+1 On Aug 10, 2009, at 6:51 AM, Nick Whitelegg wrote:
> I'll say what I always say these days whenever this subject comes > up :-) > > That is, I believe the "highway" tag should represent the physical > surface, not the rights. My current views on this are: > > highway=track - a dirt/stone track, theoretically usable for off road > vehicles (though not necessarily any legal right) > highway=path - a narrow path, typically with mud/stone surface > highway=path; surface=paved - a concrete path typically used in urban > areas, what most people are using "footway" for > > Then, the actual rights should be defines using foot, horse, etc. > foot=yes > has more or less become unusable, as different people mean different > things, so therefore foot should be no, private, permissive (use > granted > by landowner) or designated (a legal right, such as a UK public > footpath, > or - though my knowledge of German or Swiss law on rights of way is > not > good - waymarked paths in Germany or Switzerland such as the "yellow > diamond" routes in the Schwarzwald or the red/white waymarked mountain > paths in Switzerland). > > As an alternative to foot/horse etc one could use the "designation" > tag > such as designation=public_footpath or public_bridleway, > designation=cycleway for an official cycleway, or (at a guess for > Switzerland, I may be wrong) "gelb", "rot/weiss" and "blau/weiss" > for the > different types of path with different difficulties. > > Things like highway=bridleway or cycleway I would prefer to see > deprecated, and replaced by path/track with surface/bicycle/horse > tags, > though I still tag with them as that is the generally-accepted way of > tagging bridleways and cycleways. > > Nick > > _______________________________________________ > talk mailing list > [email protected] > http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk _______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

