On 20 February 2011 21:03, Felix Hartmann <[email protected]> wrote:
> > Just show me some neighboring countries where the one with imports some > time ago (minimum 1 year) are doing better than neighboring > countries/regions where no imports took place. > > Dear Felix, Take a look at Argentina, Bolivia, Chile and Peru. As long as I know, the Argentinians, Bolivians, and Peruvians haven't done any massive importation processes, here in Chile we have done the aforementioned imports, including all the suburban highways, from the dataset liberated by the Government a couple of years ago (Late 2008). Buenos Aires, Argentina (pop. ~13,300,000): http://osm.org/go/Mnx6Foy- La Paz, Bolivia (pop. ~2,300,000): http://osm.org/go/NOrAkUe Santiago, Chile (pop. ~6,000,000): http://osm.org/go/MaK0TCh-- Lima, Peru (pop. ~8,000,000): http://osm.org/go/NNZb1om-- -------------- Cordoba, Argentina (pop. ~1,300,000): http://osm.org/go/Mw0zkmc-- San Cruz de la Sierra, Bolivia (pop. ~1,800,000): http://osm.org/go/Nh5HGa1 Gran Valparaíso, Chile (pop. ~900,000): http://osm.org/go/MaMIW4o-- Arequipa, Peru (pop. ~750,000): http://osm.org/go/NOJMR7ao- ------------- San Luis, Argentina (pop. ~153,000): http://osm.org/go/MwDmIDt Sucre, Bolivia (pop. ~225,000): http://osm.org/go/NhLWxEgE- Chillan, Chile (pop. ~170,000): http://osm.org/go/MOXe09B Huancayo, Peru (pop. ~323,000): http://osm.org/go/NNzRJz5A- It is difficult to compare cities in terms of size, since the population numbers for the four countries are so different (40,000,000 people; 11,000,000 people; 17,000,000 people; and 30,000,000 people respectively), and the same applies to their cities, but I have tried to put cities of similar importance in each section. One thing is clear, until now, bigger populations (at city or country level) do not necessarily mean better mapping and/or coverage, at least in the southern half of South America. In my opinion quality and coverage totally depend in a combination of variables, including compromise of the current and future mappers, economic elements (money/free_time/etc.), geographic elements (shape of the country, distribution of highways, topography, etc.), climatic elements (snow, ice, tropical or seasonal rains, the driest desert in the world, etc.), _and_ public datasets availability. Until now I have not taken into consideration for this comparison the suburban highways (by far our biggest import process). But just take a look into this area of southern Chile: http://osm.org/go/MOB8D1 and compare it with any suburban area of the surrounding countries. This is, at least in part, thanks to the massive import process that we did years ago, it was the kick start for many towns and cities (at the beginning, in many places, we only had the suburban highways around them and a blank space to fill and connect), and not only for those towns and cities, but for the improvement and completion of the same suburban highways (they didn't include any kind of "elaborate" highway interchange with the mayor motorways, and we have been investing time adding and perfecting those during these years). Cheers, Julio Costa Zambelli OpenStreetMap Chile [email protected] http://www.openstreetmap.cl/ Cel: +56(9)89981083 Postal: Casilla 9002, Correo 3, Viña del Mar, Chile
_______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
