On Sun, Sep 20, 2009 at 10:27 AM, John Smith <[email protected]>wrote:
> 2009/9/21 Anthony <[email protected]>: > > > So this is a single way? > > > http://bikelaneblog.files.wordpress.com/2008/02/pulaski-bridge-walkway.jpg?w=324&h=241 > > > > That's nutty. > > And abusing relations to do the same thing isn't? > Irrelevant. I never said you had to use relations. In fact, I said you don't. I wouldn't call the use of relations "nutty", though. > As long as you are free to change lanes, I disagree. The maxheight of a > way > > is the maximum height of the way. Using a GPS doesn't permit you to > ignore > > signs which say to stay out of the right lane. > > You miss the point entirely, the GPS could indicate which lane you > need to be in if you program it with your current height. > Fine. You can add "maximum height" along with "maximum speed" to your list of lane-specific data. I don't find it very important, but if you want to allow for this, without messing up anyone else, feel free. > > Have you ever been on a bridge with a Jersey barrier? Is that one > bridge, > > or two? > > Ever been on a bridge with dynamic lane changes depending on time of day? > Yes. > Maybe the last one. Anything else, is "physically separated", but could > > easily be accomplished over a single bridge (one of them even *is* an > > example of a single bridge). > > Do you even grasp the benefit of being able to tag lanes rather than ways? > Yes, I do. Have you read what I said? > Pretty much all the examples you posted are exactly why we need to be > able to tag lanes, thanks for proving my point for me. > So you think those examples should all be represented as a single way? That's horrible. > You keep saying you can tag a way with the maximum maxspeed but that's > nonsense, that isn't being able to tag the real world accurately > that's tagging a subset of the real world. > The maximum speed of a way is the maximum speed of that way. If you want to *also* tag lane speeds, feel free. http://bikelaneblog.files.wordpress.com/2008/02/pulaski-bridge-walkway.jpg?w=324&h=241 One bridge or two? If it's one, then you are off-topic.
_______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
