Greetings.

As a pixel dabbler myself, I cannot help but voice a few comments on
the new glyphs.

1. They are not intuitive.

  - the "message with a reply" icon is now "envelope with a green
  stripe", no longer an "envelope with a reply arrow". Intuitiveness
  gone.

  - addressbook entry icons, previously "card files", now are BeOS
  "little gray man" ripoffs. They're no longer intuitive to think of
  as database entries or business cards, which the previous ones were.
  - addressbok search icons, however, still seem to search for the old
  style cards! Consequence, anyone?

  - "delete and next", "delete and prev" - these ones never used to,
  and still aren't intuitive. Deletion is thought of in terms of
  trashcans, X marks, scissors, vanishing... not "red envelopes". Red
  envelopes are for high priority! So in my feel, an icon with an
  envelope and a red one behind it, means "move to next/prev
  important".

2. They are inconsistent with the old and familiar looks of v1.

  - all icons have been changed, but the open/closed address books
  have remained..? They were consistent with the old "plastic" look.
  With the new one, they stand off.

3. They are simply badly done

  - the little "column header" icons are off-centre: the [P], the
  little red flag, and the little envelope, are all off.

  - the blue and red (!?) magnifying glass icons for searching have a
  dark gray border which makes them appear as horribly blurred


RIT guys... Please either send them back to the Czech guy who did them
for repairs, or get the good ol' ones back in TB! as the default...
These ones are simply worse, hands down. And no, I'm not saying this
from an "old = better" perspective :)

-- 
 |\  /|      \~~~/     \~~~/   WWW: http://none :(
 | \/ |  /\   > <  \~/  > <    E-M: maxxx[at]rpg.pl
 |____| /__\ /___\ /_\ /___\   ICQ: 3146019
Aibohphobia - fear of palindromes   


Flyin' high with The Bat! v2.00
over the swamps of Windows 2000 5.0 build 2195 Service Pack 4


________________________________________________________
 Current beta is 2.00 | "Using TBBETA" information:
http://www.silverstones.com/thebat/TBUDLInfo.html

Reply via email to