
parts of OSM have higher data quality and tend to reconcile cleanly with OS.
It's also unlikely that anybody would manage to get the wrong street name
repeatedly, both for the street and for buildings along it; and if I did happen
to see such a case, I'd assume that the extra address data gives more chance 
that
OSM is correct and OS is wrong.

(The above generalization is based on central and north London - other parts of
the country may have different data quality in both OS and OSM data sets.)

-- 
Ed Avis <[email protected]>


_______________________________________________
Talk-GB mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb

Reply via email to