There are a lot of different views on tagging and correctness. Some
common views I have seen:
* What is in the wiki is law.
* What renders in (pick your renderer) is law
* Try to follow the data that exists
* Anything goes
The wiki answer to your question (which apply to pitch and which is sport):
http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Pitch
doesn't list pitch:baseball which I believe supports the
leisure:pitch,sport:baseball model. (pitch is actually a value, not a key)
If you look at the data (many sources such as OSMDoc and
http://www.gamesforlittletimmy.com/TagStats_100811.txt.gz), sport =
<value> is common:
Total,
nodes, ways, relations
1 sport = soccer (
41975, 7748, 34209, 18)
2 sport = tennis (
28917, 2962, 25932, 23)
3 sport = multi (
12466, 2036, 10407, 23)
4 sport = swimming (
11921, 4829, 7080, 12)
5 sport = baseball (
8454, 1014, 7432, 8)
And you would be one of the first people to use pitch = baseball.
I would go with leisure:pitch,sport:baseball
John
On 64-07-22 11:59 AM, Eric Jarvies wrote:
Hello,
I would like to start adding the spanish names to the points/ways I enter, but
need further clarification as to the correct way.
Is this how to tag them?;
name:English Name
name:es:Español
Or do I need to do this:
name:English Name
name:es
es:Español
Another question.... regarding pitch, which of these apply?:
9pin
10pin
american_football
archery, athletics
baseball, basketball
beachvolleyball
bmx
boules
bowls
canoe
chess
climbing
cricket
cricket_nets
croquet
cycling
diving
dog_racing
equestrian
golf
gymnastics
hockey
horseshoes
horse_racing
ice_stock
motor, multi
orienteering
paddle_tennis
paragliding
pelota
racquet
rowing
shooting
skating
skateboard
skiing
soccer
swimming
table_tennis
team_handball
tennis
toboggan
volleyball
water_ski
And which is the correct one:
Is it?:
leisure:pitch
pitch:baseball
or is it?:
leisure:pitch
sport:baseball
Thank you,
Eric
ps- should this type of question be posted here or in the tagging list?
_______________________________________________
talk mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
