Hello Thomas Fernandez,

Responding  to  your  article  on  Friday, July 28, 2000 at 11:59:12 GMT
+0800 (which was 28/07/2000 10:59 GMT +0700 my Local Time) :

TF> we  have  two members on this list (Alex being one) who have a comma
TF> in their real name. what TB does, it will take the first part, up to
TF> the comma, as one recipient and the rest as a second recipient.

TF> With  our  recent  discussion about default domains, I would like to
TF> suggest  that  TB does check at least whether a recipient is a valid
TF> email address. What happened last time when I hit reply, is that the
TF> SMTP  server  added  its  own  domain  as  default to the first part
TF> (before  the  comma).  Since  the  message  didn't  bounce, somebody
TF> received my posting who has no business receiveing my messages.

IMHO, TB! already doing right, by putting double quote ( "") between his
Real Name Part. That way makes MTA not misintepretation.

Couple month ago, my MTA also having this problem, but our MTA Developer
already fixed this.
AFAIK,  most  Exchange  and AOL user using this (allow comma within Real
Name Part), but as far as all within quote mark, no problem. Same happen
for "[ ]" mark as Jamie's Real Name part, cause problem for some MTA.

TF> Therefore, I would like TB to check whether an incompelte address is a
TF> nickname, and if not: either dispaly an error message "not a valid
TF> email address" or allow default domains (but I tend to opt for the
TF> error messsage).

TF> What do you think?

In  regard to incomplete address (without @domain part), I tend to agree
that  we can set "default domain" per account setting basis (some mailer
can do this).

-- 
Best regards,

- Syafril -

************************************************************************
Name  : Syafril Hermansyah          |Company: Duta Integrasi Pratama 
Mailto: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>     |Voice  : (62) (21) 385-1600  
FAXto : (62)(21)351-9241 key:000FAX |URL    : <http://www.dutaint.co.id>
************************************************************************

Using The Bat! 1.45 S/MIME
under Windows NT 5.0 Build 2195 

Created : Friday, July 28, 2000, 14:38:17 GMT +0700

-- 
--------------------------------------------------------------
View the TBUDL archive at http://tbudl.thebat.dutaint.com
To send a message to the list moderation team double click here:
   <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To Unsubscribe from TBUDL, double click here and send the message:
   <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
--------------------------------------------------------------

You are subscribed as : [email protected]


Reply via email to